Found December 26, 2011 on The Rangers Tribune:

BickelThe New York Rangers have been without four of their top seven defensemen for the past few weeks, due to a slew of injuries that hit the team all around the same time. However, as the Rangers are getting closer to becoming a healthier team, there will be some significant decisions to be made about the defensive personnel on this hockey club. Of course, the order in which these players return will have a major impact on those decisions, but the final product, which I expect to be together by mid to late-January, may look slightly different than what we all originally expected. 

According to Larry Brooks in the New York Post, Marc Staal, who has yet to play a game this season because of post-concussion symptoms, could be cleared for contact as early as this week. That would then put him on pace to make his season debut within the next two weeks.

Michael Sauer has also shown some improvements as of late that would suggest he is well on his way to recovery, too. 

And then there's Jeff Woywitka, who's been battling a tricky ankle after he blocked a shot in a game two weeks ago. Woywitka could return any day now, maybe as soon as tonight's match with the rival Islanders at Madison Square Garden.

That would then see rookie Tim Erixon returned to the Connecticut Whale of the AHL, where he will receive plenty more ice time than he has up here with the big club. Erixon, though, has played very well in the several games he has dressed for, so I'll give him that credit since it's deserved. 

I don't see Erixon in the aforementioned final product on defense, though. In fact, I don't see Jeff Woywitka in there either; well, at least I don't think he should be in there. Once Marc Staal and Michael Sauer return to the lineup, my performance-based defensive corps looks something like this:

Ryan McDonagh - Dan Girardi

Marc Staal - Michael Sauer

Michael Del Zotto - Stu Bickel

Based on what I've seen through the first 33 games, those are my top six deserving defensemen this season, with Staal obviously being an automatic. Now allow me to explain...

Ryan McDonagh and Dan Girardi have been lights out all season while playing together, so there is no reason why head coach John Tortorella should even consider breaking those two up. Plus, Staal is not going to be physically prepared to take on first line responsibilities upon just returning. 

Marc is better off coming back on the second pairing where he can more comfortably get back into his groove, and if things go wrong, he will have an extremely responsible partner to fall back on in Michael Sauer. I actually think many fans don't have as much trust in Sauer as they should. 

Moving on to the third and final pairing, this is where people may have some issues. I've been very hard on Michael Del Zotto this season, but that is because I know what he is capable of, and through the early stages of the year, he was not playing to the best of his ability. At the moment, however, he is playing some important minutes for the Rangers and has shown some serious improvement throughout the past month or so. In my opinion, he deserves to be in there over Woywitka, Stralman and even his buddy Steve Eminger. 

And with Stu Bickel, I cannot remember a rookie defenseman coming up midway through the season and having such an immediate impact on the club. Oh wait, yes I can - his name was Ryan McDonagh. And where is he now? On the top pairing playing against the league's best talents.

This Bickel kid is special and Tortorella is building his trust in him for sure. I have a feeling he is going to stick around for a while. 

I know there's going to be a lot of discrepancies with this, but it's how I see the Rangers putting the best defensive product possible out there. 

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Marc Staal Cleared for Contact

The New York Rangers are reporting that defenseman Marc Staal, who hasn't played a game this season due to post-concussion symptoms, has officially been cleared for contact. Staal has been skating with the team for a couple weeks now, but today's morning skate was the first time in which he engaged in all-out physical play with his teammates.  While Staal says his conditioning...

Rangers' Staal cleared for contact

Injured New York Rangers defenseman Marc Staal was cleared for contact, and took a few bumps on the ice from his teammates as he continues his recovery from a concussion. Staal, who will turn 25 in January, has been out all season because of the effects of a concussion sustained in February when he was hit by his brother, Eric, of the Carolina Hurricanes. He has been skating in...

Marc Staal Cleared For Contact

The big news out of practice today is that Marc Staal, out all year with post-concussion symptoms, was cleared for full contact. The news on Staal is great news, but also not all that surprising. He had been making serious progress in his recovery, and had been traveling with the team and practice –in a yellow non contact jersey– for a few weeks now. With Staal cleared for contact...

