Found November 09, 2011 on Mets Fever:
PLAYERS: Jose Reyes
TEAMS: New York Mets
Vince Coleman is remembered most for being a part of the worst team money could buy, who thought it was funny to scare fans with cherry bombs instead of opponents with his on-base prowess.

While most of us Mets fans cringe when we here Coleman's name along with Saberhagen and Bonilla's there maybe a useful comparison to be draw between Coleman and Reyes.

I'll admit that for me the idea of losing Reyes is depressing and this post feels more like a justification then a legitimate argument, despite that emotional sentiment there maybe a rational lesson to be learned from past experiences. 

Vince Coleman was rookie of the year in 1985 he followed that up with two All-Star appearances in his first five years with the Cardinals.  In his first three seasons he played in more then 150 games and stole over 100 bases in every year.  In his fourth season while he continued to show durability playing in 153 gms there may have been signs that he was slowing, producing only 81 steals.  The next season at the age of 27 y/o for the first time in his career he played in less then 150 games ( 145 gms) and only stole 65 bases.  His last season in St. Louis he played in only 123 games but raised his stolen bases back up to 77 and hit for a career best .292 BA. 

In two NLCS appearances with the Cards ( 85/ 87) he hit .276 and his one World Series appearance ( 1987) he stole six bases in seven games despite only hitting .143.

Coleman became a free agent at the age of 29 y/o and despite some of the clues that his speed was already beginning to erode and his durability was on the decline, it's easy to understand how a team would sign him.  After all, aside from Ricky Henderson he was considered the most electrifying player on the base path in the game. 

The Mets signed him to a four year at around 3M a season and never saw the player he once was in St. Louis.  In his first two seasons he only played in 143 gms ( 71/72) and combined for what was less then his previous worst stolen base total, swiping a total of only 61 ( 37/24 ). In his final season as a Met he appeared in 92 games and stole 38 bases. 

In 1994 at the age of 32 y/o a very disappointing Coleman was traded to the Royals in the Kevin McReynolds deal.  He would show improvement with the small market Royals appearing in 109 gms and stealing 50 bases, it would be his last season as a full time player, he would struggle to stay on teams for three more seasons.

I focused on stolen bases because my biggest concern with Jose is his legs and speed, just as Coleman's game was predicated on speed so is Jose's and Coleman stands as an example of just how fast and early speed can go.  Up until his last three seasons Coleman's BA, OBP, SLG and OPS were essentially consistent but what made him such a dynamic player was his speed and by the time he came to the Mets it was already compromised.

Jose Reyes enters free agency one year younger then Coleman at the age of 28 y/o but with 2 full seasons and two partial seasons more mileage on his gifted legs.  Like Coleman he produced four straight seasons of durability ( over 152 games each) and electric speed (  56 or more SB).  But in 2009 he only appeared in 36 gms due to leg injuries and while rebounding the last two seasons like Coleman he has not returned to the 150 game range ( 133/ 126 games).  For a player who relies on speed another troubling sign is his stolen base totals remain well below expectations ( 30/39). 

For those who point to his batting title as a sign that his bat has improved to make up for his lack of aggressiveness on the base path, rem. the year we signed Coleman he had his best offensive year ( .292 BA). 

Now I still want Jose back at five or less years, but for those who say sign him at any cost; Coleman serves as an example of just how quickly a player who relies on speed can see his game erode. 

I ask this question rhetorically; What would be worse, watching an MVP caliber Jose on another team after signing a six year deal or seeing it all slowly wash away as a Met in 70 game seasons with 20 stolen bases and rem. what he once was.

Hopefully neither happen as he stays a Met on a reasonable deal and remains relatively consistent with his career so far but right now one of those two seems like a pipe dream...


THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

No time to sulk if Reyes leaves Mets

If you are immersed in the Mets’ blogosphere, you assuredly have read the obituary that has been written for the Mets, since it seems unlikely that the Mets will retain their franchise shortstop Jose Reyes. If Reyes leaves- it is told through many others-the Mets will be one chaotic mess. Expect the demise of the Mets to be greatly exaggerated. Look, the Mets haven’t been...

Harper: Marlins may only offer 3-year deal to Jose Reyes

With Jose Reyes set to meet with the Miami Marlins some time today, fans are understandably worried that the man they watched dazzle them at shortstop  for the better part of eight years may be on his way out.  People close to the team, however, may not be as worried….at least not when it comes to Miami.  According to John Harper of the Daily News: Photo by Michael G. Baron...

