Former Grand Slam champion Marion Bartoli, alongside Naomi Broady and Tim Henman, joined Sky Sports to break down Naomi Osaka’s stunning victory over Coco Gauff at the US Open. The panel were unanimous: Osaka is back at her very best.
Bartoli opened the discussion emphatically as Osaka booked a Quarter-Final spot to face off against Karolina Muchova for a spot in the US Open semi-finals: “She is absolutely back. She was actually my wild card for the title. And I think Naomi’s right on point because when you look at the performance today, it was absolutely incredible from the word go. She was so dominating from the back of the court, really making the whole play, as we saw Coco not doing much with her forehand.
“Of course, you can emphasise that Coco wasn’t playing her best tennis, but I think it’s fairer to emphasise how great Naomi was. For her to come back and put in this kind of performance on Ashe for the first time this event—although not the first time ever on that court—was absolutely outstanding.”
Broady pointed to Osaka’s flawless opening set as the foundation for her triumph. “She was so clinical right from the get-go. She had a really clear game plan, took all of her breakpoint opportunities in that first set and didn’t face any herself.
“She was really intelligent in targeting Gauff’s forehand, so she didn’t allow Coco to get into those backhand cross-court rallies. Osaka mixed it 50-50 on her own backhand—sometimes cross, sometimes line—but from the forehand side, almost every single ball went back cross-court.
“Her return had huge margins, straight down the middle, using that central channel a lot. Just a really clear tactical plan.”
Henman agreed, adding that Osaka immediately imposed herself. “She wanted to come out and stamp her authority. She knew the two areas she could attack: the Gauff serve and the Gauff forehand. And when you talk about someone being in the zone, that’s exactly what Osaka had—really clear mindset.
“At the other end, Gauff looked so confused. She’s focussing so much on her serve—as we all are—that it’s difficult to play your best tennis, especially against a world-class player making life tough for you.”
Bartoli underlined the psychological difference between the two players. “The contrast in their emotions was so clear. Naomi Osaka was enjoying herself, smiling, so clear in her intent. In contrast, Coco was struggling on everything—even her backhand. She hit over 30 unforced errors in what was a very quick match.
“It’s been a struggle for her mentally throughout this tournament, and today it showed up even more. At the end of the match, she just wanted to get off that stadium as quickly as possible. It’s been so hard, even traumatic at times with the tears on court. She recognised her opponent played great, but she definitely needs some time away to decompress and think about her next move.”
Broady highlighted Osaka’s unwavering focus. “When Mary Jo Fernandez asked her about the crowd, which was largely in favour of Gauff, she said, ‘I didn’t even realise, I was just so locked in.’ That’s despite her last round saying she hoped the crowd would be kind.
“It just shows her intent, her commitment to the game plan. Not only did that help her execute the tennis, but it massively helped her mentally.”
Henman reflected on Osaka’s decision to switch coaches midway through the season, a move that already looks to be paying off. “That run to the final in Canada was big. Yes, it didn’t end the way she wanted, but it made people sit up and take notice. It set her up for this US Open as well.
“She had that coaching change mid-season, which is unusual. Normally you stick it out for a year. Naomi doesn’t usually like to change coaches, but she made that bold change and was rewarded. Straightaway she made the Montreal final, then stuck with the new coach who brings that tactical element.
“I actually know him from his time coaching Agnieszka Radwanska, and of course Iga Świątek—two very smart players on court. He’s adding that same tactical dimension to Osaka’s game. We all knew she had the power, the serve, the forehand—that’s how she won her first Slam. But now, with that tactical edge, she’s even more dangerous.”
Bartoli agreed, praising Osaka’s evolution. “She was so clever today with her placement. If you add that to the raw power she already had, she becomes almost unstoppable.”
Henman, meanwhile, sympathised with Gauff’s difficulties. “With Coco, unfortunately it’s the opposite trend. The serve and forehand frailties under such a spotlight in your home Slam—it must be exhausting. Today she faced a Grand Slam champion at her best, and Osaka took full advantage. Hopefully Gauff now gets some time away from the media spotlight to work on things.”
Broady added that the timing of her struggles made it even tougher. “It was kind of the worst timing. She couldn’t really come into this tournament without addressing the serve. That’s why we were all out there with our cameras and phones watching her work with the biomechanics coach.
“But when you’re serving 16 double faults in a match before a Slam, you can’t just do nothing. It was really bad timing, and she needs to step away, decompress, and rebuild. There’s still plenty of the season left.”
More must-reads:
Get the latest news and rumors, customized to your favorite sports and teams. Emailed daily. Always free!