Found October 13, 2012 on Fox Sports:
Was there a Cardinal sin committed in South Bend on Saturday? Maybe two. No. 7 Notre Dame beat No. 17 Stanford, 20-13, in overtime. But in my opinion, the Irish had the benefit of two controversial calls that not only helped the Irish tie the game to force overtime, but also prevented the Cardinal from scoring the game-tying touchdown in overtime. Let's start with the the last play of the game. Here was the situation: Stanford had the ball, fourth-and-goal from the Notre Dame 1-yard line in overtime, with the Irish leading 20-13. Stanford running back Stepfan Taylor appeared to be stopped at the goal line, but on second effort, turned and fell into the end zone. The ruling on the field was that Taylor was stopped short and after a review, the call stood. I've looked at the play from every angle and I think the call should have been reversed to a touchdown. It would certainly appear that forward progress was not ruled and Taylor was not down. The ball broke the plane before it came loose, which makes that aspect of it irrelevant. Also irrelevant is when the whistle was blown, because just like when a runner is ruled down and it turns out to be a fumble, the play is reviewed all the way through to the end result. The first thing that needs to be established is whether or not the ball broke the plane of the goal line. That seemed pretty easy to see. The ball did come loose, but had already broken the plane. The officials then needed to determine if Taylor was down. This was one of those plays that you had to look at from every angle. The closest part of Taylor's body to the ground was his left elbow, but it seemed pretty apparent to me that by piecing the different shots together that the elbow did not touch the ground until after the ball had crossed the plane. The shot that convinces me is the field-level shot from inside, not the shot from the outside that is down the goal line. Taylor extends the ball beyond the plane before the elbow is down. One thing you may not know: In college, the review decision is made totally by the replay official upstairs in the booth, not the officials down on the field. The second play came on Notre Dame's game-tying drive. Here was the situation: Notre Dame had the ball, first-and-16 at the Notre Dame 47-yard line with 3:38 left in the fourth quarter and Stanford led 13-10. Notre Dame quarterback Everett Golson carried the ball four yards, but as he was being tackled and going to the ground, he was hit in the helmet area by Stanford's Usua Amanam. Stanford was penalized 15 yards for unnecessary roughness. Of course, I have the luxury of watching it in slow motion, but to me, this shouldn't have been called a foul. Golson was being tackled and was almost to the ground when hit by Amanam with his upper arm, not his shoulder or helmet. Golson was a runner at this point and he should not have been deemed defenseless unless, as the rule states, he was already on the ground. He was not down when the contact occurred. Officials are told to err on the side of safety and I think that was the case here. But it's a big call at a big point in the game. I can see why the official made the call, because it looked a lot uglier in real time. But it's a call that I think should not have been made. Stanford certainly had no luck on these two calls. All of that went to the Irish.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES
REPLAY SAYS

ND-Stanford ends in controversy

Notre Dame beat Stanford on a controversial last play that was reviewed and upheld by the officials. Did the running back score?

Stanford-Notre Dame ends on controversial replay ruling

Notre Dame beat Stanford 20-13 on Saturday after the referees reviewed a 4th and goal play in overtime and ruled that Cardinal running back Stepfan Taylor was short of the goal line. The Cardinal handed the ball to Taylor, who had 28 carries for 102 yards, on their final play of the game. After initially appearing to be stuffed in the backfield, Taylor kept moving and wiggled his...

Dirty Dozen: The Tough Luck Trophy Edition

James Vaughters, Cardinal slaughters. Henry Anderson "Cooper". Levine Toilolo, how low can you go-go? It's free association hour, and it's time to let our minds play. It's a look at the lighter side in this week's Dirty Dozen, courtesy of TreeBoy. (And what's with that name, anyway?)

Notre Dame Holds Stanford in Goal Line Stand, 20-13 in OT

Notre Dame holds Stanford running back Stepfan Taylor on fourth-and-1 at the goal line, winning its sixth straight game without a loss in its most promising season since 2002. (Photo: Jonathan Daniel) Did we just witness another Notre Dame classic? Notre Dame knew that Stanford was not going to be an easy win. But they

No. 7 Notre Dame 20, No. 17 Stanford 13, OT

Notre Dame knew what was coming. Stanford doesn't get cute inches from the goal line. And after three years of getting pushed around by the Cardinal, the Fighting Irish pushed back, winning the most important shoving match they've had all season. Or did they? A wall of Notre Dame defenders stopped Stepfan Taylor inches from the end zone on fourth down in overtime and the...

No. 22 Stanford tries to move past Notre Dame loss

With the 30th anniversary of the famous lateral play surrounding this week's Stanford-California rivalry, Cardinal coach David Shaw was asked for his opinion about the controversial call given the benefit of replay all these years later. Shaw responded: ''You're asking me about replay?'' Indeed, this is not the week. Shaw said Monday he believes running...

Are undefeated Irish lucky or good?

Notre Dame had already stopped him once at the goal line. And the Irish knew Stanford would power the ball in Stepfan Taylor's hands again. Everyone knew. For Notre Dame, one more stop and it would be over. Simple as that. "I love you guys,'' Notre Dame linebacker Manti Te'o said in the huddle, in the emotion of a game-ending, goal-line stand. "No matter...

Notre Dame remains undefeated

TJ Jones made a reaching 7-yard touchdown catch in overtime and No. 7 Notre Dame stopped Stanford inches from the goal line to beat the 17th-ranked Cardinal 20-13 Saturday. After Jones and Tommy Rees gave the Fighting Irish (6-0) a seven-point lead in OT, Stanford (4-2) drove to a first-and-goal at the 4. Stepfan Taylor ran for 1 on first, 2 on second and inches on third down....
Cardinal News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.