Found April 28, 2012 on Red Light District Hockey:
Gettyimage.ashx_url_http_3a_2f_2fcache.gettyimages.com_2fxc_2f91125141.jpg_3fv_3d1_26c_3dewsasset_26k_3d2_26d_3d77bfba49ef878921cc759df4ebac47d08088f2d11a876d38e2bc5c9e4874ff81eaeb7cc02ab00d62

Photobucket
Immediately after Boston’s first-round exit, speculation grew that the Bruins should trade or will trade veteran goaltender Tim Thomas this off-season. But should they do so? Tab and I debate…

Yes, the timing is perfect for a tradeBy Ryan Porth
This is a similar situation to the one in Vancouver right now. The Canucks brass is trying to decide whether to keep Roberto Luongo or pass the keys to promising youngster Cory Schneider. In Boston, GM Peter Chiarelli could trade Tim Thomas and make 25-year-old Tuukka Rask the starter.
Thomas has one year left on this contract, worth $5 million. Like Schneider, Rask is a restricted free agent this summer. Since Thomas’ contract situation is a lot different from Luongo’s, it’ll be easier for Thomas to be traded – and that’s the route the Bruins should take.
Thomas is 38 years old and, presumably, doesn’t have much left in the tank. However, with his success over the last few years he still has some trade value. He had the banner year in 2011, winning the Stanley Cup, Conn Smythe and Vezina Trophy, and he followed that up with a 35-win campaign where he recorded a 2.36 goals-against average.
There is enough there for an opposing GM to want to acquire Thomas. With that in mind, the timing is right for the Bruins to turn the page and part ways with the veteran netminder.
Rask is ready to be a starter in the NHL. The former first-round pick of Toronto has good career numbers as a backup (or 1B goalie). In 102 career games, Rask boasts a 2.20 GAA and .926 save percentage; and in 2009-10, he led the NHL in GAA (1.97). This summer he’s due for a raise from his current $1.25 million salary.
There’s no telling where Thomas could end up, if he is traded. As mentioned, his contract situation is favorable for a trade. His cap hit is $5 million, but the actual salary is $3 million. Also, his no-movement clause expires on July 1st.
Would Toronto want to get Thomas as a short-term solution to their goaltending woes? What about Chicago or Tampa Bay? If San Jose is no longer confident in Antti Niemi, would they be an option for Thomas?
Despite his age, Thomas will be an attractive option for teams looking for a one- or two-year fix in net. Contrarily, the Bruins can use the cap space to make upgrades elsewhere on the roster.
For Boston, it’s time to move on and make Rask the starter.---
No, Boston should hold on to ThomasBy Tab Bamford
A very good case can, and has, been made for the Bruins to trade Tim Thomas this summer. But that wouldn’t be the best course of action for a Boston team that wants to get back to the Cup final. There are a number of issues that emerge if the Bruins decide to move Thomas this summer, and there isn’t an easy remedy for any of them.
First, the best time for the Bruins to move Thomas would, in theory, be at (or before) the NHL Draft in late June. But that limits the time the organization has to deal with restricted free agent Tuukka Rask; if the Bruins move Thomas before signing Rask, their leverage is gone.
Speaking of Rask, moving Thomas before the season starts places an overwhelming amount of faith in the youngster. Boston would have to look for a veteran backup through free agency if Thomas was moved before the season, or turn over that spot to 22-year-old Michael Hutchinson, who had an impressive .927 save percentage with Providence (AHL) this year.
But how many teams enter a season with both Stanley Cup aspirations and a backup goalie with zero NHL ice time on his resume?
Back to Thomas.
Another concern is the value the Bruins would be able to get back in a deal when this summer’s crop of goalies is fairly deep. A free agent group that could include Josh Harding, Johan Hedberg, Tomas Vokoun, Al Montoya and Jonas Gustavsson figures to present the teams looking for a goalie enough opportunities.
Add to those players Roberto Luongo and a number of restricted free agent netminders that might also become available, and there wouldn’t be enough desperate general managers to pay a premium for Thomas.
The best course of action for Boston is to keep Thomas through the summer. Let him rotate in net with Rask through the first half of the season, and trade him to a desperate team at the deadline. Boston would undoubtedly get more value for Thomas in that scenario, and wouldn’t be putting their entire 2012-13 season on the shoulders of a player that finished this season injured.
Photo credit: Getty Images

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Peter Chiarelli 'Not Inclined' to Trade Tim Thomas, Keeping Current Goalie Tandem Could be Tricky

BOSTON -- Tim Thomas has a no-trade clause that expires on July 1, prior to the start of the final season of his four-year, $20-million deal. He just turned 38, stirred up controversy with his polarizing political stances and is coming off a season in which he played well, but didn't come close to matching the historic campaign he put together last year. Oh, and the Bruins have...

Future of Tim Thomas, Other Bruins in Question as Offseason Moves Begin (Video)

If defeat wasn't bad enough, now the chatter starts about what will happen to the Bruins in the offseason. Tim Thomas is the No. 1 man in question, but plenty of other Boston players need their contract situations worked out if they’re going to stay with the B's. NESN Daily offers an inside look at what the Bruins are planning and which players hope to stick around.

