Found February 13, 2013 on
Blue Seat Blogs:
Last week on Twitter I posed the simple question: Would you trade Derek Stepan straight up for Ryan O’Reilly? At the time it was just a hypothetical, but last night the Denver Post’s Adrian Dater reported that an O’Reilly trade is likely going to happen.
O’Reilly, of course, is the last of the three star RFAs to continue holding out into the season. Both Jamie Benn and P.K. Subban have been playing with their respective teams for weeks, but O’Reilly and the Avalanche appear to be no closer to a deal.
O’Reilly reportedly wants five-years, $25 million while Colorado, a notoriously stingy franchise, is unwilling to budge from its offers of two-years, $7 million or five-years, $17 million. There seems to be no resolution on the horizon and it’s become very possible that Colorado will trade its star 22-year-old centerman.
The Avalanche presumably wants a #2 center (TSN’s Darren Dreger said a roster player and a top prospect) in return, so Stepan makes sense in that regard (in the sense that Stepan alone could feasibly get a deal done). But O’Reilly’s value is extremely high and he doesn’t have a crazy contract or no-trade clause a la Rick Nash, so there will be no shortage of suitors and there’s probably not much chance Colorado would consider a straight up deal given the other offers O’Reilly would surely fetch.
Still, Rangers fans seemed torn on whether they’d even deal Stepan alone for O’Reilly.
Stepan’s offensive ceiling is higher than O’Reilly’s, but O’Reilly does a little bit of everything. He’s among the best defensive forwards in the league, wins faceoffs, plays on both the power play and penalty kill and has demonstrated tremendous leadership. Stepan is a solid player on both ends of the ice in his own right, but his offensive development has stalled a bit due to his unselfishness and also because he’s not quite fast enough or strong enough to be a star right now. At 23 years old, Stepan still has plenty of time to become a very productive forward, but that’s certainly in question. O’Reilly is a complete player already and would be a perfect fit for coach John Tortorella.
From the financial side of things, Stepan carries a cap hit of only $875k this season, but he will also be an RFA this summer and due for a raise. Even if O’Reilly won’t budge much off his $5 million asking price, the difference between Stepan’s new deal and O’Reilly’s would likely be less than a couple million dollars, so the Rangers could probably make the numbers work even with their upcoming cap issues. (And no, the Rangers won’t be using an offer sheet on O’Reilly because A) They don’t have a first-round pick, B) They can’t afford O’Reilly without shedding future salary, and C) That’s not how the organization does business).
So back to the original hypothetical question: would you pull the trigger on a one-for-one trade? Fans seem split right down the middle on this and while I can understand that the flashes we’ve seen from Stepan are tantalizing, I think this is yet another instance of homegrown bias.
Again, Colorado probably wouldn’t accept Stepan for O’Reilly so this is purely a hypothetical, but would you make that deal? What more would you be willing to add to sweeten the pot, if anything?
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
(Scott Levy/NHLI/Getty Images)
As Brian Boyle continues to sit in the press box, there have been some rumblings about trading him for some defensive depth. There’s some sound logic behind this, as the Rangers desperately need a sixth defenseman capable of 10-15 minutes a night, and Brian Boyle appears to be an asset that has seen a rookie take his roster spot. It makes sense honestly...
Per Jim Cerny, Torts did some re-shuffling of his lines at practice. The biggest move appears to be inserting Brian Boyle back into the lineup, and scratching Chris Kreider. Boyle was centering a line with Taylor Pyatt and JT Miller. This move is likely about two things: Getting Boyle back in the lineup, and giving Miller his fifth and final game as a way to rebound from his poor...
Per Andrew Gross, citing the AHL transaction website, the Rangers have loaned defenseman Steve Eminger to the Connecticut Whale on a two-week conditioning stint. Eminger has played just four games this year for the Rangers, which includes just one game in February. In each of those games, Eminger was used for less than ten minutes per game in each of those contests.
I am Nash. HEAR ME ROAR
It’s Musings day. I’m in Germany as you read this on a game day, so enjoy. Unfortunately the Islanders game is the first game I’ll not have caught live this year to any extent but I’m sure you’ll all cope without me.
