Found June 05, 2013 on
When will Gerrit Cole pass the Super Two cutoff?
I’ve been getting Super Two and arbitration clock questions all day, probably because of the Wandy Rodriguez injury and the chance that Gerrit Cole could come up soon. Rather than answering these over and over, I’m going to go over the deadlines here. Then I can just send people here when I keep getting the questions over and over.
Question 1: When will Gerrit Cole be eligible for an extra year of control?
Answer: He already is. One year of service time is 172 days. A player isn’t eligible for free agency until he passes 6.000 years of service time. If Cole came up today, he’d have 0.117 years of service time this season, giving him six full years of control remaining. So no matter when he comes up, the Pirates control his rights through the 2019 season.
Question 2: When will Gerrit Cole avoid Super Two status?
Answer: There is no specific date here. Super Two status is awarded to players with more than two, but less than three years of service time. Only the players with the top 22% of service time in that group are Super Two eligible (that’s up from 17% under the old CBA). If the Pirates called Cole up today, and kept him up, he’d have 2.117 years of service time after the 2015 season.
The thing is, it’s really hard to predict what the actual cutoff will be two years from now. Right now the projected cutoff for the upcoming off-season is 2.119. So Cole’s 2.117 if he came up today would be dangerously close. Also, the 2.119 is the lowest in the last five years, but that’s probably due to the increase from 17% to 22%. In this article about the Mets and Matt Harvey, they’re estimating the date could be anywhere from late-May to June 10th, while another team estimates June 15th.
If Cole came up on June 15th, he’d finish with 0.107 years of service time. If he stays up for good, he’d be safe.
Question 3: CALL HIM UP!
Answer: Cole just finished seven shutout innings for the second game in a row. He currently has 19.2 scoreless innings in a row, with five hits allowed in that span. As I wrote earlier, the Pirates don’t need a fifth starter until June 15th (coincidental that this date comes up multiple times in this article). I still have questions about whether Cole is ready, but he’s answered a lot of them in his last three starts. Is he dominating like a number one starter? No. Is he looking like a guy who could have success in the majors right now? Yes.
Cole could make one more start, then come up if the Pirates need him on the 15th. That gives him one more start to show he’s ready, plus it almost certainly avoids Super Two status down the line, which could be huge for the Pirates if Cole ends up being the pitcher we think he will be.
Question 4: Why not just call him up for one start?
Answer: When Cole comes up, he needs to be up for good. The problem with calling him up for one start is that he’s not on the 40-man roster. You’d have to add him to the 40-man, bring him up, then option him down after that one start. That burns one option year.
Ideally you won’t need to worry about options with Cole. But at some point we thought the same thing about Pedro Alvarez, and that quickly turned to “is Alvarez eligible for a fourth option?” (and Cole wouldn’t be). I don’t think the value of one start is worth one option year. If you’re going to bring him up, bring him up for good. And there’s no reason why that can’t happen on June 15th.
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
PIRATES LIFE FOR ME
The Pirates made Gerrit Cole the top overall pick in the 2011 MLB Draft and now two years later, he's poised to make his first big league start.
Episode eight of The Pirates Prospects Podcast can be downloaded or streamed below. This episode includes analysis from Tom Bragg (@TomBraggSports) and James Santelli (@JamesSantelli) on the Pirates. Highlights of the show include:
**We looked at the injury to Wandy Rodriguez, and debated whether the Pirates should call up Gerrit Cole. Also, what kind of pitcher will Cole be when...
Gerrit Cole has not had the season in Triple-A that any of us hoped that he'd have. He racked up high pitch counts early on on the season, then struggled badly with control for a stretch, then gave up 12 runs (11 earned) in 11 innings over two starts on May 14th and May 19th. Since those two bad starts (the one on the 19th was particularly bad), Cole's bounced back some....
TOP OF THE SYSTEM
A look at how the current top 20 prospects did today. Note that this list doesn’t include players currently in the majors. If a player is in the majors, he will be removed, everyone below him will be shifted up a spot, and a new player will be added to the bottom of the list. Rankings are from the pre-season rankings, and links to each prospect writeup can be...
