Originally posted on Fox Sports South  |  Last updated 10/5/12
ATLANTA While ballpark debris and half-empty metal beer bottles littered Turner Field's stage, Sam Holbrook stood resolute in his split-second decision. He never second-guessed: Not when he worried for his safety "Yeah, when cans are flying past your head, yeah, you worry a little bit." not when he and his fellow umpires huddled together near the pitcher's mound, not as Braves manager Fredi Gonzalez exercised every last power a manager has to change Holbrook's ruling. Holbrook, the left field umpire in the Braves-Cardinals one-game Wild Card playoff, which St. Louis won 6-3, made the biggest perhaps most controversial call of the baseball season Friday night. Given the sudden death circumstances, his decision to motion for an infield fly rule nearly halfway to the outfield warning track will remain a point of contention for years in Atlanta. He understands that. But as he and other baseball representatives sat behind microphones following the debacle which caused many of the 52,631 Braves fans in attendance to unload their belongings in protest, Holbrook's expression never changed. He did not back down, either. "I saw the shortstop go back and get underneath the ball where he would have had ordinary effort and would have caught the baseball, and that's why I called the infield fly," Holbrook said. The point of grief for Gonzalez is the interpretation of "ordinary effort." The point of contention for most in attendance without clear understanding of Major League Baseball's rulebook was that the shortstop, Pete Kozma, and his left fielder Matt Holliday suffered a miscommunication. The ball dropped to the ground, apparently giving Atlanta a one-out, bases loaded situation trailing by three runs. Turner Field erupted in delight at their misfortune. "It's an infield fly rule. I was arguing or pretesting that it was not an ordinary effort. I thought that the shortstop had to go way out there to make a play on that flyable, and I think we've got to take into account the crowd," Gonzalez said. "Fifty thousand people yelling, and I thought there was some miscommunication between Holliday and Kozma." Once the overwhelming sense of joy dissipated into disgust, fans began throwing beverages and other items onto the field. After a heated discussion with home plate umpire Jeff Kellogg, Gonzalez officially protested the outcome of the game. Kellogg then went to the phones to discuss the unique, and somewhat scary, scenario he and his fellow umpires were in. After a 19-minute delay, the call was upheld, although the protest for a short while stood. Braves general manager Frank Wren officially withdrew the protest during postgame press conferences. The disappointing result will not change for the Braves, but Holbrook's call remained front and center. How can an umpire make that call when the infielder drops the ball? How can he make that call so far into the outfield? Ultimately, how could this happen? According to the MLB rulebook, an infield fly rule does not have to take place in the infield at all. The rule, which automatically registers an out for the defense on high-hit balls with two men on base, is enacted if an infielder gets under a ball by making an "ordinary effort." The rule, ironically in this scenario, is meant to benefit the offense. If defenses were allowed to let high popups drop, then unfair force outs could occur. So it did not matter that Kozma and Holliday botched the play. Once the ball was on its downward flight, and Holbrook made his call, and that fly ball's fate was sealed. Baseball stuck to its guns and its rulebook in the aftermath. MLB executive vice president Joe Torre, head of umpires Charlie Reliford and home plate umpire Jeff Kellogg all backed Holbrook's call. Reliford and Torre held court for ten minutes following the press conference explaining that even the timing of Holbrook's call was correct, as an umpire can not make a judgment of "ordinary effort" until the ball is, in fact, on its downward flight. "If I was grading a minor umpire who didn't make that call on its downward flight, I would mark him off for that," Reliford said. Exacerbating the matter Friday night was the moment itself the bright lights, the emotion, the tension, the stakes. Baseball is one of the few sports remaining that does not make substantial use of instant replay, so such reactionary judgment calls carry even greater weight. That can be tough on an individual, and that pressure showed on Holbrook's face following the outcome that knocked the Braves out of the postseason and, notably, ended future Hall of Fame third baseman Chipper Jones' career on a sour note. "We're certainly looking at expanding replay, but we're trying to make sure if we do expand it through the technology that it makes sense for baseball," said Torre, a former Braves player and manager. "But, again, baseball has been played a long time, and I'm not looking to hide from this. But the fact that because there's a controversy, baseball has been controversial for a long time." If "baseball has always been this way" is the argument, it is a rather weak one, but, as Jones stated following his final game, the call resides in a gray area. Despite baseball officials circling the wagon around Holbrook, protecting one of their own, there is no black-and-white answer for the Cardinals' defensive predicament. One could easily argue, as Gonzalez did for 19 minutes, that Kozma's long trek back into the outfield was far past "ordinary effort." There is the playoff setting; there are the distracting home fans. Too many factors come into play to say, without a shadow of a doubt, that the right call was made. How baseball's logic be denied? Well, because if Holbrook's had not decided to call infield fly as Andrelton Simmons' popup fell back to Earth, not one complaint would be filed. Baseball executives and its umpires would not have answered any postgame questions. But the painful admission for Braves players, coaches and fans is that the call was not the game's deciding factor. The Braves' defense was atrocious, committing three errors that directly led to five runs. That was the true difference in the game. The assumption can not be made that, even with bases loaded and one out in the eighth, this Atlanta offense could deliver it left 12 men on base against the Cardinals. "Ultimately, three errors cost us the ballgame, mine probably being the biggest," said Jones, whose fourth-inning throwing error kickstarted a three-run Cardinals inning. "Did the call cost us one out? Did it cost us one run, possibly more? Yes. But I'm not willing to sit here and say that that cost us the ball game." In the end, there is no deciphering the unknown. Gonzalez and his players will likely carry some form of protest to their graves. Braves fans will argue tooth and nail that, with all that playoff momentum, Atlanta would have won the first-ever playoff Wild Card if only it weren't for the left field umpire's interpretation of one particular play at one particular time. Sam Holbrook ducked off stage and out of the spotlight as quickly as possible Friday night, turning right where the media turns left, face flush with either excitement or unwanted attention. It didn't even take an ordinary effort to see the man wanted little to do with what transpired at Turner Field Friday night. Right or wrong, baseball paints with shades of gray. Sam Holbrook was just an artist in an unwanted spotlight.
MORE FROM YARDBARKER:
Best athlete by state all time
GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Russell Westbrook leads NBA in scoring, averages a triple-double… and will not start in All-Star Game

