Found May 28, 2012 on 60 Max Power O:

Yesterday, we looked at the wide receivers and tight ends throughout the division, and corrected a couple errors that I made in misclassifying a receiver or two for Green Bay. Tonight, we'll turn our attention to the running backs and fullbacks.

Bears
2011:
Matt Forte, Marion Barber, Kahlil Bell, Armando Allen / Tyler Clutts, Kyle Adams
2012: Matt Forte, Michael Bush, Kahlil Bell, Armando Allen / Tyler Clutts, Kyle Adams

Obviously this is presuming the signing of Matt Forte to either his franchise tender or some other deal, but even without that, Michael Bush is still a solid back, at this point a better version of Marion Barber with much less mileage. Bell performed pretty well when called upon, and Armando Allen also played well for a fourth running back. And, well, we know what Matt Forte is. Clutts displayed some decent blocking ability and the occasional soft hands, especially for an undrafted player in 2008.

Lions
2011:
Mikel Leshoure (injured), Jahvid Best (injured), Kevin Smith, Keiland Williams, Maurice Morris, Jerome Harrison / TE Will Heller
2012: Jahvid Best, Mikel Leshoure, Kevin Smith, Keiland Williams / James Bryant

If there's a team that knows about running back depth, this is it. They lost their top two backs to injury (Leshoure's Achilles and Best's concussions), lost Harrison after a failed physical found a brain tumor that voided a trade to the Eagles (for Ronnie Brown) and potentially saved his life, and had to ride out the season with re-signing former draft pick Kevin Smith and playing Keiland Williams and Maurice Morris. They hope they won't have to rely on the same crew, but Best is in a bit of jeopardy with all his concussion issues and who knows how Leshoure will take his first NFL carries.

At the fullback position, they signed James Bryant from the CFL, but since they don't use one much, Heller might moonlight again as the fullback.

Vikings
2011:
Adrian Peterson, Toby Gerhart, Lorenzo Booker / Ryan D'Imperio
2012: Adrian Peterson, Toby Gerhart, Lex HIlliard, Jordan Todman / Jerome Felton, Ryan D'Imperio

The Vikings stack first-round picks at the running back position, and one of them is in the conversation as arguably the best running back in the NFL, though Peterson will be coming off an injury. Gerhart filled in adequately, but he'll need to take a next step in the coming year. That's pretty much what matters for the Vikings - the fall-off is pretty steep after that.

D'Imperio worked out okay last year, but the Vikings picked up Jerome Felton in the offseason, who was passed around from the Panthers to the Colts last year and now to the Vikings.

Packers:
2011:
Ryan Grant, James Starks, Alex Green, Brandon Saine / John Kuhn
2012: James Starks, Alex Green, Brandon Saine / John Kuhn

Yeah, I botched up Saine in the receivers piece, but he really is a running back. But if he's a significant piece in the Packers' future, something happened here. And the Pack no longer has Ryan Grant, electing instead to go with James Starks as their feature back and hoping Alex Green can pick up more than the three carries and one reception he got last year. Starks hasn't been bad, but so far he hasn't taken a full season load - given the system Green Bay runs, it's not likely he'll have to.

As far as KUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUHN goes, the only thing more annoying than his short-yardage pounding is that crowd-call any time he touches the ball. But there's a reason he's picked up eight touchdowns in the last two seasons and last year made a Pro Bowl as a fullback - he does the little things well and chips in carrying the ball himself.

So as far as ordering this unit... I'd say for once the Packers rate at 4 - though their offense doesn't suffer for it because the passing game is just so good. I'll put the Lions at 3, because between their top two combining to miss 26 games last season, do they really know what they have there? And will Best even be able to come back this season with his concussions?

Then it becomes a tossup between the Vikings and the Bears for 1 and 2... And it's really close, because the Bears have a deeper, more proven top 3 and top 4, but the Vikings have a pair of first rounders at the position, one of whom is arguably the best running backs in the NFL. Forte may be a better receiver than Peterson and makes up much of the difference between the pair's rushing with his receiving, but Peterson's never had a year of less than 10 touchdowns receiving, never had less than a 4.4 yards-per-attempt.

I'll take the Vikings at 1 and the Bears at 2 (reeeeeeeeeeeeeally close) for this reason: while Forte and Peterson both played in the same amount of games this year and Forte outdueled him in total yards from scrimmage, I don't see how one can pick against a guy who did some really ridiculous things in his career (almost 1300 yards in four straight seasons, 2010 had 1298 yards) and, approaching his age 27 season, will still be the same age as Matt Forte, and thus, at this point I think it's fair to overlook the one year where Forte had more yards from scrimmage. Peterson does have an additional year of NFL carries that Forte doesn't (Peterson declared for the draft his junior year), I will admit. (Forte did play his senior year at Tulane, so it's not so much of a difference, as he had 361 carries and 32 receptions his senior year - Forte has 2,173 total NCAA and NFL touches compared to Peterson's 2,314.) But Gerhart was a first-rounder for a reason, and should be able to keep Peterson fresher as they continue to push along the painfully slow quarterback development plan. Forte's been great the last two years, and Bush will be a solid complement, but I'm just not sure if that tandem (plus Kahlil Bell) is greater than the Peterson/Gerhart tandem.