It's been a rough week for the Pirates, but there's some good news for them today; Michael Sanserino says that the tests done on Wandy Rodriguez's elbow revealed only inflammation (thus, no structural damge) and that Rodriguez is optimistic he could avoid a trip to the disabled list and may start for the Pirates as soon as next Thursday. Sanserino also says that Charlie...
Pittsburgh Pirates left handed pitcher Wandy Rodriguez left yesterday’s game against the Atlanta Braves after recording one out thanks to what is being described as left forearm tightness. That’s his throwing arm and that’s especially bad news for an organization that just put Jeanmar Gomez on the Disabled List with forearm tightness of his own. That’s two starters in...
Pirates left-handed pitcher Wandy Rodriguez told Michael Sanserino of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that he has inflammation in his left arm and not a more serious injury.
Wandy Rodriguez said he will likely avoid a trip to the disabled list. Said tests revealed inflammation. Will throw this morning. #Pirates
— Michael Sanserino (@msanserino) June 7, 2013
Rodriguez left his start...
Episode seven of The Pirates Prospects Podcast can be downloaded or streamed below. The MLB Draft is on Thursday, and to prepare we have a special draft-only podcast, featuring special guest Jim Callis (@jimcallisBA) of Baseball America. Highlights of the show include:
**John Dreker and I discuss the Pirates Prospects Top 100 Tiered Rankings, which can be found here. We give our...
Wandy Rodriguez left his start Wednesday in the first inning after facing just four batters, complaining of tightness in his forearm. Rodriguez has 6 wins and a 3.59 ERA on the season. Charlie Morton could be removed from his rehab assignment to fill Rodriguez’s rotation spot should he need to miss starts. This could potentially be a big blow for the Pirates chances of remaining...
Wandy Rodriguez left today’s game in the first inning after recording one out, pointing to his left elbow. The Pirates later announced that Rodriguez left the game with tightness in his left forearm. That’s the same injury that Jeanmar Gomez had earlier in the week (although the right arm, obviously), and Gomez went on the disabled list. It seems likely that Rodriguez will go...
Pittsburgh's Wandy Rodriguez has left his start against the Atlanta Braves with tightness in his left forearm after recording only one out.
The left-hander pointed to his forearm when visited by manager Clint Hurdle and a Pirates trainer in the first inning Wednesday. After a brief discussion on the mound, Rodriguez was removed from the game.
Rodriguez gave up two hits and...
Pittsburgh Pirates left-hander Wandy Rodriguez will throw a bullpen session on Monday before the team decides if he will go on the disabled list.
Manager Clint Hurdle said before Friday's game against the Chicago Cubs that Rodriguez has no ''acute structural damage to the ligament'' in his throwing arm. Even so, the Pirates will wait to see how his arm responds...
Pittsburgh Pirates left-handed starting pitcher Wandy Rodriguez exited today's contest against the Atlanta Braves in the first inning with forearm tightness, according to Eric Single of MLB.com.
Rodriguez lasted only 14 pitches before he was visited on the mound by the Pirates' trainers and manager Clint Hurdle. Prior to his exit, the southpaw allowed Andrelton Simmons...
Pirates (35-24) at Braves (36-22)
12:10 PM–Turner Field, Atlanta
The Bucs will try and avoid a sweep for the second straight series as they take on the Braves in this very early getaway day afternoon game.
Wandy Rodriguez (6-3, 3.47) vs. Julio Teheran (3-2, 3.71)
Rodriguez pitched well his last time out but two solo homers were enough...
The Pirates and Braves go at it at 12:10 this afternoon, with the Pirates looking to avoid their first sweep since their ugly trip to Los Angeles back at the beginning of April. The Pirates are not playing well right now; they've lost two in a row and four of their last five. It's worth noting, though, that you don't have to pull your focus back that far to put things...