Found November 15, 2012 on Midwest Sports Fans:
Mlb-all-star-futures-game
[Editor's note: Be sure to check the end of this post for an exciting new MSF feature, The Debate Zone, where YOU can chime in on one of the most intense AL MVP debates of all time.] Let me establish a few things right off the bat: Nate Silver is a friggen’ genius. Mike Trout will not win the AL MVP. The first fact should come as no surprise. Read anything from Silver’s FiveThirtyEight blog at the New York Times, and you will come away a wiser person for doing so. Silver became an overnight phenomenon last week, but baseball fans have known about Silver’s passion for baseball for quite sometime. He’s nothing short of brilliant, and because of this fact people tend to listen what he has to say. I was fully prepared to write this post before reading this article, which was released yesterday. So thanks, Nate, for stealing my thunder. Which brings me to point No. 2. Despite all of the statistical evidence that leans in Mike Trout’s favor, I can’t see how he wins the AL MVP when the award winners are announced Thursday. And that’s wrong. [Commentary: Cabrera's Triple Crown Trumps Trouts Unprecedented Rookie Success] A Superlative Season For Cabrera… Miguel Cabrera had a heck of a regular season for the Detroit Tigers. And remember, the MVP is a regular season award. Cabrera will win MVP, even though he was only the second most valuable player in the AL. A .330 average, 139 RBI, and 44 home runs made Cabrera the first Triple Crown winner since Carl Yastrzemski in 1967. It’s those two words – Triple Crown – that will sway enough writers from the BBWAA to vote Cabrera in as the MVP. I’ll be the first to say that his season was remarkable, but to say that he was the Most Valuable Player in the American League is a disservice to Mike Trout. …Just Not As Valuable as Trout’s The guidelines for winning the MVP are ambiguous at best. The BBWAA website describes the voting process as such: “There is no clear-cut definition of what Most Valuable means. It is up to the individual voter to decide who was the Most Valuable Player in each league to his team. The MVP need not come from a division winner or other playoff qualifier.” Tigers Were Not “Better” Than Angels It’s a fact that the Tigers advanced farther than the Los Angeles Angels this season. That’s easy to do when only one, Detroit, actually makes the playoffs. But that’s not saying that the Tigers are a better team. One fact that many pundits have overlooked is that the Angels actually had a better record than the Tigers. Don’t believe me? It’s true. Detroit finished first in the AL Central at 88-74 while Los Angeles was 89-73 and third in the AL West. Los Angeles was unfortunately behind the powerhouse Texas Rangers and upstart Oakland Athletics in the West, while the Tigers’ only real threat in the Central was the White Sox. So don’t even start with that excuse, that Cabrera is the MVP because his team was better. It’s not going to fly here. Stats Say Trout’s Season Superior I could present all of the statistical analysis in the world, but that sort of breakdown is going to come with a lot more credibility from a guy like Nate Silver, and I’m not going to fight that. Like I said before, the guy is brilliant. So let’s piggyback off his research and show all of the things that Trout did, and that Cabrera didn’t, which made Trout MORE VALUABLE player in the American League this season. 1) Base running Trout finished with 49 stolen bases in 54 chances, an unreal 91% for that many attempts. Cabrera? Four stolen bases in five attempts. 2) Defense Often overlooked in MVP voting, this one is another no-contest that should not be ignored. Defense is a big reason why Trout should be named MVP.   Trout played Gold Glove-caliber defense in centerfield. Granted, Trout and Cabrera play very different positions, but there’s a stat for that. It’s called Ultimate Zone Rating. It’s sabermetric and a little complex, but if Silver uses it as an argument, so will I. Trout saved his team 11 runs on defense over the course of the season, while Cabrera cost the Tigers 10 runs over the course of the season at first base. Easy math: That’s a 21-run swing. 3) Triple Crown The candidacy for Cabrera as AL MVP starts and ends with those three offensive categories. Cabrera was first in the AL with a .330 batting average, with Trout on his heels in second place at .326. I’ll admit that there is a bigger gap in the other two categories (RBI: 139 to 83, HR: 44 to 30), but remember this: Trout is a leadoff hitter. His job was to get on base and allow the heart of the order to drive him in. He did that better than Cabrera (On-base percentage: .399 to .393), good for third in the AL behind singles machine Joe Mauer (.419) and the guy giving Cabrera protection in the line-up, Prince Fielder (.412). Let’s go back to the criteria for MVP. The first thing mentioned in the guidelines set by the BBWAA when voting for MVP is this: Actual value of a player to his team, that is, strength of offense and defense. Both were undeniably valuable to their teams. But what Trout did on offense, defense, and on the basepaths made him more valuable to the Angels than Cabrera is to the Tigers. And that’s what the award comes down to. Mike Trout deserves to win the AL MVP, yet he will likely not do so because of the allure of the “Triple Crown,” and I think that’s plain wrong. I guarantee this will be one of those awards that baseball folk will look back on and say, how was Mike Trout not voted MVP? Oh yeah, by the way. Trout was only a rookie. #MikeTrout4MVP [Commentary: Settling The Mike Trout v Miguel Cabrera AL MVP Debate: One Has Clearly Been More “Valuable” Than The Other] ***** The Debate Zone You’ve heard what Daniel has to say in defense of Cabrera. You’ve also heard from Chris has to say. Now it’s your turn. Check out our new feature here at MSF: The Debate Zone. Just click and record your 30-second argument, and readers, as well as our team of writers, will vote on whose argument is the best. The AL MVP will be announced later today; we’ll announce the debate winner in three days. ***** The post AL MVP Debate: Mike Trout Will Not Win…And That’s Wrong appeared first on Midwest Sports Fans.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Does Mike Trout have a shot at pulling an AL MVP upset?