Video: Jose Reyes (in Marlins helmet) touring new ballpark

“I’ve been here all day in Miami meeting with them, just checking out the new stadium and the city,” Jose Reyes says in the following video from Contacto Deportivo, while touring Miami’s new ballpark yesterday with team officials. “We haven’t spoken about anything specific, but who wouldn’t want to play here with a new stadium, it’s always warm and sunny, it’s close...

Signing Reyes almost a done deal for the Miami Marlins?

According to Jorge Sedano of 790 AM ‘The Ticket’ in Miami, a source has informed him that signing Jose Reyes is almost a done deal for the Miami Marlins: #bbpBox_134800463710265346 a { text-decoration:none; color:#2FC2EF; }#bbpBox_134800463710265346 a:hover { text-decoration:underline; }Marlins returned from Cespedes workout. Source tells me Reyes "almost a done deal."...

Brewers not likely to sign Jose Reyes this winter

In a post to Twitter, Tom Haudricourt of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel says he doesn’t believe it’s likely the Brewers will sign Jose Reyes this winter. Having said that, in regards to Reyes, Brewers GM Doug Melvin told Haudricourt “I’m interested in everybody until I know what the price is.” SI.com’s Jon Heyman recently said the Brewers are targeting Jose Reyes, since...

If Reyes Leaves Should the Mets Trade Wright?

With the news that Jose Reyes and the Marlins are getting closer and closer to reaching a deal, it may become time to seriously consider what life for the New York Mets will be like without Jose Reyes. It is highly unlikely that Reyes or any other big name free agent will sign until the new CBA is in place, but the two sides could easily put together a deal that is just waiting...

Always More To The Story

What if there is more to the Jose Reyes and NY Mets negotiations than we all are assuming? I’m guilty of one thing, I like to think outside the box and sure I may be totally wrong here but that doesn’t mean it’s impossible. To set up my point, I think back to July 30, 2004. A day most Mets fans remember as the day they gave away Scott Kazmir. The Kazmir deal is pretty interesting...

Braves not pursuing Jose Reyes or Jimmy Rollins

Earlier today on MLB Network Radio on Sirius/XM, Braves GM Frank Wren said he is not pursuing free-agent shortstops Joe Reyes or Jimmy Rollins. According to Wren, he is more likely to find a shortstop on the trade market than through free agency. Here are other key updates about Jose over the last few days: SI.com’s Jon Heyman says the Brewers are targeting Jose Reyes, since...

Reyes takes tour of new Marlins stadium

MIAMI -- A person familiar with discussions between Jose Reyes and the Florida Marlins says the team is courting the free-agent shortstop in Miami. The Marlins gave the Mets All-Star a tour of their new ballpark Wednesday, the person told The Associated Press on condition of anonymity because the team...

Low Years, High Money

Via MetsBlog.com, the Marlins may offer Jose Reyes a low years, high salary contract: Yet Mets people on Tuesday privately downplayed the significance of the Marlins’ aggressiveness. One person said he heard they plan to offer Reyes only a three-year deal at a high annual average, presumably more than $20 million a year. It seems to me these contracts make much more sense for an...

Free-agent SS Jose Reyes meets with Marlins

MIAMI (AP) -- Jose Reyes toured the Florida Marlins' new ballpark as a potential pillar for the franchise. The Marlins courted the All-Star shortstop Wednesday with the tour and lunch on South Beach, team president David Samson said on his weekly radio show on WAXY-AM. "We're interested in making our team better," Samson said. "To be interested, you have...

Marlins not expected to dispatch Hanley Ramirez Tuesday in Jose Reyes recruitment

Perhaps Jose Reyes already has received assurances from Hanley Ramirez he would be welcomed to the Miami Marlins, specifically to the shortstop position, with enthusiasm. If Reyes still is looking for Ramirez to extend him that support, it’s not likely to happen Tuesday. Ramirez is not expected to be part of the Marlins’ welcome party when team officials host Reyes. While Reyes...

Stating the Obvious (& more): Wright wants Reyes to stay with the Mets

Erik Boland of Newsday quoted David Wright saying the following: “I don’t know what [Jose Reyes is] going to do but I know what I want him to do. That’s to be to my left next year. I’ve shot him a couple text messages here and there, nothing about baseball, but I guess that’s the eternal optimist side of me is that he’ll be to my left in spring training. Hopefully, the...

MMO Fan Shot: A Hall Of A Comparison!

Here is a tale of two players… Let’s start off with career averages in some key Categories:   Career Averages per Season G PA RS H BA OBP SLG Player A 108 471 81.3 107.8 0.279 0.401 0.419 Player B 116 537 81.6 144.4 0.290 0.336 0.432 Here is the thing about this comparison. Both are similar type players, Both had...
Mets News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.