Rangers Should Continue Cautious Approach With Staal Return

The New York Rangers currently sit in first place in the Eastern Conference with a tremendous 22-8-4 record through 34 games this season.  Making the record even more impressive is the number of injuries they have battled through on defense with the most significant being All-Star defender Marc Staal.  Staal has been sidelined for the entire season while he recovers from post-concussion...

Marc Staal Cleared For Contact In Practice

from Katie Strang of ESPN New York, “Today I felt fully confident going on the ice and taking some hits. There wasn’t a doubt in my mind that that wasn’t the right thing to do with the way I was feeling,” Staal said. Staal was encouraged that, after being jostled by teammates, he felt fine. “I took a few bumps, my head bounced off the glass a couple times, things like...

Rangers D Staal cleared for contact (AP)

Injured New York Rangers defenseman Marc Staal was cleared for contact, and took a few bumps on the ice from his teammates as he continues his recovery from a concussion. Staal, who will turn 25 in January, has been out all season because of the effects of a concussion sustained in February when he was hit by his brother, Eric, of the Carolina Hurricanes.

Practice Notes: 8 Defensemen; Same Extras; & Staal Cleared for Contact

The Rangers report that all eight defensemen (no Sauer or Eminger) took the ice for the morning skate....assuming this means Woywitka will be back in the line-up and Erixon back in the AHL.Meanwhile, Andrew Gross reports Sean Avery along with Erik Christensen and Wojtek Wolski made up the scratch line again....only a matter of time till Avery and EC are waived.Speaking of Wolski...

Rangers' Staal OK'd for post-concussion contact

NEW YORK (AP) -- Injured New York Rangers defenseman Marc Staal was cleared for contact, and took a few bumps on the ice from his teammates as he continues his recovery from a concussion.

Practice Notes: Gabby, Bickel Sit; Woywitka Ready; Staal Does Drills

Andrew Gross reports that Marian Gaborik was given a maintenance day today and Stu Bickel missed practice due to a swallon eye he received during scrap with Michael Haley last night.Gross adds that Jeff Woywitka says he's ready to return to the line-up, however John Tortorella isn't sure what he's going to do with his defensemen.Tortorella also says he's undecided...

Rangers D Staal cleared for contact

New York Rangers defenseman Marc Staal was cleared for contact for the first time during his recovery process from a severe concussion. The 24-year-old Staal was able to participate in drills and took some hits from teammates during the team's practice on Monday. "Today I felt fully confident going on the ice and taking some hits," Staal said. "There wasn'...

Marc Staal cleared for contact

New York Rangers defenseman Marc Staal has been cleared for contact and is closer to his return. Staal suffered a concussion after getting hit by his brother Eric early this year in Feburary. Marc has been suffering from lingering concussion symptoms since and hasn't played a game yet this season.He's hoping that he'll be able to return for the NHL's Winter Classic...

Wolski Return Will Create Log-Jam; Staal Back in Two Weeks

Larry Brooks at the New York Post reports that Wojtek Wolski (hernia sugery) should be able to return to the Rangers lineup by the end of the week meaning the Blueshirts will need to make some roster moves.Brooks adds that The Rangers are currently at the 23-player roster limit, which does not include injured players Wolski, Marc Staal, Michael Sauer and Steve Eminger.The holiday...

Slap Shot: Rangers' Staal, Still Battling Concussion, Is Cleared for Contact

Defenseman Marc Staal, who continues to recover from a concussion after a hit by his brother Eric on Feb. 22, was cleared for contact and took hits during the Rangers' practice Monday at Madison Square Garden.

It’s Go Time!

Game 34. Rematch of Thursday’s 4-2 Rangers win. Ya boys on a four-game winning streak. With Boston idle tonight, the Rangers could move into first place in the East with a victory. Same lineup, other than Henrik Lundqvist in goal (Martin Biron beat the Islanders Thursday) and probably Jeff Woywitka (back from a foot injury) in place of Tim Erixon. Marc Staal has been cleared...
Rangers News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.