John Tortorella challenges LeBron: “Not a chance” he could play hockey

Orioles, Mark Trumbo close to agreeing on 3-year deal

Report: Khris Middleton could return before All-Star break

Over a dozen Steelers players dealing with the flu

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Mike Mularkey: Marcus Mariota ‘should be ready’ for 2017 season

WATCH: Angry fan interrupts Chargers Los Angeles presser

Serena Williams forced a reporter to apologize for saying she played poorly

Pablo Sandoval has 'reshaped himself' this offseason, John Farrell says

Report: Seahawks could lose second-rounder for not disclosing Sherman injury

Kemba Walker on if he should be an All-Star: ‘Not really,'

NFC & AFC Championship preview: We love scoring

Roger Goodell is a coward, but then we knew that

Box Score 1/19: Happy anniversary to the 'Tuck Rule' game

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

TailGreater: Picking the conference champions by their signature cocktails

Clarification Please: Why college basketball needs to ditch the possession arrow

NBA hotline bling: Derrick Rose gets disconnected

The 'What's a Romo worth these days anyway?' quiz

Melo out: How the Knicks can move on from their superstar

Was Jack Capuano the right person to blame for Isles' woes?

Ten NBA players who need a change of scenery

The 2017 Baseball Hall of Fame Ballot, Part 1

All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

QUIZ: Name the owners of these 50 famous NFL nicknames

NFC & AFC Championship preview: We love scoring

Roger Goodell is a coward, but then we knew that

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

TailGreater: Picking the conference champions by their signature cocktails

The 'What's a Romo worth these days anyway?' quiz

Clarification Please: Why college basketball needs to ditch the possession arrow

QUIZ: Name every NCAA men's and women's basketball team with perfect regular seasons

NBA hotline bling: Derrick Rose gets disconnected

Melo out: How the Knicks can move on from their superstar

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker