Originally written on Red Light District Hockey  |  Last updated 10/21/14

NEWARK, NJ - FEBRUARY 05: Jonas Gustavsson #50 and Francois Beauchemin #22 of the Toronto Maple Leafs defend against Zach Parise #9 and Dainius Zubrus #8 of the New Jersey Devils at the Prudential Center on February 5, 2010 in Newark, New Jersey. The Devils defeated the Leafs 4-3. (Photo by Jim McIsaac/Getty Images)

By Dan Berlin

With their first playoff berth in almost a decade in sight, it's February and the Toronto Maple Leafs are still without a clear-cut number one goalie.

For the past month, it looked like Jonas Gustavsson was going to be it. Heading into the All-Star break, the "Monster" had been just that -- a beast between the pipes, starting 10 of 11 games for Toronto since the New Year, while posting an impressive 7-2-1 record, with three shutouts to boot. He had seemingly gained the confidence of head coach Ron Wilson and wrestled the starting gig away from consensus pre-season starter James Reimer. Or so we thought.

Then Tuesday night happened. In the team's first game back after the break, Gustavsson reverted to the shaky "Monster" of old, from beast to bust. Staked to a three-goal lead in the third period at Pittsburgh, the Penguins managed to come all the way back, tying the game with under seven seconds left to play. Thanks in no small part to Gustavsson's inability to hold down the fort late in the game, including a real softie that cut the lead to one with five minutes to play. The Leafs eventually lost 5-4 in a shootout.

Enter the revolving door.

On Wednesday, it was Reimer who got the call in goal for the Leafs, in the second game of their back-to-back, home-and-home series with Pittsburgh. Reimer, who has struggled in his return from a concussion suffered in late October and had managed only one start since Jan. 1 -- a 3-2 loss to Ottawa on January 17 -- did himself a huge favour by not only getting the win, but pitching a 25-save shutout in Toronto's 1-0 victory over the Pens. It was his second shutout of the season and first since opening night.

Wilson now has a tough decision to make. Does he go back to Reimer, and give him the chance to build off his solid shutout performance? The answer is a resounding yes, if Wilson believes that there's still a chance that Reimer can regain his stellar form from the second half of last season, and legitimately be the guy to lead his team into the postseason and beyond.

To Reimer's credit, he spent the All-Star break working his butt off, doing two-a-day workouts with a personal trainer in Vancouver, trying to get his mojo back. Reimer needs reps, and there'd arguably be no better time than the present to see if he has what it takes to reclaim the starter's spot in net.

But what about Gustavsson? Just two weeks ago, Wilson showed strong support for his supposed No. 1 (at the time) despite a bad game, giving the 27-year-old Swede the start following a subpar performance in a 3-1 loss to Montreal on Jan. 21. He responded with a 3-0 shutout win over the Islanders two nights later.

While Gustavsson did well to offer some semblance of consistent goaltending during the month of January for the Leafs, he ultimately remains an unproven and enigmatic quantity moving forward this season. Reimer, on the other hand, managed to rekindle some hope among the Leafs faithful that Wednesday night's win could be the start of things to come.

Of course, there are no guarantees. With his glaring weakness high-glove-side, it's more like a 50/50 proposition at best. And there's always the possibility that, if neither guy can assume the reigns as No. 1 in the next few weeks, GM Brian Burke could trade for a goalie (i.e. Evgeni Nabokov) at the deadline.

Truth is, there's not only a ton of pressure on both of these goalies to perform now, but on management as well. Anything less than making the playoffs this season translates to epic failure for the Leafs. Sitting precariously in seventh spot in the East with 31 games to go, they need consistent and solid goaltending from here on out in order to get there.

For now, the revolving door in net continues to turn in Toronto. The question is, when will it stop?

Photos credit: Getty Images
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

C-USA hired PR firm to help Marshall’s playoff chances

Wilson denies rumored Harvin rift, blames media for scrutiny

Report: Cowboys could limit DeMarco Murray's touches

Lakers announce Steve Nash to miss season with back issues

Is Mack Brown the best option for SMU?

Jeremy Kerley on new contract: 'Bentleys for everybody'

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Buss: Any FA who won’t play with Kobe ‘probably a loser’

NFL to start airing its own anti-domestic violence PSAs

Ex-Bronco John Boyett punched cabbie, told cops to call Elway

Former NFL QB still feels effects of concussions every day

Robert Klemko given four-week suspension from The MMQB

Michael Vick: Percy Harvin won't be a monster here

NFL teams facing potential must-win scenarios in Week 8

WATCH: Jeremy Lin poses as Adidas employee for prank

WATCH: Peyton screams at fans to 'shut the f- up!'

Father auctioning off infant son's soccer club allegiance

Love thanks T'Wolves fans in essay for not burning his jersey

WATCH: Browns WR 'kicks out' son over favorite player snub

Memorabilia dealer wants Todd Gurley reinstated immediately

Aaron Rodgers gave girlfriend Olivia Munn a 'special ring'?

The 10 college football programs with most to gain in Week 9

Most disappointing potential dynasties of divisional era

WATCH: OHL hockey coach goes off on reporter: ‘F*** you!’

PK Subban as Michael Jackson at Canadiens' Halloween party

NHL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

NFL teams facing must-win scenarios in Week 8

Programs with a lot on the line this week

Wilson denies rumored Harvin rift

Lakers: Steve Nash out for season

Is Mack Brown SMU's best option?

Are sports leagues finally getting serious about domestic violence?

Brian Urlacher rips Jay Cutler

On Kevin Love, Kyrie Irving and embracing newfound roles

Top NFL storylines: Week 8

Kiffin's mom worried for son's safety

Report: Goodell will have to testify

Penguins do 'O Canada' following tragedy

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.