Found November 13, 2011 on College Football Section:
Konica_minolta_gator_889b

So I’ve read a lot about the “terrible calls” made during the Miami at Florida State game, and decided to take a look. There were several calls that were made that were definitely incorrect, and there were a few that were made that were correct. Overall, the officials should not decide the outcome of the game.

Jump to the video A rundown of the calls after the break.

 

1. FSU fumble recovery called back because Miami player didn’t have control of the ball. Miami player caught the ball, turned and made two steps.

FSU Miami Play 1 650x328 Miami at FSU Officials and Nigel Bradhams Hit

Ruled that he didn't have control.

FSU Miami Play 1a 650x328 Miami at FSU Officials and Nigel Bradhams Hit

Ruled Miami player didn't have control

2. FSU penalized for intentional grounding in the endzone that resulted in a safety. This call was overturned after replay official got it correct, but it’s still hard to understand how it wasn’t correct on the field.

FSU Miami Play 2 650x328 Miami at FSU Officials and Nigel Bradhams Hit

Ruled pass was made in endzone.

FSU Miami Play 2a 650x330 Miami at FSU Officials and Nigel Bradhams Hit

Ruled in the endzone

3.  FSU penalized for a holding on the kickoff return. Grasping at straws here, but it looks like a legit block.

FSU Miami Play 3 650x328 Miami at FSU Officials and Nigel Bradhams Hit

FSU penalized for holding on kickoff returned for TD, it's close

4. FSU penalized for running into the kicker on a punt. Call made was INcorrect. FSU player’s helmet hits the kickers leg. The call should not have been roughing, but running into the kicker, which is only a 5 yard penalty instead of the 15 yarder. (edited, thanks to Xterra1945 for pointing out that the call was incorrect)

FSU Miami Play 4 650x329 Miami at FSU Officials and Nigel Bradhams Hit

FSU player roughing the kicker. Very close, but helmet does hit his leg.

5. FSU player, Nigel Bradham was ejected for leading with his helmet and launching himself on a hit on LaRon Byrd. Doesn’t look like Bradham lead with helmet and he did not leave the ground when he made the hit. While the hit may be considered “dirty”, it was a legal hit.

FSU Miami Play 5 Miami at FSU Officials and Nigel Bradhams Hit

Nigel Bradham ruled FSU player led with helmet, clearly shoulder

FSU Miami Play 5a Miami at FSU Officials and Nigel Bradhams Hit

Nigel Bradham was ruled to have launched himself at Byrd

Here’s a video of the Nigel Bradham hitting LaRon Byrd

Click here to view the embedded video.

Here’s a video of all of the calls

Click here to view the embedded video.

Miami at FSU Officials and Nigel Bradham’s Hit is a post from: The College Football Section

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

'Noles linebacker won't sit after disputed hit

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. Florida States leading tackler, linebacker Nigel Bradham, will not be suspended for the home game Saturday against Virginia after being ejected following his fourth-quarter hit on a Miami receiver. Bradham was flagged for launching his body and hitting a defenseless player, LaRon Byrd, as the Miami receiver tried to catch a pass from Jacory Harris late in the...

Mistakes, penalties spell doom for UM

No question about it, Florida State was outplayed by Miami for a good portion of Saturday's contest. But the Seminoles took better care of the ball and didn't make as many errors in a 23-19 victory.

With rival Miami, a win is a win for FSU

When Florida State and Miami get together, while the games tend to be physical and hotly contested, rarely are they truly well played. Saturday's 23-19 win for FSU was the latest example.

Seminoles Speak: 'Noles 23, 'Canes 19

Florida State didn't get many breaks and once again needs to make a call to the ACC office to chat about officiating. Here's an array of quotes from players in the turf room after a 23-19 win over Miami.

U-C-F (1-0) at Florida State (1-0) (ET)

U-C-F (1-0) at Florida State (1-0) (ET)

UF Football Game Against Florida State To Begin At 7 p.m. On ESPN2

The start time for the Gator football team's regular-season finale against Florida State at Ben Hill Griffin Stadium on Nov. 26 will be at 7 p.m. and the game will be shown on ESPN2.

M. Tennis. Noles Sign Palm City's Rinaldi

Florida State head coach Dwayne Hultquist and the Florida State administration announced that Michael Rinaldi signed a National Letter of Intent to play tennis for the Seminoles next season.

W. Soccer. Brockway Earns Weekly Honor

Florida State's Tiana Brockway was named to TopDrawerSoccer.com's Team of the Week after scoring a goal and leading the Seminole defense to a shutout in the first round of the NCAA Tournament.

No. 25 Florida State rolls past UCF (AP)

Florida State's Bernard James has been known mostly for his defense and shot-blocking skills. That may be changing. The 6-foot-10 James had 18 points and 11 rebounds -- career-highs in both -- on Monday while notching his fifth career double-double to lead the 25th-ranked Seminoles to a 73-50 victory over Central Florida.

Virginia Heads to Florida State on Saturday At 7:30 p.m.

Cavaliers on a three-game win streak

NoleDigest Video: UM-FSU Recruiting

Florida State's win over Miami was witnessed by a lot of top recruits in Tallahassee. Laura McKeeman and Geoff Vogt tell you who was there, who wasn't and what it means for the 'Noles in recruiting.

Cross Country. Broom, Broom!

The Florida State men's and women's cross country teams punched their tickets to the NCAA Championships, capturing NCAA South Region titles in dominating fashion Saturday.

Recap: Florida State vs. U-C-F

Bernard James scored 18 points and grabbed 11 rebounds to lead the 25th-ranked Florida State Seminoles past the UCF Knights, 73-50.
Seminoles News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.