It is a foregone conclusion that when the American League MVP award is announced later today that Miguel Cabera will be declared the winner.  The logic goes that Cabrera and his Triple Crown will simply be too much for the more traditional voters that make up a major bloc in the Baseball Writers Association of America.  No matter how much stat-friendly pundits, including super...

Halo Headlines: Trout unanimous pick for AL Rookie of the Year, Trout ready to move to left, ...

The November 13th, 2012 edition of daily news for the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim including Trout unanimous pick for AL Rookie of the Year, Trout ready to move to left, assessing the risk with Zack Greinke's mental health and much more... The Story: Mike Trout was the unanimous winner of the American League Rookie of the Year award. The Monkey Says: I think he even...

Debate: making cases for both Miguel Cabrera and Mike Trout for AL MVP

Tonight, we will finally learn the MVP of the American League, a contest that really comes down to two candidates in Miguel Cabrera of the Detroit Tigers and Mike Trout of the Los Angeles Angels. For the majority of the 2012 season the debate raged on who should ultimately take home the prize with traditionalist seemingly siding with Cabrera while the sabermetric junkies simply fell...

Miguel Cabrera’s Consistency, Production, Sacrifice Make Him Right Choice For AL MVP

The right man won the American League MVP. While Mike Trout had a phenomenal campaign as a rookie, Miguel Cabrera deserved the 22 first-place votes that landed him the award. At the end of the day, it comes down to baseball not computer stats. With 44 home runs, 139 RBIs and a .330 batting average, Cabrera became Major League Baseball’s first Triple Crown winner in 45 years. To...

Halo Headlines: Angels 'low-balled' Hunter, Trout nominated for SI Sportsman of the Year, ...

The November 14th, 2012 edition of daily news for the Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim including Angels 'low-balled' Hunter, Trout nominated for SI Sportsman of the Year, statistical revolution still won't be strong enough to make Mike Trout the AL MVP and much more... The Story: The Angels "insulted" Torii Hunter with an offer of a one-year, $5 million contract...

Is Mike Trout's Rookie Of The Year Campaign The All-Time Best Angels Single Season Player Performance Ever?

Vlad Guerrero won the 2004 MVP award while with the Angels Well, there's a lot to cover so without further ado, here's our AngelsWin.com top five all-time best Angels player performances in the history of Angels Baseball according to us. 1. Nolan Ryan Nolan Ryan's dominance over opposing hitters and strikeout record set in 1973 will be talked about...

The La Morte Report: Miguel Cabrera Hands Down!

I’m going to keep this extremely short! Miguel Cabrera won the TRIPLE CROWN! While Mike Trout had possibly the best rookie season ever, The Triple Crown is something that most of us watching sports these days have NEVER seen! In any other season Mike Trout is hands down the AL MVP! I’m not taking anything away from the kid, he just chose the wrong season to be a rookie.

You stay classy, Rob Parker

ESPN's Rob Parker, the man who makes Skip Bayless look like a professional sports analyst, has gained infamy across the internet for his comments attacking intelligence and individuals who prefer advanced statistical metrics to understand baseball.  Why a man who went to Columbia hates learning new things is beyond me, but nevertheless, this jockular wagon that makes him look...

Who was under-represented in the MVP voting?

We've talked endlessly about Miguel Cabrera winning the AL MVP award over Mike Trout, and that's a debate we're not going to get into anymore. But looking at the balloting, there were plenty of players that didn't receive nearly enough support in either league for their performances this season. Here are some of them. Ben Zobrist, Rays. Seven points: one seventh...

Shut Out of the MVP Voting

The big news associated with the MVP award announced today will be the winners, especially this year with the Trout vs. Cabrera debate. Besides the winners, the below average players who receive votes get a bit of press. Today, I will look at another group of hitters, those who had a good season, but may not get a single MVP vote. Last award season, I looked at what kept a hitter...

Will AL MVP stay in Detroit?

DETROIT -- Its said that youre judged by the company you keep, and Tigers teammates Miguel Cabrera and Justin Verlander might soon join a very select circle. If third baseman Cabrera wins the American League Most Valuable Player award Thursday night, it would come one year after pitching ace Verlander received that honor. The duo would be only the fourth pitcher-position player...
AND THE WINNERS ARE...

MLB announces League MVPs

The MLB announced Thursday the recipients of the MVP award in each league: Tigers third baseman Miguel Cabrera in the AL and Giants catcher Buster Posey in the NL.

Miguel Cabrera and Buster Posey Win MVP Awards

 Detroit’s Miguel Cabrera has won the American League’s Most Valuable Player award after becoming baseball’s first Triple Crown winner in 45 years. Cabrera received 22 of 28 first-place votes and 362 points from the AL panel of Baseball Writers’ Association of America. Los Angeles Angels rookie center fielder Mike Trout had six firsts and 281 points. San Francisco’s...

Buster Posey and Miguel Cabrera named leauge MVP’s

Tweet 25-year year old Buster Posey of the San Francisco Giants became the third catcher in MLB history to be awarded league MVP by capturing 27 first place votes. He led the National League in batting average (.336), becoming the second catcher in league history to do so. Posey also had 24 HR, 103 RBI, [...]
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.