Found October 14, 2012 on isportsweb.com:
As a football fan, I see this every week.  And, every time, it drives me crazy.  A team will have 3rd and manageable either inside the Red Zone or close to it, and what do they do?  They’ll call a run into the line, and they will play for the FG.  Consider this an open letter to football teams.  Here’s what I’ve seen in just the last few weeks:   Jacksonville v. Indianapolis.  The Colts drove into the Red Zone late in the fourth quarter, trailing the Jaguars by a point.  Instead of continuing to attack, the Colts run into the line three times and make the Jaguars burn all three of their timeouts.  They decide to play for the FG, setting up Adam Vinatieri who had already missed one FG in that quarter.  He does hit this one to put the Colts up two.  On the next Jaguar play, however, they hit an 80 yard TD pass.  Indianapolis now finds themselves down by 5 with a little over a minute to play.  And, since they were playing for FGs, they now need a TD to win the game.  Andrew Luck tried to force into Reggie Wayne in tight coverage on the last play leading to an incompletion, giving the Jaguars the win. Andrew Luck has a had fantastic rookie season, but when the Colts played for a FG late against the Jaguars, that was too deep of a hole for Luck to dig the Colts out of.               Notre Dame vs. Stanford.  Down 3 with 33 seconds to play, the Irish find themselves on the Stanford 5 with 3rd and 2.  With a pouring rain and a wet field, Notre Dame decided to run into the line with the FG in their back pocket.  The Fighting Irish had already botched a FG attempt earlier with a bad snap and wet ball, and it was now raining harder.  However, it all worked out for Notre Dame this time.  The FG was hit to force overtime, and the Irish prevailed 20-13 in OT.  Even though they won, this game became a lot closer than it needed to be, because the Irish played conservatively and didn’t go for the TD with 30 seconds to play from five yards away.   West Virginia vs. Texas Tech.  I was listening to ESPN College GameDay radio coverage of this game.  West Virginia had a 4th and 5 from the Texas Tech 30 down 7-0 in the first quarter, and they went for it.  They didn’t pick it up and gave the ball back to Tech.  The commentator ripped West Virginia for not taking the FG saying that the West Virginia head coach didn’t trust his defense.  Now, it ended up not mattering because Texas Tech won by double digits, but what if the Red Raiders won by 4?  Then, is it the right call to go for the FG when you have a potent offense that you feel can convert a 4th and 5?   I have two problems with playing for FGs.  1) I think teams play for FGs simply because it’s what has always been done.  It is the conservative play, and the media won’t backlash against for taking the conservative play.  Look at Louisiana Monroe this season.  They go for most 4th downs, and they play for TDs.  How has that worked out for them?  They beat Arkansas, and they lost to Auburn by 3 and Baylor by 5.  The Warhawks by being aggressive were able to compete with BCS teams.  And, I’m not saying never take FGs, and I’m not trying to banish kickers.  But, when you run into the line on 3rd and short instead of trying to pick up the first down, that’s too conservative.  2) Instead of showing a lack of trust in the defense, I think playing for FGs shows a lack of trust in the offense.  I’m surprised the Brian Kelly didn’t trust his offense to go for a TD 5 yards away that late in the game.  That would’ve been the nail in the coffin; instead, he gambled the Irish would prevail in OT.  I’m always going to be for letting the offense make a play.  It’s simple math: if your defense has a good game and gives up 14, then you would need 5 scoring drives of FGs to win.  Trust your offense and try to pick up that 3rd and short.  Play for TDs, that’s what wins ballgames.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

NY Times: Andrew Luck a Step Ahead as a Rookie

Today The New York Times' NFL writer Judy Battista profiles Andrew Luck and his impressive football acumen in the paper's Sports Section.  Even with his low profile, aw-shucks demeanor, the young Colts QB manages to demand national attention every week through is eye-opening ability to play the position.  Battista, who also has a nice article on all 5 NFL rookies, manages...

Indianapolis Colts try to stay #CHUCKSTRONG in week 6 vs. Jets

The Indianapolis Colts try to maintain the momentum gained after last week’s stunning upset over the Green Bay Packers as they meet the New York Jets Sunday at MetLife Stadium.It was as emotional a win as any you could imagine for the Colts, whose head coach Chuck Pagano is battling recently diagnosed leukemia. It is up to interim head coach and offensive coordinator Bruce Arians...

