Found December 09, 2012 on Waiting For Next Year:
PLAYERS: Pat Shurmur
TEAMS: Cleveland Browns
Nothing irritate me more than poor game management. It’s inexcusable. Any 12 year old kid who plays Madden knows when to go for the 2-point conversion and how to use timeouts at the end of a game. A kid in his basement, chugging mountain dews, and stuffing his face with pizza doesn’t think twice before going for two when going up 15-10 in the 4th quarter against Philadelphia, or when going up 19-14 late in the 3rd quarter against Pittsburgh. Luckily the second decision didn’t come back to bite the Brownies, but the fact that Shurmur isn’t learning from these mistakes is what worries me. If only Shurmur could type in “2 point conversion chart” into Google, and find a magical chart that tells you when you should and when you shouldn’t go for two. Oh wait? These charts do exist? And every decent football coach from Dillan, TX to Hudson, OH uses it? Hmm… Why would Pat ignore such widely accepted principles? Maybe he’s not. Let’s start with the Eagles game, according to the chart if you are up 5 with approximately 15 minutes to play, you go for two as long as you believe you have a greater than a 24% chance of converting. Pat must have believed his offense had less than a one in four shot of converting. The chart shown below, computed using the footballcommentary.com Dynamic Programming Model, is intended to provide guidance on when to attempt a two-point conversion. That logic makes complete sense. I mean two yards is a long distance. I’ts approximately how tall Shurmur is himself. Pat knows how hard those two yards are to come by and did the safe thing of kicking the point after. I could see how his decision may have been different if the Browns’ average play goes over 5 yards and average run is over 3 yards or something like that. Ohhhh wait, 2 yards is practically nothing. That’s right. Not to mention if you kick the extra point, Philly needs a touchdown to beat you. Wait they still need a touchdown even if we’re up five? Well what about Pittsburgh? Up five with 20 minutes to play. The chart says we would need to be more than 30% confident in our offense or else we should kick it. Almost an identical situation to the Philly game, in which Shurmur got burned for not trying for two, and good ol’ Pat does the same thing, and kicks once again. And once again the Browns found themselves on defense with a six point lead as the game concluded. This time the defense held, but the point is the Browns shouldn’t have been up six in this game or the Philly game. Go for two, if you get it you’re up seven and can’t lose, and if you fail then you’re up five and no worse off than being up six. It baffles me that an NFL head coach doesn’t know these things. Pat continued to audition himself as a game managing consultant last Sunday in Oakland. After receiving a horrible spot on a 3rd and 1 quarterback sneak, up 13-10, with 5 minutes left, Shurmur decides to call a timeout. As soon as he calls timeout, he no longer can challenge the play since this was the Browns’ final timeout. Maybe Shurmur just wanted to be sure he had time to think about 4th and inches and what the team should do. That’s  fine, I get that. Except if Shurmur throws the challenge flag, you can take the review time to think about 4th down, ANDyou might even win the challenge and get a first down! It’s like wanting to order two different sauces for chicken wings, but you just order the one. Then they tell you can have both if you want but you tell them no thanks I’ll settle for just the one. Shurmur could have had his timeout to think about the situation AND could have had the refs review the bad spot, but Pat said no thanks, I’ll just take spicy garlic. I understand you don’t know what these coaches go through until you strap a headset on and walk the sidelines yourself. I’m guessing Shurmur isn’t quite as comfortable on Sundays as little Mikey talking smack on Xbox Live as his mom brings him snacks and drinks. But the decisions Mikey faces while playing Madden simulate the real decisions coaches make every Sunday. When do I punt? When do I kick? Onside kick? Should we go for 2? When should we take the timeout? Is it worth a challenge? These are questions that coaches like Belichick, Tomlin, and the Harbaughs have memorized the answers to. Those men don’t hesitate. They’ve done their homework, they know how to play the game, and they execute their plan. For the Browns to go to the next level as a team, they need to be led by a man who is ready to take them there.  Whether it’s Pat Shurmur, John Gruden, or Little Mikey the Madden guru in his mom’s basement, Jimmy Haslam must make sure he has the man who will give the Browns an edge over their opponents, not a handicap. Pat Shurmur has had 28 games to make his case, but none will leave a more lasting impression than these next four. Sharpen up Pat, I hear little Mikey is free on Sundays.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Reports continue to link Nick Saban to the Cleveland Browns

Greg A. Bedard of the Boston Globe reported NFL Network’s Michael Lombardi could become the next general manager of the Cleveland Browns if Jimmy Haslam and CEO Joe Banner decide to switch from Tom Heckert this season. The report also stated Heckert may force his way out if Banner assumes the personnel controls like he did as president of the Philadelphia Eagles. Lombardi...

