Found June 04, 2012 on The Saints Nation:
This isn't a surprise, but it's a tough break none the less for the suspended players and the NFLPA. System Arbitrator Stephen Burbank ruled in favor of Roger Goodell and the NFL, saying Goodell was indeed acting within his rights of power when he suspended Will Smith, Jonathan Vilma, Scott Fujita and Anthony Hargrove. Specifically, the pay for performance program is a salary cap violation, therefore an off the field infraction which falls within Goodell's sole jurisidiction. It was a nice try by the NFLPA, but clearly Goodell can do what he wants. It was pretty obvious to me this would never work because the CBA that was signed clearly gives him that power. The ruling that a salary cap infraction is an off the field action seemed fairly straightforward.

The NFLPA is still hanging on to the hope that... infractions committed prior to the new CBA cannot be grandfathered in. I think that ultimately won't work either, but it has more merit than this previous item Burbank ruled on. That claim will demand a ruling as well. Vilma's libel suit against Goodell, in my opinion, has the weakest chance at any kind of success. Unfortunately, the longer this goes, the more I get the feeling we're just cutting through a lot of red tape to get back to the original ruling by Goodell against the players. It's certainly worth the effort, especially for Vilma, but it's not looking too promising to yield any improvement in results.

Another problem in this ongoing saga is the NFL coaches association has now turned on the NFLPA releasing this statement. Another source that does a decent job covering this story is, which is worth the read. What we have here is everyone turning on each other. Filmmakers turning on players, players turning on filmmakers, players turning on coaches (and the league), coaches turning on players. Everyone is throwing others under the bus in this scandal and no one is willing to accept blame other than Gregg Williams, who had no choice. Even Sean Payton, Joe Vitt and Loomis tried to turn on Gregg Williams using the defense of a solely authoritative rogue coach. I think every recognizes this is bad, and they want to do everything in their power to shift blame and distance themselves from responsibility. It makes you wonder if the NFL hadn't been better off stopping at the suspensions of the coaches.

One thing is for sure, the league, the coaches, the owners and the players are all more fractured than ever. You would have thought the new CBA would resolve differences and give us a good 10 years of amicable business dealings, but it's becoming increasingly clear that each side is more divided by the day. This really all started with the lockout, and I do feel the commraderie of the NFL took a huge hit during that process. The residual lack of trust and hard ball tactics are continuing as a result of those negotiations. The timing of "bounty gate" in a time of fragile relationships, just one year removed from a lockout and ugly finger pointing, wasn't the best.


Is It Time for Roger Goodell to Step Down as NFL Commish?

Roger Goodell has been at the helm for six NFL seasons. In many ways, he was the right man for the job at the right time when he stepped into the role. But is he still? Roger Goodell has had many successes and some failures as commissioner. Are the failures now starting to outnumber the successes? (Photo credit: By derivative work: Kelly (talk) Roger_Goodell_Afghanistan.jpg: Staff...

Goodell isn't a player hater

I am not without prejudice on the subject of NFL ownership. After all, who's ever heard of an owner coming down with post-concussion syndrome? The recent decision not to eliminate that annual desecration of tackle football -- the Pro Bowl -- is a case in point. Still, it was a relatively modest money grab compared to, say, the lockout, which was downright immoral. Just the...

Goodell's authority upheld; NFLPA appeals

Special master Stephen Burbank upheld NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell's authority to suspend four players the league punished for alleged involvement in the Saints bounty scandal. Burbank ruled just five days after the NFLPA hearing that the penalties were out of Goodell's CBA-granted authority and should be viewed as salary cap violations and not on-field misconduct. Burbank...

Goodell's authority to suspend uphelp in bounty appeal

Special master Stephen Burbank upheld NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell's authority to suspend four players the league punished for alleged involvement in the Saints bounty scandal. Burbank ruled just five days after hearing the NFLPA appeal that the penalties were out of Goodell's CBA-granted authority and should be viewed as salary cap violations and not on-field misconduct...

Fujita suspension upheld as Goodell’s standing is confirmed

The first tactic to try and poke holes in Roger Goodell’s punishment of players for the Saints bounty program has failed. The first order was to try and claim that Roger Goodell didn’t have standing to punish players under the current form of the Collective Bargaining Agreement. Specifically, the players were questioning whether the current CBA gave Goodell standing over actions...

NFL Should Get Rid Of The Pro Bowl

The NFL announced this past week that there will be a Pro Bowl in 2013 after speculation that Commissioner Roger Goodell wanted to get rid of the All-Star event.   Goodell expressed concerns about the level of competition after this year’s embarrassing display. In case you missed it, here’s pretty much what happened: defensive linemen rose up out of their stances and watched...

Vilma’s lawyer calls Goodell “misguided and irresponsible”; claims bounties were for “good, clean, legal plays”

Peter Ginsberg, the man who is representing Saints LB Johnathan Vilma in his appeal of the one-year suspension handed to him by Roger Goodell and also the defamation lawsuit that Vilma has filed against commissioner Goodell, has issued a statement in response to the allegations that there was a ledger that documents the Saints’ bounty payments. In the statement, Ginsberg called...

Saints Bounty Suspensions Upheld As NFLPA Grievance Rejected

The New Orleans Saints players who were suspended by NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell in the wake of the team’s Bounty Incentive Program will have their penalties upheld, after Stephen Burbank rejected the grievance filed by the NFLPA. Burbank reaffirmed Goodell’s decision to suspend the four players involved in the bounty program orchestrated by former Saints defensive coordinator...

NFL wins bounty arbitration ruling

An arbitrator has ruled that NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell has the authority to discipline New Orleans Saints players for their role in a bounty system.

Top 10 reasons why the NFL locked out the refs

10) Just not making enough money 9) Really want to see how much they can infuriate fans who will still, of course, watch every minute of every game 8) Refs kept leaving negotiation session to go to a nearby porno arcade and go "under the hood" 7) Roger Goodell's looking to make an example out of those who defy him, and he's fresh out of Saints personnel 6) League...

Ray Rice Misses His Teammates and Can Roast You With Kindness

;Ray Rice and Roger Goodell at DeWitt Clinton HS in the Bronx on May 30th The Carroll County Times caught up with Baltimore Ravens RB Ray Rice at Lardarius Webb’s charity softball game and asked him what it feels like to be back with his teammates who were competing against each other (O Vs. D). Ray had this to say: “I miss it,” Rice said when asked about not being around his...

NFL Looking For Replacement Refs

Talks over a new CBA with game officials has hit a standstill. Meanwhile, Anthony Hargrove and the other suspended players lose a challenge to commissioner Roger Goodell.

Arbitrator upholds Roger Goodell’s ability to suspend Saints

(PhatzRadio / USA Today) — UPDATE, 11:26 a.m. ET: The NFLPA announced it will appeal Burbank’s ruling. The union released a statement that reads in part: Any pay-to-injure program runs counter to the health and safety principles we stand for as players. However, none of the players punished in this case have seen a shred of evidence justifying the NFL’s punishment.
NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.