Tim Thomas, insurance policy?

In his Sunday notebook, the Boston Globe’s Kevin Dupont offers a unique solution to the potential market for one Tim Thomas, echoing the comments made by the gents on the Satellite Hotstove on Saturday night: As much as he is revered in Boston, forever to be remembered for playing every minute of the 2011 Cup run, Thomas turned 38 this month. Even with his pedigree, he can’t...

Boston Bruins face offseason retooling

A year removed from winning the Stanley Cup, the Boston Bruins face many serious questions after their first-round exit from the playoffs.What do they do in goal? Tim Thomas is 38 years old. He has a year left on his contract, but his no-trade protect expires June 30. Would another team be willing to take on his $5 million salary cap hit? Tuukka Rask appears ready to take over for...

Champion Bruins pack up, head home for 'some rest'

The Bruins tried every tactic possible to avoid the dreaded ''Stanley Cup Hangover.'' They didn't work. Different lineups, different travel schedules, extra rest, you name it. But Boston still slumped through certain times of the regular season, and though it won the Northeast Division and snagged the No. 2 seed in the Eastern Conference playoffs, there the...

Re-Signing Chris Kelly, Developing Dougie Hamilton Keys for Bruins Heading into Offseason (Video)

The Boston Bruins suffered a heart-breaking loss on Wednesday night, dropping Game 7 of their series against the Capitals on a goal just three minutes into the overtime. While the Bruins prepare to clean out their lockers and settle their summer plans, there are still some lingering questions to be answered this coming offseason. Barry Pederson sat down with NESN's Jameson Coyle...

Zdeno Chara Suffered Broken Nose, Tuukka Rask Won't Require Offseason Surgery

Bruins captain Zdeno Chara may be the biggest man to ever toss on an NHL jersey, but the defenseman couldn't avoid injury in the first round of the playoffs against the Capitals. According to the Bruins Twitter account, Chara suffered a broken nose -- likely when Alex Ovechkin's stick came up high on the captain in Game 6. In other injury news, goalie Tuukka Rask will not...

Bruins Thank 'Greatest Fans in Hockey' With Video of 2011-12 Season Highlights (Video)

The Boston Bruins think they have the best fans in the NHL. To show their appreciation, the team released a video on Friday of some of the best highlights from the B's 2011-12 season. The video includes a mix of goals, fights, saves and clips of fans' wild celebrations, with The Wanted's hit song "Glad You Came" playing in the background. Check it out below.

Patrice Bergeron Looking a Lot Like Milan Lucic After Suffering Broken Nose, But Not Sure That's a Good Thing

BOSTON – Playing with a painful oblique injury, Patrice Bergeron definitely didn't feel like himself this postseason. Thanks to a hit by Washington forward Alexander Semin in Game 5, Bergeron didn't end up looking much like himself either. Bergeron said the oblique injury left him at about "60 percent of what I usually am." The missing 40 percent may have been...

Patrice Bergeron Suffered Strained Oblique Muscle in Game 3, No Offseason Surgery Needed

Patrice Bergeron's "upper-body injury" is no longer a mystery. According to Bruins reporter Naoko Funayama, Bergeron told the media on Friday that he injured his oblique muscle in Game 3 and aggravated it in Game 5. Bergeron also suffered a broken nose. Luckily, he won't require offseason surgery, as seen in the tweet below.

Which Eastern Conference Team Are You Rooting for Now That Bruins Have Been Eliminated?

The Bruins' season came to a screeching halt on Wednesday, leaving Boston fans heartbroken that the team's championship reign has come to an end. The NHL playoff field is now down to eight teams, with the Rangers, Devils, Flyers and, of course, Capitals still standing in the Eastern Conference. So who should B's fans be pulling for now that their beloved team will be...

Blast From The Past: Milan Lucic 2006 Draft Picture

Milan Lucic On Draft Day (function(d, s, id) { var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; if (d.getElementById(id)) return; js = d.createElement(s); js.id = id; js.src = "//connect.facebook.net/en_US/all.js#xfbml=1&appId=132297480225654"; fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); }(document, "script", "facebook-jssdk"));

‘Capitals goals shouldn't have counted’ - per Kerry Fraser

When I watched the Washington Capitals score the game winning goal I thought that the refs should review that goal. I thought there was some interference on Thomas by Mike Knuble. According to Veteran NHL Officials Kerry Frasier that goals shouldn't have counted. Last night in Boston reality struck when the series ended with a Game 7 overtime goal that was manufactured by...

Boston Bruins Added to the List of High Seeds Out

                    The Washington Capitals defeated the Boston Bruins in overtime of game seven 2-1. The 2011-2012 season has ended for the Boston Bruins after their 2-1 game seven overtime loss to the Washington Capitals.  It’s unfortunate that the run to repeat ended this early, but I am not too surprised that it did.  There is a reason that the last team to repeat...
NHL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.