Found April 27, 2012 on Awful Announcing:

rcmh

Ryan covered ESPN's draft coverage, and I'm here to take a look at what the NFL Network did with the first round of the NFL draft last night. Let's take it away, shall we?

The Good

-Mike Mayock was great. He gave a ton of information about the players, was brutally honest, and provided a lot of refreshing insight. Mayock also actually analyzed the players instead of spitting out the usual catchphrases you hear nonstop from guys like Kiper and McShay on ESPN.

-The NFL Network main set worked very well together and focused on Mayock.  The crew let Mayock be the star of the show, as he had the most experience and knowledge of the players in the draft. Rich Eisen was very good in his anchoring role and was mainly there to facilitate the flow of the coverage towards Mayock, while guys like Michael Irvin, Steve Mariucci, and Marshall Faulk added insight about the NFL teams in the draft and what their needs were.

-I liked the live camera shots of draft parties. It was like a more amped up version of the shots of fans at Radio City that ESPN would always do, highlighting fanbases that wouldn't normally make the trip to New York (like Miami and Houston, to name two). I'm a little shocked that the Dolphins fans didn't completely revolt when they picked Ryan Tannehill though, as the reactions I saw from fans on Twitter were less than pleasing. 

 

The Bad

-I was irked at how midway through the first round, the NFL brought out some armed forces members to honor...and then, the network cut away halfway through the ovation. It seemed really tacky to me, as you go for the cheap pop and then you don't even get the full effect of it.

-The war room cameras were worthless. During the preshow, they kept showing a multi-screen look in the war rooms.... and half of them were empty, a half hour before the draft. When they would cut to a war room, the executives were essentially just sitting there with stupid grins on their faces, waiting for their picks to be announced by the heavily delayed system. It added less than nothing to my viewing experience of the draft.

-What the hell was the purpose of Jason LaCanfora and Michael Lombardi in the auxiliary stage? They sat there, and essentially, all they did was talk about the trades between teams in the top 15 or so. I don't think they were given any camera time in the last half of the broadcast. It just seemed like NFL Network could have gotten much more out of their insiders.  

The Ugly

-Deion Sanders' interviews with the draftees were awful. They were mostly of the human interest variety, except they weren't really interesting. The first couple were multiple questions, then they turned into single question, then they pretty much disappeared while the lower profile draftees started getting taken. And thank God too, because they were a complete waste of time.

-The pacing of the draft over the first ten picks was terrible. It took a half hour for the first three picks to be announced, considering that two of them were chiseled in stone for quite awhile. Teams would get their picks in quickly, and the NFL Network would be scrambling to get everything taken care of, from the backstage views of the pick and his family, to the walk to the stage, to the posedown with Goodell, to the interview with Sanders...it was just a total mess. At one point, I think there was a backlog of about three picks that were submitted while the car wash went on.

-This isn't so much a criticism of NFL Network, but reporters around the league were incessantly tweeting out picks before they happened. The NFL Network was absolutely great about not spoiling picks with shots in the green room (aside from Luck), but it was strange when someone like Adam Schefter or Jay Glazer would tweet out a pick minutes before it was officially announced, and Mayock and the rest of the crew would play be ambivalent to the news. The best example was when the Bills went with Stephon Gilmore and Mayock called an O-lineman for them... you really couldn't get much further off even though plenty of us knew who the pick was going to be already.  It was that dilemma between embracing the news aspect of the draft and the television aspect of it that still needs improved.

Grade

Overall, the actual analysis of the Draft by NFL Network was good....but the presentation didn't go so well. Possible changes include completely discontinuing the post-pick interview, absolutely not waiting for the player's name to be pressed onto the jersey (which probably added to the car wash time), and maybe even killing the whole "meeting with Goodell" thing. When a p;ayer gets picked and is in the green room hugging a dozen people, and then we don't see him for two minutes, and then he's on the stage for another three minutes.... it's such a waste of time. And then, he needs to do a brief interview with both the NFL Network and ESPN? It's too much. People love to criticize the relatively new to TV MLB Draft for not being marketable, but the first round of that draft is done MUCH quicker than the NFL draft.

