Found June 19, 2012 on Fox Sports:
Believe me, it pains me in the gizzard to speak negatively of any stab at boxing reform, especially one as near and dear to my heart as the establishment of a national commission. But the Professional Boxing Amendments Act of 2012 is not the immediate answer to boxing's long-standing need for sanity. Co-sponsored by Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., the legislation is nearly identical to the one previously introduced by McCain and voted down several times in the past. This time, it only stands a slightly better chance of approval because of the controversy surrounding the June 9 Manny Pacquiao-Timothy Bradley decision and the involvement of heavy-hitter Reid. The legislation would establish the US Boxing Commission, an organization dedicated to establishing and enforcing federal mandates regarding the regulation of fights, fighter safety, boxing-related business and officiating. According to McCain, the USBC would "work with the boxing industry and local commissions to improve the safety, integrity, and professionalism of professional boxing in the United States." However, some fatal flaws are built into the legislation that could render it useless before it even becomes enacted. First, the USBC still would operate in deference to the sanctioning bodies -- WBA, WBC, IBF and WBO -- which still would be allowed to "provide a list of judges and referees deemed qualified" for any given title fight, eliminator or other officially sanctioned bout. While the commission would have final say as to who actually officiates, this is not much different than the current system in place, which allows state commissions to assign officials from a list of "acceptable" judges and referees pre-approved by the sanctioning body and promoter. If there's any part of the boxing process that's in real need of reform, it's in the selection of the officials and the often incestuous relationship between who gets which assignments and how one becomes pre-approved for jobs. The Professional Boxing Amendments Act of 2012 doesn't address this issue at all; it merely passes the buck from the state to the federal level. Another problem with the legislation involves the co-sponsor, Reid. The long-standing senator from Nevada is waist-deep in the Las Vegas boxing culture, has personal friendships with many of the sport's power brokers and top officials and also counts promoters Bob Arum and Don King among his financial donors. Would Reid be eager to go on the offensive against people pumping so much money into the state economy and into his own political war chest? A third problem is enforcement. While the USBC would have the power to suspend or ban any fighter, official, promoter or manager in violation of regulations, the actual enforcement of these penalties in a sport like boxing would require massive federal involvement. With a long-established subculture of corruption and coercion, boxing has proven itself to be almost impossible to clean up, even by agencies like the FBI, which frequently investigate obvious frauds, but only manage to bring down a few patsies from the fringes of the sport. McCain has been active in trying to enact boxing reforms in the past and has succeeded in passing the Muhammad Ali Boxing Reform Act, which was aimed at improving the working conditions of the fighters and protecting them in their business dealings with promoters and managers. Still, violations frequently occur and fighters who balk at mistreatment face loss of payment and the promise of a lengthy legal battle if they make waves. Any attempt at reform at the national level has to be iron-fisted, intensive and worked by outsiders, without ties to the industry in any way. By allowing for state and local commissions to have their say and keeping the sanctioning bodies in the mix, the USBC is all but assuring itself to be little more than a paper tiger, designed to appease fans and issue a few token punishments here and there, but not much else. There are also concerns regarding the funding of the commission. The legislation currently forces the promoters, managers and fighters to foot the bill for the extra branch of regulation, something that could hit those on the bottom rungs of boxing's socioeconomic ladder the hardest. Having said that, it might be worth the effort to pass, if only actually to have the commission in existence. With true efforts at reform only coming along once every century or so, the boxing community has to grab at whatever is offered. The Professional Boxing Amendments Act of 2012 lacks the punch to actually reform the sport to an acceptable degree, but the mere establishment of a national commission is a baby step in the right direction. And, who knows? Maybe some hotshot politician will come along one day, take that national commission and actually do some good with it. Hell, waiting for someone to do some good with a national boxing commission is infinitely better than hoping for Bob Arum or the Boxing Promoters Association to "get to the bottom" of boxing corruption.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES
ROB JOB

Judges' review: Pacquiao won fight

The WBO had some judges review the Manny Pacquiao-Timothy Bradley fight that ended with a controversial decision. Their findings ...

Timothy Bradley Says He Wants A Rematch Against Manny Pacquiao

Tuesday night, Timothy Bradley sat down for a live internet chat interview where he claimed he wanted a rematch against Manny Pacquiao, who he fought just 10 days ago and won (via) a split decision.The Desert Sun in Palm Springs hosted the live interview, were Bradley discussed the harsh and sometime painful aftermath of the fight against Pacquiao. "The first couple of days...

