Found December 04, 2012 on
Waiting For Next Year:
When we talk about the future of the Cleveland Browns, we have a tendency to turn it into a question of who Joe Banner will keep or fire. Certainly that makes a lot of sense with first-time head coach Pat Shurmur; he’s a first-timer in his position and the wins haven’t really piled up making the case that he should continue being a head coach anywhere let alone in Cleveland. It seems logical that he is at the will of his new employers.
Tom Heckert is a different story.
Heckert was reportedly making calls this past August inquiring about new jobs. Those rumors ended up being denied, but the fact that they ever even surfaced is instructive. While Tom Heckert might be under contract with the Browns, he certainly carries his own amount of leverage in this scenario and might just be the one who pulls the trigger on getting out of Cleveland as opposed to being fired.
Why would Tom Heckert want to leave his job with the Browns? Certainly he might have some desire to follow through with the roster rebuild he started here in Cleveland. If he has truly laid a foundation of talent that the team can build off of, it might be a real point of frustration for Heckert to leave and see someone else take it to the next level should that happen. Still, I’m left drawing on my own experience working for various bosses over time.
I was a financial analyst at a big corporation and my five-plus years in that corporation taught me something very valuable about the working world: Jobs are just titles, and they have descriptions, but those jobs vary wildly and drastically depending on who your boss is. I’ve always gravitated toward bosses that I wanted to work for and tried to find ways out of working for bosses I didn’t want to work for. So imagine if your first boss hired you and you were left to be an autonomous department working for a guy who was spending, say, 30 hours per week in the office. Then, that boss retires and is replaced by a control-freak workaholic.
[Related: Joe Banner in Cleveland: When the circus leaves town]
Joe Banner might be a genius. Nobody knows for sure, but one thing’s pretty apparent: Joe Banner will be logging many hours in Berea – certainly you have to think far more than Mike Holmgren – and he will be quite active in overseeing everything that goes on. Obviously, Browns fans hope he is a genius and is wildly successful, but that absolutely doesn’t mean that Tom Heckert signed up to be a GM like this. It might be the same title and the same money, but to say it’s the same job today as it was before Jimmy Haslam III bought the team is almost absolutely false.
So, while this isn’t a report or rumor that is informed by a bunch of sources, if you look at the proliferation of rumor and you look at all the chess pieces on the board, it’s reasonable to predict a couple of ways the pieces could move. Namely, I’m starting to consider that even if the Browns decided that Heckert’s done a good job and would have wanted to keep him, he might not want to continue his employment under the new set of circumstances. I’m not even saying that I think Tom Heckert and Joe Banner hate each other. But I know a lot of people in my life that I like and respect immensely that I absolutely, 100 percent wouldn’t want to work under.
As always, we’ll see how it all shakes out, but I’m less and less optimistic that Tom Heckert will be back. I think Heckert is one of the brightest spots for the Browns since 1999 and I love most of what he’s done with the Browns’ roster but between he and Joe Banner, there’s just no indication in the proverbial tea leaves that this situation is tenable for either one of them. With each passing day and each additional Mike Lombardi rumor the Browns logo on Tom Heckert’s golf shirt fades a little bit more. If we could see his phone records from August we also might find that Heckert’s okay with that.
(Gus Chan / The Plain Dealer)
BEST OF MAXIM
Who caught your eye? Did someone stand out? Who blew it? That’s what were interested in this morning. Winners and losers.
What’s this? Consecutive weeks in which we get to run this feature after a win? Interesting. A guy could get used to this…
WINNER: Josh Gordon. Before we get too crazy, we all agree that Oakland’s defensive backfield is pretty bad. That said, this was...
This time it comes from longtime Pro Football Weekly editor Hub Arkush, as respected a name as there is in the business, who’s hit all the big Cleveland news outlets with his report.
Per Tony Grossi, Arkush says:
“We have it confidentially from very good sources close to the story that Mike [Lombardi] is a strong front-runner for the job. If you work (your) way backwards you’ll...
Browns coach Pat Shurmur sees major progress in his young team and room to grow.
With a game-clinching, 94-yard touchdown drive in the fourth quarter Sunday at Oakland, the Browns (4-8) snapped a 12-game road losing streak and won their second straight game. It's another step forward for Cleveland, which is trying to shake off years of losing and mostly horrendous football....
BEREA The youngest player on the Browns might be the teams biggest playmaker.
Josh Gordon celebrated his 21st birthday in April. Since then, Gordons life has been a whirlwind.
After sitting out a season of college football last Utah for transferring from Baylor, he was contemplating to play college football again or enter the NFL Supplemental Draft.
He chose the latter and the Browns...
Christmas has come early for Cleveland Browns’ fans in two forms. First, the Cleveland Browns were handed a gift wrapped win from their hated rivals, the Pittsburgh Steelers, thanks in large part to the Browns getting eight turnovers. The second way will be revealed on December 4th when “‘NFL Road Tested: The Cleveland Browns” premieres on the Travel Channel.
CLEVELAND (AP) -- The Browns are coming to reality TV.
A new series, "NFL Road Tested: The Cleveland Browns," will premier Tuesday night on the Travel Channel, giving fans a behind-the-scenes look at the NFL team. The five-part series will include features on players and show the inner workings of the team during the regular season. A film crew went to kicker Phil Dawson...
Their record won’t be an indication, but the Cleveland Browns are slowly starting to turn things around. They likely won’t make the playoffs, unless they win out and have a ton of help, but that doesn’t mean they are going just to roll over for teams. Rookies have played huge roles for the Browns this [...]
[[ This is a content summary only. Visit my website for full links...
“Week in and week out, it’s the same — can’t stop the run, can’t stop the pass. Right now I guess we’re just a bad defense. We can’t really hide it. At this point, the numbers don’t allow it. We’re just bad right now.” — Raiders cornerback Michael Huff
“There’s nowhere to go but up, unfortunately.” –Carson Palmer
“Brandon Weeden wore a T-shirt with...
Browns offensive tackle Joe Thomas called former teammate Peyton Hillis ''a terrible distraction'' last season, and said the running back put his contract situation ahead of the team.
Hillis is returning to play in Cleveland this week with the Kansas City Chiefs. Thomas unloaded Wednesday on Hillis, saying he didn't always play hard and called his time with the...
After what seemed like years of spending high draft picks on the defensive side of the ball, the Browns focused on the offense this past April. RB Trent Richardson came off the board first, a pick higher than the Browns even had going into the draft. At number twenty-two in the first round the Browns grabbed QB Brandon Weeden. RT Mitchell Schwartz was the pick in round number two...
Since 1999 there hasn’t been much positive to come the Cleveland Browns way, however with new ownership come fresh ideas. The Browns will be the focus of a Travel Channel show that chronicles the life of an NFL team as they travel on the road. The debuts tonight December 4 [...]
Kansas City at Cleveland Sunday, 1:00 p.m. ET, at Cleveland Browns Stadium, Cleveland - TV: CBS; DirecTV: 709 *TV announcers: Bill Macatee, Steve Tasker *Keys to the game: The critical battle for the Chiefs will be the early carries for RB Jamaal Charles in the ground game. With the passing game ineffective and Browns CB Joe Haden typically able to shut down his half of...