Originally written on Rob The Hockey Guy  |  Last updated 11/16/14
2008_nhl_entry_9f25

Mike Gillis sent shockwaves through Canuck nation on trade deadline day. In the biggest deal of the day, Gillis sent Cody Hodgson and Alex Sulzer to the Buffalo Sabres for Zack Kassian and Marc-Andre Gragnani. I think like a lot of people, I was immediately confused by this trade. So I sat down, weighed the pros and cons, looked at it from all angles and I still don’t like it.

Lets take a look at what the Canucks are getting:

Zack Kassian

Kassian is the key to the deal for the Canucks. He was the 13th overall pick in the 2009 draft and starred in the 2011 World Junior Championships for Canada. At 6’3″, 214 lbs, he’s a big power forward and projects to be exactly what the Canucks need. He’s mean and nasty and can score. He had 77 points in 56 games in junior last year and has put up very good numbers in the AHL (26 points in 30 games) as a rookie. He has only played in 27 NHL games with the Sabres this year, notching 7 points while averaging about 12 minutes of ice time per game.

The Canucks are likely hoping that Kassian can be big, mean and provide a scoring touch, playing on their third line. If he’s able to do that, he’ll give the Canucks a dimension that they don’t have currently. Of course, he’s still a rookie so the jury is still out on whether or not he can carry the mail.

I asked Eric Schmitz, a Sabres blogger at 3rd Man In, how he felt about Zack Kassian and here’s how our conversation went:

Rob: “You ought to be thrilled to get Cody Hodgson”

Eric: “I definitely am. I’m very high on him, was hoping to get him in his draft year.”

Rob: “think you did ok with Myers”

Eric: “Yeah, it worked out in the end I think hahaha”

Rob: “do you think Kassian is ready to play full-time in the NHL right now?”

Eric: “He has shown the skills. Great down low at defending the puck, good hands. Just rarely throws his weight around.”

So those are hardly rave reviews, especially when you consider that he hasn’t scored a lot yet. Before speaking with Eric, I got the impression that Kassian was a big guy that wasn’t ready to score at the NHL level yet, but was certainly ready to throw big hits.

Marc-Andre Gragnani

Gragnani is a 24 year old offensive minded defenceman playing in his first full NHL season. He has 12 points in 44 games this year, but first burst onto the scene late last year. Gragnani only played in 9 regular season games for Buffalo last year, but he had 7 points in 7 games in the playoffs. Gragnani averaged 22 minutes of ice time per game in last year’s playoffs, good enough for third most on the Sabres. The question on Gragnani for me is if he was treated fairly this year. Was his drop in ice time unfair or was it warranted? The numbers would suggest to me that he should have been given more playing time, but high priced newcomers like Christian Ehrhoff and Robyn Regehr caused his reduced responsibility.

Analyzing the Trade

In many ways this is a bizarre trade, because people aren’t sure if this is a trade for the future or a trade for the present. In my opinion, the best player in the deal is Cody Hodgson in the short term, and in the long term. He was more highly touted than Kassian as a junior player and has proven more at the NHL level. Hodgson has shown enough to believe that he is going to be a star player one day, and is a very useful player today. Kassian’s ability for this season is undetermined, and long term is not a sure bet either. I hope that Mike Gillis believes that Zack Kassian will be a better player than Cody Hodgson in the long run, because that will determine the winner of this trade.

In this trade, the Canucks have made a decision that they needed to go with a grittier, more defensive third line in the playoffs. I think Alain Vigneault would have been hesitant to play Hodgson as much in the playoffs, and I think they need a checking line. But to give up on Cody Hodgson to make this happen I believe is an unnecessary risk.

Hodgson may not be your prototypical third line centre, but I think he could have learnt to play the wing, if that was the main concern. If you’re going to trade a guy like Hodgson, I would have preferred to see players with fewer question marks coming back. In this trade, Mike Gillis has managed to make me less confident in the short term and the long term.

But there is hope. The Canucks needed to get grittier and Zack Kassian certainly does that. They needed to get more depth on defence, and they did with Gragnani. Sami Pahlsson, acquired earlier from the Blue Jackets, will determine the success of this trade in the short term, as he will likely take over the third line centre spot. If Pahlsson is a better all-around third line centre in the playoffs than Hodgson would have been and if Gragnani can improve their defence and if Kassian can play on the third line, then the Canucks will have a better chance to win the Stanley Cup. And if the Canucks can win the Stanley Cup in 2012, nothing Cody Hodgson can do will make Mike Gillis regret the trade.

MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Darrelle Revis on Calvin Johnson: 'A man among boys'

LeBron: Teaching Cavs bigger challenge than winning first ring

Jets-Bills game won't be played in Buffalo on Sunday

LeGarrette Blount apologizes to former teammates, fans

Pilar Sanders posts audio of children saying Deion is abusive

Kobe Bryant dishes on trash talk with Dwight Howard

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Raiders owner Mark Davis: 'We want to stay here in Oakland'

Terrance Knighton: Broncos fans are ‘high-maintenance'

Ex-NFL player delivers own baby on North Carolina farm

USC players not happy about Josh Shaw reinstatement

FSU student: Books stopped bullets from hitting me

Jets-Bills game could be moved to Detroit, Toronto, New Jersey

Paul George interning with Pacers PR Dept. while injured

Manny Pacquiao vs. Chris Algieri: Full card preview

Could Josh Gordon put Cleveland Browns over the top?

Nike cancels 'AI' sneaker in light of Allen Iverson protest

Rick Pitino calls releasing pre-March rankings 'a football thing'

Lauren Hill surprises Devon Still with gift after practice

Raiders fans take out ad calling for Hue Jackson return

Eagles broadcaster has Cowboys turkey for Thanksgiving

Nick Young on his swag: 'I’m like Michael Jackson, Prince'

Le'Veon Bell adds Steelers o-line to award candidacy picture

Ranking the NBA's most exciting rookies

Steve Smith drops fantastic line about playing in prime-time

NHL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

LeBron on challenge of leading Cavaliers

LeGarrette Blount issues apology

Phelps' alleged GF born a man?

Bears considered benching Cutler?

Can Cardinals win a Super Bowl with Drew Stanton?

Steeler: Blount's release a blessing

WATCH: Carter moved by tribute

Giancarlo Stanton and the cost of becoming a boss

Report: Sandoval headed to Red Sox

VIDEO: HBO's 'Under The Lights' is a must watch

Brady: Belichick not as he seems

The NFL Chick gloriously interviews for the Gators head coach job

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.