Found March 01, 2013 on
Waiting For Next Year:
Twenty-two combined seasons in Orange and Brown. Four Pro Bowls. Two fan favorites. Both free agents.
Cleveland fans love to hold on to their sports heroes. Josh Cribbs and Phil Dawson have been consistently the best things about Cleveland Browns football since the team returned in 1999.
Josh Cribbs walked on the team as an undrafted free agent after playing QB for Kent State in 2005. His counterpart from the University of Akron Charlie Frye, was a third round pick of the Browns that same year. Frye would start 18 games for the Browns before being traded to Seattle in 2007.
Phil Dawson is another undrafted player that found a home with the Browns after trying to stick with the Raiders and Patriots. Dawson is the only player that has been with the team from the return in 1999.
Both are fan favorites. Whether it was the hard work they put in to become top players at their positions or the way they embraced Cleveland and it’s fans, both are loved and would be missed if they weren’t with the team next year.
Josh Cribbs has said he would give a hometown discount in order to finish his career with the Browns. That still might not be enough for the new management to give him a contract. Vic Carucci hit the nail on the head with Cribbs-
“As noble as it might have been for Cribbs to say in the media he would be willing to take a pay cut to remain with the Browns, it doesn’t change the fact that the team’s decision-makers need to believe he holds enough value to maintain a valuable roster spot.”
Cribbs may be a legend when it comes to returning kicks, but is he the same returner? And is the return game even the same with the new rules? The fact remains Travis Benjamin is probably a better option than Cribbs as a returner. As a wide receiver, Cribbs isn’t a starter in the NFL. Could a creative coach find ways to get Cribbs the ball and be effective? At one time that was certainly true. Now? Not sure. The fact remains NFL roster spots are a big deal. If the Browns are to give one of those spots to Cribbs, he has to give them something that they can’t get from another player. Does Josh give them that?
After 14 seasons, Dawson is on top of his game. Not many players earn their first Pro Bowl birth at age 38. Obviously he plays a position that allows players to perform at a high level for a longer time. Dawson isn’t just a prolific kicker, he’s a prolific kicker in a stadium that isn’t easy to kick in.
Unfortunately, the Browns have already used the franchise tag on Dawson twice, which would mean they would have to pay him QB money to do so again. Will the Browns offer Dawson a multi-year deal? How much will Dawson ask for?
There is a good chance that the Browns will pass on both players.
Perhaps the fallout from not signing these two fan favorites won’t be as big as it would have been in the past. Browns fans realize the situation for the most part, and know that this new organization has no ties or real attachment to them.
If the Browns do open the wallet a little this off season and bring in a couple players the fans are excited about, it would certainly smooth over losing a couple of fan favorite special teamers.
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
Cleveland Browns wide receiver Josh Cribbs was asked by ESPN Radio in Cleveland if he’s been talking with other teams.
“My agent has been meeting with several different teams. There is a lot of interest. There are already numbers brought to the table. Things are happening. Wheels are turning behind closed doors,: said Cribbs, per ESPNCleveland.com
The problem with what Cribbs...
This latest 2013 NFL mock draft takes into account where players could be drafted so far in the process and takes in account the Alex Smith to the Kansas City Chiefs trade.
The NFL Scouting Combine is over, and a lot of players shot up the board due to their performance.
Eddie Lacy dropped out of the first round due to opting out of the combine. Sharrif Floyd and Sheldon Richardson...
It’s comical how many people want to come out and accuse Josh Cribbs the Cleveland Browns great return man of tampering because his agent has talked to many NFL teams about acquiring the soon to be free agent. Lets get one thing perfectly clear, it is Rickert’s that should know the tampering rules, Not Cribbs. Why do you think Cribbs has an agent in the first place? The first...
For one Browns fan he could care less about who the starting quarterback is, whether or not it is Brandon Weeden or Colt McCoy he is going to root for his Cleveland Browns from his living room no matter how many games they win or lose. When the Browns left Cleveland and went to Baltimore he had a sick feeling in his stomach. Now that the team losses more games than they win, he...
The Cleveland Browns need to part ways with receiver Mohamed Massaquoi. He has never lived up to all the hype he got from former team president Mike Holmgren. Massaquoi has never been the same guy since taking a hit to the head from Steelers line backer James Harrison. If you were to visit the official Browns web site you would find Mo-Mass on the Reserve/Injured list. He only played...
Some day its the chicken, others the egg.
So it goes with the Cleveland Browns' new defensive system, a chicken or egg question if ever there was one.
Did the Browns adopt the new system because they hired coaches who believe in it, or did they choose the coaches because they believe in the Browns preferred system?
CEO Joe Banner had a plain answer last week when he met the...
It’s become abundantly clear that NFL players don’t quite have an understanding of NFL rules. Free agency start on March 12 and until that date players can’t begin negotiating with any other team but their own. If players were to meet with other teams, it would be considered tampering.
But that didn’t stop Vontae Leach from tweeting that former teammate Sean Smith was negotiating...
Season SummaryThe best way to sum up the Browns 2012 season is to copy and paste the season summary from any of the past five seasons. From 2008 through 2012, the Browns have won a total of 23 games. To you and me, that's an average of 4.6 wins/year and we all know there are 16 games in a full season, so you can do this math.Losses = 16 - 4.6, so losses equals 11.4. It's...
Geno Smith will not be drafted by the Kansas City Chiefs unless their deal to bring Alex Smith to Arrowhead falls through. That move sets up a number of possibilities on draft day that revolve around quarterback needy teams.
The Jacksonville Jaguars sit at number two overall, behind the Chiefs. Jacksonville is a quarterback needy team, but they've expressed that they'll...
Few teams are going through more change this offseason than the Cleveland Browns. … Again.
This time the turnover includes not just a new coach or quarterback, but a new ownership group led by Jimmy Haslam. Haslam wasted no time putting a new stamp on the organization, bringing in Joe Banner to run the team. The duo then signed off on the additions of Michael Lombardi as vice president...
Silly season is obviously going on now. After visiting with the Cleveland Browns on Wednesday, there’s been a bit of a reversal in the Steve Breaston narrative.
On Thursday and Friday, both the Plain Dealer’s Mary Kay Cabot and Elyria Chronicle-Telgram’s Scott Petrak respectively tweeted that the Browns would be unlikely to sign the free agent wide receiver. The 29-year-old...