What do you guys see out of the division running backs?

var switchTo5x=true; stLight.options({publisher:''});

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Minnesota Vikings: Nick Taylor’s Talents Made Room For Former Point Guard in NFL

Oftentimes, when a door closes, another opens—either by chance or through an opportunity.   Photo Via TheVikingAge.com There are many times when the abilities of extremely talented individuals are nearly impossible to ignore.  That’s a fitting description for Nick Taylor.  Despite being labeled undersized, Taylor’s talents allowed him to get recognized. The Minnesota Vikings...

Vikings rookie says following Longwell an 'honor'

Blair Walsh says he would've enjoyed meeting Ryan Longwell. He surely would've benefited from learning from the 16-year veteran, too. But the Minnesota Vikings rookie is on his own now. And that, he says, is a humbling honor. The Vikings began spring practice Tuesday - known around the league as organized team activities - but Walsh said being on top of the depth chart...

Minnesota Vikings Fantasy Football Projections

QB Christian Ponder (Minnesota) Christian Ponder should start 16 games this year. Unlike last year, he’s the week 1 starter and unlike last year, he has a capable blindside protector so he’s less likely to miss time with injury. As a team, the Vikings passed 510 times last year. That seems about right for Ponder, who should improve upon his 6.4 YPA from last year as he goes into...

Bears worried about Matt Forte’s knees

Matt Forte was franchised by the Chicago Bears earlier this offseason and he has not been happy about it. Forte is refusing to sign the 7.7 million dollar tender as he’s looking for a deal worth 8.5 million or so per year over 4-5 years with about half guaranteed: a deal essentially on par with what LeSean McCoy, Chris Johnson, and Arian Foster have gotten in the last 2 seasons...

Bears RB Matt Forte Tweets video of him pulling a 100 pound sled

Running back Matt Forte and the Chicago Bears have yet to agree on a contract extension. The Chicago Tribune reported that the Bears are reluctant to give Forte an extension because there are concerns about the durability of his knees. Forte tore the posterior cruciate ligament in his left knee in 2006, and sprained the [...]

QUICK HITS: 2012 NFL Draft-or-Bust Off on Robert Blanton

Welcome to Purple Jesus Diaries' 2012 NFL Draft-or-Bust Off where we cover all items related to the 2012 NFL Draft as pertains to the Minnesota Vikings. At this point in the year, we will continue reviewing this crop of draft picks. We've already looked at Matt Kalil, Harrison Smith, Josh Robinson, Jarius Wright, Rhett Ellison, and Greg Childs, so today we start to...

Progress will take time in loaded NFC North

As the Minnesota Vikings convene at Winter Park today for the start of organized team activities, they are trying to erase the stigma of a 3-13 record that tied the franchise mark for futility in a 16-game season. The NFL presents rags-to-riches stories every season. Though the players and coaches won't publicly acknowledge the obvious, Minnesota isn't so concerned with...

Bears Concerned With Matt Forte

The Chicago Bears are reportedly concerned with the condition of running back Matt Forte's knees, according to The Chicago Tribune.  Fantasy Spin: This sheds light on why the Bears are reluctant to ink the ultra-talented young running back to a long-term contract. Forte sprained his right MCL late last season and the club is concerned regarding the stability of his knees for...

Percy Harvin not ready to participate in OTA’s

Getty Images According to Jeremy Fowler of TwinCities.com, Minnesota Vikings wide receiver Percy Harvin hasn’t been participating in OTA’s after undergoing minor offseason shoulder surgery. Harvin isn’t expected to miss a lot of time, but he was only limited to team meetings during Tuesday’s session.  There’s no indication as to when he will participate on the field, at this point.

Matt Forte addresses the concerns over his knees

After Saturday’s report that the Chicago Bears are concerned about the long-term health of running back Matt Forte’s knee’s, he posted a video on his Twitter feed to show everyone that they have nothing to worry about. 100Lbs sled up hill i think my knee will be ok RT @nfl: Bears concerned with Matt Forte’s knees: nfl.com/news/story/090… twitvid.com/OPVBZ — Matt Forte...

VIDEO: Earl Bennett at OTAs

Film work and commentary on Chicago Bears wide receiver Earl Bennett from the most recent OTA practice session.

Unlike Martz, Tice not a dictator

Bears quarterback Jay Cutler says developing this year’s offense will be a group effort between him, quarterbacks coach Jeremy Bates and offensive coordinator Mike Tice.
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.