The Rangers win in Boston; if that finishes 3-0 then half of Ranger nation will be booking time off to attend the Cup parade. It...
Matt Kalman at NHL.com reports that the recent string of healthy scratches are not sitting well with Brian Boyle...
"I'm trying not to think about anything, really, honestly. I'm just trying to come work every day and work as hard as I can because it's ... I've said it before, I didn't play as well as I think I could've, but I know I can be a good...
NEW YORK, February 13, 2013 – New York Rangers President and General Manager Glen Sather announced today that the club has assigned defenseman Steve Eminger to the Connecticut Whale of the American Hockey League (AHL) for conditioning.
Eminger, 29, has skated in four contests this season, having made his season debut on January 23 against Boston. He has not dressed in six of...
#NYR sticking with same lineup tonight...Lundqvist starts in goal
— New York Rangers (@NYRangers) February 12, 2013
...if it ain't broke don't fix it. Starting to feel bad for Boyle. Ah, who am I kidding, I couldn't care less as long as the Rangers are winning.
In other line-up news, Andrew Gross at the Bergen Record reports that Dan Girardi will be back...
Tonight's matchup with the Bruins marks the New York Rangers' 12th game of the condensed 48-game schedule or, in other words, the quarter pole of the season. If the Blueshirts win their regular-season series finale in Boston, they'll be 7-5 and trending upwards.
After the panic of a 1-3 start, New York has corrected itself by winning five of the last seven games...
This is the type of play that made the New York Rangers want Rick Nash so badly. He singlehandedly made this goal possible with his display of sheer athleticism and awesome hands. All Carl Hagelin had to do was put the puck in the empty net with all of the Boston Bruins defenseman pre-occupied with Nash. If the Rangers can get their act together in time for the playoffs, they...
Through 12 games this season, the Rangers have six, count em, six too many men on the ice penalties. Yes, that means the Rangers have a 50% chance of being assessed one tonight.
I didn't think a team could do that if they tried. It's the most basic part of the game of hockey. I remember learning how to properly administer a line change in Pee Wee hockey. And it's...
Despite only being about a quarter of a way into this condensed season, the Bruins and Rangers met for the third and final time this season on Tuesday night in another matchup of Eastern Conference powerhouse squads.
The Rangers got on the board first 10:37 into the opening period when the Rangers new All-Star forward Rick Nash put forth an outstanding individual effort to create...
2012-2013 Records: Islanders (4-7-1), Rangers (7-5-0)
NYR Leading Scorer: Rick Nash (3-7-10)
NYI Leading Scorer: John Tavares (7-8-15)
NYR Goaltender: Henrik Lundqvist (11 GP, 2.48 GAA, .912 SV%)
NYI Goaltender: Evgeni Nabokov (10 GP, 3.00 GAA, .897 SV%)
New York Rangers Tickets.
Marian Gaborik-Brad Richards-Ryan Callahan
Carl Hagelin-Derek Stepan-Rick Nash...
If there’s one thing the Bruins have shown so far in this shortened season, it’s that they don’t give up–ever. And last night’s 4-3 shootout loss to the New York Rangers only stand to prove that points can be stolen, and enough tenacity from a team can bear good results.
Brad Marchand scored with 43 seconds left to tie the game against the Rangers
That being said, the Bruins...
Boston MA. The New York Rangers came in tonight on their second trip to the Garden and their third meeting with the Bruins over the first month of the shortened NHL season.
The Rangers were the first to strike as Rick Nash drove through the zone drawing three Bruins and Tuukka. Nash fell to the ground but was able to pass the puck to Carl Hagelin who finished it behind an out of...
That is officially what the New York Rangers have and what they will look to do tonight against a struggling New York Islanders' hockey club at Madison Square Garden.
After beating the Boston Bruins 4-3 in a shootout at the TD Garden on Tuesday night, the Rangers have now won three straight games and are starting to find ways to gain traction in an extremely competitive Eastern...