Indianapolis Colts get beat down by Jets 35-9

The Indianapolis Colts came into this week riding the high of a rousing 30-27 victory over the Green Bay Packers in Indianapolis that week.It didn’t last long.The Colts were run over (quite literally) by a truck bearing the license plate “GREENE.” As in Shonne Greene. The Jets running back, who prior to today had failed to register a single 100 yard game this season, trucked...

Armstrong: Respecting the Rookie

It seems like the league's worst 2011 team is becoming the feel-good story of 2012; Kevin Armstrong, who writes for the Jets, has a great article on Andrew Luck, maybe the most complimentary I've seen on the Colts's QB. Luck is a 6-4, 234-pound rookie capable of throwing from all angles with uncommon touch. Already able to identify his progressions and reads, he is...

Problem 1: Run, Run, Stop

There was a plethora of things that went wrong on Sunday afternoon.  You don't lose 35-9 against a team with serious issues becuause of a few lucky breaks. The Colts lost because they have multiple issues on both sides of the ball, in coaching, and they had a few unlucky bounces.  One of the most noticable issues the Colts had against the Jets was their complete inability...

Indianapolis Colts helmet, uniform concept design

A number of designers have taken their shot at redesigning the Indianapolis Colts helmets and uniforms to their liking.Could you imagine Andrew Luck, Reggie Wayne, or Dwight Freeney wearing something like this?Featured are a number of Indianapolis Colts helmets and uniform designs. Some are interesting options that fans may like and others may strike  a nerve with some fans.Images...

Column: Fun times for NFL rookie quarterback crop

(Eds: With AP Photos.) By TIM DAHLBERG AP Sports Columnist Andrew Luck's first working trip to New York didn't exactly go to plan, though some punishing defense by the Jets had a lot to do with that. All part of the learning curve for rookies, who sometimes have difficulty understanding that big second-half comebacks can't be pulled off every week in the NFL. The leap...

Almost Instant Recap: Colts 9, Jets 35

  Today, the Colts came into East Rutherford, New Jersey with high hopes and expectations against the Jets after last week’s furious and emotional comeback victory over the Packers.  Many have wondered what this team can do if they put together two halves of the kind of football they played in the second half against Green Bay and in the first halves against Jacksonville and...

Brunner: Colts got Grounded and Pounded by the Jets

The Colts-Jets game was frustrating to watch, but we're going through with some links anyway. Conrad Brunner of 1070 The Fan broke the game down in his Hot Reads column, and in his earlier quick recap and box score.    It was eerily similar to the season-opening 41-21 loss in Chicago, as the Colts were plagued by shaky play from rookie quarterback Andrew Luck (two interceptions...

NFL Week 6: New York vs Indianapolis Recap

NEW YORK (35) d INDIANAPOLIS (9) The Headline: Luck comes crashing back to earth as the Jets defense steps up The Story: What to do when your team looks like it is in total disarray and the season is teetering on the edge of a cliff about to completely collapse? What about when your starting quarterback and his backup both are struggling to look like competent players on a pop warner...

CHEERS AND JEERS: COLTS 9 JETS 35 FINAL

There was plenty to cheer about during Week Six as the New York Jets snapped their two-game losing streak and secured a convincing win over Andrew Luck and the Indianapolis Colts on Sunday.

Indianapolis Colts at New York Jets: Five Things We Learned

"GROUND AND POUND!" "GROUND AND POUND!" This should be the New York Jets new mantra. A slogan to play by, to live by, TO WIN BY. The author of this article had a funny feeling about this game. In fact, the only prediction that was WAY OFF was the final score.Jets 35, Colts 9 I did, in fact, anticipate a blowout. I also assumed (incorrectly, it seems) that Colts...

Fantasy Football Week 6 Preview: Colts at Jets

Indianapolis Colts @ New York JetsIndianapolis:  The Colts come off of a stunning and emotional upset of the Green Bay Packers in Week 5.  The question is, with all that emotion from coach Chuck Pagano’s diagnosis poured into a herculean effort to defeat Aaron Rodgers and the Packers, do Andrew Luck and the Colts have anything left in the tank for a vulnerable Jets team? For...

A letter to the Indy Star

Indianapolis Star October 15, 2012 Dear Indy Star, Pardon my French, but this really pisses me off.  Road Wimps?  Really?  I know you were just in New York, but let me fill you in on something…you’re back in Indiana.  Where Hoosier Hospitality is a thing.  And not just a thing…a real thing. I’m not one of those fans who thinks you can only say or write positive things...
Colts News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.