AG rules on Pacquiao-Bradley bout

The state attorney general in Nevada says she found no illegalities and no criminal wrongdoing in boxer Manny Pacquiao's controversial split-decision loss to Timothy Bradley in a welterweight title fight last month in Las Vegas. An aide to Attorney General Catherine Cortez Masto on Tuesday called the matter closed. Top Rank chief executive Bob Arum manages both fighters. He...

Pacquiao-Bradley furor reaches Senate

Giving voice to the outrage over Timothy Bradley's controversial split decision over Manny Pacquiao, two senators introduced legislation Monday that would create a special boxing commission to oversee all matches in the United States and restore integrity to the sport. Sen. John McCain, R-Ariz., who boxed while at the U.S. Naval Academy, and Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid...

Senators push bill to battle fraud in boxing

Two senators are pushing legislation to establish oversight of professional boxing after Timothy Bradley's controversial split decision over Manny Pacquiao in a welterweight title bout. Republican Sen. John McCain of Arizona and Senate Democratic leader Harry Reid of Nevada introduced legislation Monday that would create the U.S. Boxing Commission. McCain said it would bring...

Manny Pacquiao Wins WBO Review, Wants Bradley Again

Manny Pacquiao says he wants a rematch with Timothy Bradley after a five-judge panel assembled by the WBO championship committee unanimously favored the Filipino fighter in a video review. Pacquiao said Thursday he would prefer a rematch rather than Bradley giving up the WBO welterweight title that he won on a split decision because “people may think I just usurped it.” The...

The Pacquiao-Bradley fix continues as a rematch looms

I still contend that Manny Pacquiao was in on the fix. The 33 year old fighter only has a few good years left, and without the Floyd Mayweather bout in his future he had nothing to sell. His last few fights have been dogs. Interesting is dropping, quickly. His  fight against Timothy Bradley didn’t sell [...]

HBO Boxing: It’s All Part of Their Plan

It's All Part of the Plan

If Floyd Mayweather isn’t interested, Timothy Bradley will consider scrapping Amir Khan

After avoiding “King Khan” like anthrax for roughly two-years, WBO welterweight titleholder “Desert Storm” Timothy Bradley told the Desert Sun today that he is considering fighting former IBF and WBA world light welterweight champion Amir Khan in the near future. … Continue reading →

WBO Review Means Manny Pacquiao Wins... Nothing

If nothing else, the WBO review of Manny Pacquiao's loss to Timothy Bradley means we can all feel better about our sanity and can trust our own eyes.Actually, it really does mean nothing else. Sure, five other judges took a look at the fight and all of them scored it for Pacquiao. That's hardly surprising, and it's pretty easy for them to have done so after the fact....

Timothy Bradley predicts Juan Manuel Marquez will beat Manny Pacquiao in November

Rather than exercise his negotiated rematch clause, WBO welterweight titleholder “Desert Storm” Timothy Bradley believes Manny Pacquiao will instead battle WBA, WBO and The Ring lightweight royalty “Dinamita” Juan Manuel Marquez for a fourth time on November 10 in either … Continue reading →

The World’s 100 Hightest-Paid Athletes via Forbes

If you're still reeling about that horrendous decision in the Manny Pacquiao/Timothy Bradley fight, here's more ammunition.  Forbes Magazine recently released its annual list ranking the world's highest-paid athletes.  Boxing's two biggest mone

Pacquiao wants rematch with Bradley

Manny Pacquiao says he wants a rematch with Timothy Bradley after the sanctioning body reviewed their controversial bout of June 9 and said the Filipino fighter should have been given the decision.

All five WBO judges who reviewed fight gave it to Manny Pacquiao, but decision won’t be overturned

Boxing’s leadership and phony organizations remain as pointless as ever. The WBO, which gave Timothy Bradley a shot at Manny Pacquiao’s welterweight champion belt on June 9 in Las Vegas, conducted a review of the controversial decision. All five WBO judges who reviewed the fight scored it in favor of Pacquiao. In fact, Pac Man won 9 rounds to 3 on average based on these judges’...
Boxing News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.