Gordon has serious shot at 1000 yard year

Rookie Browns receiver Josh Gordon, a.k.a. Gordo, is having one of the best rookie seasons in Browns history with 34 catches, 646 yards, and 5 touchdowns. With four games remaining, Gordo needs to average 89 receiving yards per game to hit the millennium mark. Time after time this year, Gordon has blazed 1  by the defense to haul in a Weeden bomb for a long gain. His big play ability...

Rookies playing a huge role in Browns' streak

BEREA A big reason the Browns won their third game win in a row was due to the contributions of rookies. Pat Shurmur was asked if it was the confidence theyve gained or the opportunity to show their skill set. Its probably a combination of both, Shurmur said. When they have the confidence and opportunity and when those two meet they have the chance (to make plays). There was probably...

Browns handle Chiefs easily, 30-7

That's three in a row for the Cleveland Browns, as they beat the Kansas City Chiefs 30-7, highlighted by rookie Travis Benjamin's 93-yard punt-return for a TD. The win makes it one more win than last season's total record. It also marks their longest winning streak since 2009. Cleveland QB Brandon Weeden went 17/30, 217 YDS, but without a TD pass, instead handing...

Browns continue surge with win

The Browns are finally streaking in a positive direction. Rookie Travis Benjamin's electrifying 93-yard punt return touchdown gave Cleveland momentum and the Browns won their third straight game, 30-7 over the emotionally drained Kansas City Chiefs on Sunday. Benjamin's game-changing runback helped the Browns (5-8) continue their resurgence under second-year coach Pat Shurmur...

Browns beat Chiefs for 3rd straight win

CLEVELAND (AP) -- The Browns are finally streaking in a positive direction. Rookie Travis Benjamin's electrifying 93-yard punt return touchdown gave Cleveland momentum and the Browns won their third straight game, 30-7 over the emotionally drained Kansas City Chiefs on Sunday. Benjamin's game-changing runback helped the Browns (5-8) continue their resurgence under second...

Quinn vs. Weeden: Jaws’ 29th and 30th ranked QB’s

ESPN’s Ron Jaworski has Chief’s Brady Quinn and Browns Brandon Weeden ranked 29th and 30th of his quarterback rankings. Both Quinn and Weeden are coming off career days in which Weeden threw for 364 yards and Quinn completed 19 of 23 for 201 yards and a touchdown.

Browns 30, Chiefs 7

Rookie Travis Benjamin's electrifying 93-yard punt return touchdown gave Cleveland momentum and the Browns won their third straight game, 30-7 over the emotionally drained Kansas City Chiefs on Sunday. Benjamin's game-changing runback helped the Browns (5-8) continue their resurgence under second-year coach Pat Shurmur, whose future in Cleveland remains uncertain. The Browns...

Shurmur: 'I'm not worried about saving my job'

(Eds: Updates. With AP Photos.) By TOM WITHERS AP Sports Writer The Browns are still mathematically alive in the AFC playoff hunt. It's a long shot, but they haven't been eliminated with three games remaining. And with every win, Pat Shurmur's odds of returning as Cleveland's coach improve. With his team riding a three-game winning streak - the Browns' longest...

What we think will happen today vs. the Chiefs

Cleveland Browns vs. Kansas City Chiefs (Week 14) December 9, 2012 Brian  Browns 27 Chiefs 6 Sometimes crazy ex-girlfriends win the battle. I'm thinking the Chiefs will wake up with their pet bunny in the crock-pot. Tom  Browns 24 Chiefs 14 Browns win an uneventful game, meaning they keep...
Browns News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.