Found November 17, 2012 on The Daily Stache:
Much of the talk around the Mets fan base in the wake of R.A. Dickey’s Cy Young win this week has been about his value and whether it would be best for the Mets to give Dickey a contract extension or trade him at what appears to be the peak of his value. I’ve found myself on both ends of this discussion over the last few weeks. There was a time two weeks ago that I had pretty much resigned myself to the idea that R.A. had thrown his last pitch in a Mets uniform. But that was when I thought Dickey wanted a five-year deal and could command a top prospect. That doesn’t seem to be the case anymore. The more I look at it and hear about the modest expectations Dickey has for a new contract, as well as the level of player the Mets can get in return, I think extending him is the move the Mets have to make. Today two reports came out about Dickey. Andy Martino of the New York Daily News noted that the Mets have made a two-year offer to Dickey and believe he will accept a two-year deal at the right price. Buster Olney of ESPN cited a source that Dickey wants north of $10-million a year and Martino tacked on that Dickey is looking for a deal comparable to the one Jake Peavy signed with the White Sox in October. Two years and $29 million is pretty high, but I think it’s worth it and here’s why. Even if you do extend Dickey for a deal similar to Peavy’s the 2014 Mets rotation is a bargain as a whole. With Dickey still in the fold for 2013, you’re set with a rotation of Santana ($30.5 million), Dickey ($5 million), Jon Niese ($3 million), Matt Harvey and Dillon Gee on rookie deals and Zack Wheeler in the wings if injury strikes. After the season, Santana’s albatross comes off the books. Dickey gets half of what Santana did this season, Niese is locked in at 5 million for 2014, Harvey and Wheeler will still be on rookie salaries and Gee will be in his first year of arbitration, putting his salary at 1-1.5 million at most. So the total cost of the Mets’ 2014 rotation will be about 22 million, or less than one Johan Santana. Pretty nice, right? That leaves plenty of money to build the rest of the team. The argument here is, you have to spend on upper tier pitching at some point. If Dickey is traded, you might not need to fill that spot with a big-time pitcher in 2013, but once Johan comes off the books in 2014, you’re going to be right back in the market for a top-tier, big-money pitcher. Who knows if you’ll be able to get a pitcher that can give you Dickey’s production at that price? Why not have that player be R.A. Dickey, a high-character guy who has proven he can do it and well with the Mets? I’ve seen the argument that Dickey can’t possibly replicate his 2012 season and so the Mets should sell high. While that very much could be true, Dickey’s 2012 wasn’t exactly a flash in the plan. His wins went up, but his ERA was in line with his 2010 number. He got a lot more strikeouts, but that came in large part to the hybrid knuckleball he throws. It’s a pitch he’s continuing to evolve and R.A. is a smart, motivated guy, so there’s no real reason to believe that evolution will stop once he gets his money. And limiting Dickey to a two-year extension would mean that his contract will expire in line with when Niese’s contract ramps up ($9 million in 2016), Harvey will be due a raise and Wheeler will be coming up on one. There should be some other pitchers further along in the pipeline (Michael Fulmer, for one) by that point, allowing you to redistribute your funds and keep a solid rotation intact. This to me is very similar to the way the Tampa Bay Rays have done business with their pitching staff by retaining James Shields and gradually infusing players like Price, Hellickson and Moore. The Mets have explored trading Dickey, which is wise. They should be doing the same with David Wright, whether they plan to trade him or not. Finding out what a player is worth to other teams can only assist in contract negotiations. But in my opinion Dickey has more value to the Mets than anyone else. Unless a team is willing to come in and offer a top-tier, can’t miss MLB ready player (looking at you Blue Jays/Travis D’ Arnaud), I don’t think parting with Dickey for some B-level prospects and bench pieces is a worthwhile endeavor. The Mets should be building around their current rotation, not dismantling it and make no mistake, R.A. Dickey is the centerpiece of that rotation next year and for the next couple. Get him signed and build from there. The post An Argument to Extend R.A. Dickey appeared first on The Daily Stache.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Mets Want A Monster Package For Dickey

Andy Martino of the Daily News reports that the Mets want a ‘monster package’ for R.A. Dickey, which is likely a few high-end prospects, major leaguers, outfielders and catching help. He cites a high-ranking MLB executive, that “if the Mets don’t get this level return, they’re probably not going to trade him.” Wow, talk about too pricey… Incredible… Honestly, I don’t...

Trading R.A. Dickey… For whom?

There has been TOO much talk about the Mets keeping/trading R.A. Dickey without any real discussion over what they think they could realistically get for a 37-year old Cy Young.  It’s great that he throws a pitch that’s easy on the arm and has shown remarkably good health but age is always a concern and just as the Mets are more eager to trade Dickey than David Wright because...

