Posted April 23, 2013 on AP on Fox
Two former Syracuse University basketball ball boys have asked a judge to reinstate their slander lawsuit against the school and head coach Jim Boeheim over comments the Hall of Famer made following the firing of his longtime assistant amid a sex abuse scandal. Attorneys for Bobby Davis and Mike Lang filed a 54-page brief with the Appellate Division of state Supreme Court in Rochester in March. State Supreme Court Justice Brian DeJoseph threw out their lawsuit in May, ruling that comments made by Boeheim after assistant coach Bernie Fine was fired were not statements of fact but were opinions that are protected from defamation lawsuits. Davis and Lang say Boeheim slandered them in November 2011 when he publicly called them liars only out for money when they accused Fine of molesting them as children. Their claims could not be investigated criminally because they did not fall within the statute of limitations. Fine has denied the allegations and a federal investigation into a third man's claim did not find enough evidence to warrant criminal charges. Fine has served notice that he plans to sue ESPN for airing claims made by Davis and Lang. After the allegations of sexual abuse surfaced, Boeheim vehemently supported Fine, a friend for more than 40 years and his assistant for 35-plus seasons. Boeheim told ESPN that Davis was telling ''a bunch of a thousand lies'' and called him an opportunist looking to cash in on the publicity surrounding the then-emerging Penn State sex-abuse scandal. ''The content, tone and purpose of Boeheim's statements would clearly signal to the reasonable reader that what was being said in the articles published in the days after the initial ESPN report were likely to be an opinion -- a biased, passionate, and defensive point of view of a basketball coach -- rather than objective fact,'' DeJoseph wrote in his 30-page decision. The lawyer for Davis and Lang, Mariann Meier Wang, wrote in the brief filed March 13 that DeJoseph should have allowed the case to go to a jury. ''The lower court's opinion should be reversed,'' Wang wrote. ''A reasonable person reading Boeheim's statements readily could conclude that he was asserting specific and damning facts, not merely blowing off steam and voicing an opinion about an old friend.'' Lawyers for Boeheim and the university filed their response last week, arguing that Boeheim's comments were opinions and thus protected by free speech.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Syracuse ex-ball boys appeal slander suit ruling

Two former Syracuse University basketball ball boys are asking a judge to reinstate their slander lawsuit against the school and coach Jim Boeheim. Attorneys for Bobby Davis and Mike Lang filed a 54-page brief with the Appellate Division of state Supreme Court in Rochester in March. State Supreme Court Justice Brian DeJoseph threw out the lawsuit in May, ruling that comments made...

NBA.com’s David Aldridge Claims In Article That SU Forward C.J. Fair Has Declared For The NBA Draft

suathletics.com Typo, or leak? NBA.com’s David Aldridge wrote an article yesterday about the small forwards of the 2013 class, claiming that Syracuse star C.J. Fair had already declared for the NBA Draft. While many believe Fair will in fact go pro, he hasn’t made any decision public, though he is scheduled to have a press conference this week to update the school and fans on...

C.J. Fair Returns to Syracuse, Restores Faith in NBA Decision Process

SU Athletics Sanity prevailed in C.J. Fair’s decision on whether to jump to the NBA. “After talking it over with my family and my coaches, I decided another year at Syracuse was best for me. I’m excited about working hard with my teammates to put together another great season and graduating has also been a goal of mine.” First off, this gives the Orange a major boost going...

Orange's Fair returning for 2013-14

Syracuse's C.J. Fair is returning for his senior season. The Orange's leading scorer and rebounder last season announced his decision Wednesday, saying another year of college basketball and graduating are in his best interests. The return of Fair, who averaged 14.5 points and 6.9 rebounds last season, gives coach Jim Boeheim a nice boost as Syracuse transitions to the...

C.J. Fair Coming Back to Syracuse for Senior Season

We interrupt your regularly-schedule programming to alert you to a change in the Syracuse Orange Basketball C.J. Fair Headband Threat Level System. Due to recent developments, we have lowered the C.J. Fair Headband Threat Level from YELLOW to ORANGE (C.J. is staying!). We have lowered the CJFHTL due to the announcement that the Commence Jubiliation Fair (H/T: Matt) is returning...

Star QB A.J. Long Says His Recruitment is Done, He’s Sticking with Syracuse

A.J. Long made his way back to Syracuse last weekend and sat on the 30-yard line inside the Carrier Dome for the Spring Game. Long tells The Fizz the experience was more than he expected it to be, and it’s solidified his decision from a month ago when he committed to the Orange. “After this past visit, my commitment is stronger than ever. My deal is done and I’m done with...

Ryan Nassib Will be Number 1 QB.

The 2013 NFL Draft might not be packed full with top flight quarterbacks, but this draft could be important for one young man who not many people know about Ryan Nassib. Nassib is a 23 year old from West Chester, PA who played his college ball a Syracuse University. He [...]

Exclusive: Syracuse OG Zach Chibane Pre-Draft Interview

    It was nice to catch up with my good friend, Zach Chibane of the Syracuse Orange. Zach is headed to the NFL after a stand-out career on Doug Marrone’s offensive line at Syracuse University. I had the opportunity to chat with Zach again recently about his path to the draft since we had last spoken. Zach is excited to hear he may be drafted as high as the 5th round on Saturday...

Fizz Four: A Quartet of Syracuse Players Talk the Summer’s Biggest Storylines

Although there won’t be another SU football game inside the Carrier Dome for another five months, the Spring Game provided Orange Nation a final glimpse into what to expect this fall. Terrel Hunt shined in his debut, Prince-Tyson Gulley erased his signature dreadlocks, and Scott Shafer enjoyed every moment with the Syracuse fans. We take the Fizz Fam under the Fizz Microscope...
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.