My issues aren't necessarily with the NFL Network, but with the layout of the draft itself. There was just so much wasted time, and the NFL could have probably been able to hack an hour off of their coverage, get everything done, and get fans more pleased. On the bright side, this is ahuge upgrade to the seven hour first round from a few years back.


facebook Like Awful Announcing on Facebook twitter Follow Awful Announcing on Twitter

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Draft Day: Mel Kiper and Mike Mayock’s Projections for the Eagles

It’s draft day–who’s excited?! In a few hours, we will shift from trying to anticipate the Eagles’ first round draft pick to dissecting their selection. But until then, let’s enjoy the last few moments of speculation. Draft expert Mike Mayock of the NFL Network released his one and only mock draft yesterday, and on it he had Philadelphia selecting a player that some may...

Breaking: Patriots trade up and select Chandler Jones 21st...

Breaking: Patriots trade up and select Chandler Jones 21st overall Well there’s two ways to look at this. One is the way that all us amateur draftniks who weren’t blown away by Jones, or there’s the Mike Mayock way, who said that he thinks in a couple years Jones will be the best defensive player from this draft class. Jones will be used in a variety of ways, using his great...

Texans Profile: Brandon Brooks

  With the 76th overall pick in the 2012 NFL Draft the Houston Texans select… Brandon Brooks, Guard, Miami, OH Vital Stats Height                         6’5” Weight                        353 lbs. Arms                           33 Wingspan                  80”   Described by Mike...

HOORAY … it’s NFL Draft Day!!!

Yes, the day has finally arrived.  The 2012 NFL Draft is here, and we couldn’t be more excited about it! As you pore over Mike Mayock‘s one and only mock draft in preparation for this weekend’s festivities, keep in mind that pretty much none of these so-called “experts” have a clue as to how this draft is going to pan out.  For all the scouting and testing and poking...

With the 172nd overall pick, the Seahawks select...

...Jeremy Lane, CB, Northwestern State.   Carroll and Schneider continue the surprises with this pick, a speedy, raw cornerback from a relatively unknown school. Per ESPN's Mike Mayock, Lane ran a 40-yard dash in the 4.4s, and had a very good game against LSU, which may have gotten him his chance in the NFL. Others are describing him as tough, physical and ready to compete...

The NFL.com draft feed has some strange technical difficulties

We've reached Day 3 of the NFL Draft and Rounds 4-7, which is the day hardcore draftnkis truly relish.  It's Day 3 where the Kipers and McShays and Mayocks of the world truly make their living as fans talk themselves into finding the next Tom Brady or Marques Colston in the latter rounds.  For NFL.com's online draft feed, it was also time to endure this bizarre cutaway...

Video: Browns get their tackle, taking Mitchell Schwartz

As Kirk let us all know earlier, the Cleveland Browns got giant many Mitchell Schwartz. He is a 6’5″ 320 pound monster who Mike Mayock called a “plug-and-play” right tackle. Of course the Browns could have gone with either offensive line or wide receiver with their second rounder. I guess the Browns feel their chances of getting a receiver are still good later. But let...

Tennessee Titans Make Surprise Selection, Take Star WR Kendall Wright

Entering the 2012 NFL Draft, wide receiver wasn’t on the list of the top three needs for the Tennessee Titans. But that didn’t stop the team from making a surprise selection again this April and taking the star receiver out of Baylor. Kendall Wright saw steady growth in his four-year college career at Baylor. “When he gets the ball in his hands, he’s special,” Mike Mayock...

Mock Drafts: Mayock, Kiper and McShay all predict Broncos will draft DTs

The mock drafts of Mike Mayock, Mel Kiper, Jr., and Todd McShay have all been updated to their final versions (or, in the case of Mayock, his first and only version). One thing is clear, the experts agree: the Denver Broncos should draft a defensive tackle. But none of them agree on the player. Check it out — Mike Mayock – 25. Denver Broncos — Dontari Poe, DT, Memphis I...

Late NFL Draft Rumors to Screw with Your Board

NFL Draft: The only time men are on the phone more than women Late NFL Draft Rumors NFL Network’s Mike Mayock predicts that the Bills’ pick at No. 10 overall will be Boston College ILB Luke Kuechly. You can throw that into the many possible players taken by the Bills The Charlotte Observer reports that the Panthers “will” draft Oklahoma State WR Justin Blackmon if he’s...

More Kuechly projections on Draft Eve

The Mock Drafts are flying around the internet. In theory nothing has changed but that doesn't mean players aren't moving up and down draft boards. One of the "hot" names is Luke Kuechly. Luke's sudden popularity makes sense. Every draft pick is a roll of the dice. As much as team's draft for need and upside, what they all want to avoid is a bust. Busts...
NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.