Subway Squawkers interview with R.A. Dickey, Mets Cy Young Award winner

I was very excited to have the opportunity to speak with 2012 NL Cy Young Award winner R.A. Dickey earlier today. Dickey is one of the stars of "Knuckleball!," which is now available through video on demand. The DVD is available for pre-order at knuckleballmovie.com. Squawker Lisa and I were able to see the movie last spring at the Tribeca Film Festival and we highly recommend...

Mets may be close on offer to Dickey

The New York Mets could be on the verge of a breakthrough in their negotiations with National League Cy Young Award winner R.A. Dickey. Or, maybe not. The Mets plan to offer Dickey a two-year contract extension, according to major league sources. Whether Dickey would accept such a deal remains to be seen. Dickey, 38, is under contract next season for $5 million. He likely would...

R.A. Dickey, National League Cy Young award winner, is the Toast of the Town

R.A. Dickey will deservedly be accepting the Cy Young Award at the BBWAA’s annual awards dinner this January. The 38-year-old knuckleballer for the Mets, found a fitting epilogue to his storybook season tonight, when he was named winner of the 2012 National League Cy Young Award. Dickey earned 27 of 32 first-place votes, finishing ahead of Clayton Kershaw of the Los Angeles Dodgers...

What Will Mets Do With Wright and Dickey?

I used to love checking out those polls they frequently conduct at MetsBlog and always enjoyed reading the results. But in the last two years, the majority vote seems to mirror the same opinions of the MetsBlog team. I find their poll results being too predictable now, and I think it’s because readers have more choices with new Mets sites sprouting up all the time. We love to...

Report: Mets offer Dickey two-year deal

The New York Mets have reportedly offered NL Cy Young winner R.A. Dickey a two-year contract extension. Fox Sports reported Saturday morning that the Mets planned to make an offer but the New York Daily News later reported that the club already made the offer. It is not clear how much money is involved, but the Daily News reported that Dickey, 38, would sign a contract comparable...

This Is Too Funny… Mets On Verge Of Dickey Deal, Or Maybe Not

Major League sources tell Ken Rosenthal of FOX Sports that the Mets plan to offer R.A. Dickey a two-year contract extension… I think… The New York Mets could be on the verge of a breakthrough in their negotiations with National League Cy Young Award winner R.A. Dickey. Or, maybe not. The Mets plan to offer Dickey a two-year contract extension, according to major league sources...

Olney: Dickey wants more than $10 million/year on 2-year extension

According to Marc Carig of Newsday “the window between Thanksgiving and the winter meetings are going to be an important window in Mets’ talks with Dickey/Wright.”  That window may be even tighter as rumors today have suggested the team is making a 2-year offer to Dickey.  In fact, depending on what you read, the team may have made an offer as long as 2 weeks ago: #bbpBox_26984354869687091...

Memo To Mets: Stop Screwing Around And Sign Dickey And Wright

The press release came via email as it always does and my first reaction was: How insignificant is Brian Bixler? He means something to his family, but hit .193 with two homers and seven RBI last season for Colorado and Washington. Yup, that will have them breaking down the doors at Citi Field. Another meaningless signing by the Mets, who continue to insult their dwindling fan base...

Cy Young surprise

Sure, OK, David Price wins the American League Cy Young Award. Not entirely surprising.   But R.A. Dickey in the National League? Don’t get me wrong, he put up some great numbers and was absolutely deserving of the honor. But raise your hand if you had Dickey winning the award before the season started.   [...]

Olney: Wilpons should re-sign Dickey or sell team

In reading a column from Buster Olney recently I saw the ESPN writer make a pretty bold statement regarding the Wilpon family and the New York Mets.  Most of the column requires ESPN Insider access to read, but Olney makes his point pretty clear in the intro (click here to read in full):   Photo by Michael G. Baron R.A. Dickey looked a little shaken after winning the Cy Young...

Mets to Make R.A. Dickey a Two-Year Offer

The news broke yesterday that the New York Mets, in their attempt to keep their 38-year old Cy Young Award winner, would offer R.A. Dickey a two-year deal.  The deal would be a two-year extension as Dickey is still under contract with the Mets through next season. According to Ken Rosenthal of Fox Sports, Dickey would be looking for at least $20 million over the two-year extension...

Rosenthal: Mets could be on verge of a breakthrough in negotiations with Dickey

Yesterda, Newsday reporter Marc Craig tweeted that New York Mets general manager Sandy Alderson “doesn’t think Dickey winning the Cy Young will significantly impact talks.”  Ken Rosenthal’s article today for Fox Sports certainly seems to echo that sentiment as the team is reportedly preparing to offer Dickey a 2-year-extension: The New York Mets could be on the verge of...

This weeks crowning of R.A. Dickey as National League Cy Young award winner sets the Tennessee native near the top of another rather select list of major leaguers…those who succeeded despite physical deformities.  These men didn’t overcome bad knees, a la Mickey Mantle, or end a dominant career with a bone on bone elbow like Sandy Koufax…. No these men had actual missing...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.