Originally written June 21, 2013 on 643ball:
Grade the Trade is a new feature here at 643ball.com that hopes to engage you, the reader in discussion about a trade. The information and discussion may even help you in trade talks in your league as you look to improve your standing in the second half of the year. We’ll give you the scenario of both teams and the league settings. Then, you the reader can use the comment sections to “grade the trade”, telling us which owner you think won the deal and improved their team the most with the move. This week we’ll keep it simple and look at a couple straightforward deals in a redraft league. Assume some depth at the positions that each owner is trading from. For example, if an owner trades a starting pitcher like Matt Harvey, assume they have depth in their rotation and they are trading from a strength. DEAL #1: (submitted by Adam H., CT)LEAGUE SETTINGS: 12-Teams, Mixed, Standard 5x5 Roto, RedraftSCENARIO: Team A - 6th place, needs AVG, RBITeam B - 10th place, needs K’s, W’sTHE DEAL: Team A receives Billy Butler, 1B/DH and Nolan Arenado, 3BTeam B receives Matt Harvey, SPOUR VERDICT: Normally a lock for over 20 homers and 90 RBI, Butler is having a pretty down year, and it's no sure thing he will turn it around. Arenado is a nice young player, but probably won't reach his potential until 2015. Meanwhile, Harvey is one of the best pitcher's in the game and while he may be treated with kid glove as the calendar turns to September, he's the best player in the deal. Win goes to Team B. DEAL #2: (submitted by Chris L., CA)LEAGUE SETTINGS: 12-Teams, Mixed, Standard 5x5 Roto, RedraftSCENARIO: Team A - 10th place, needs RBI, SB, AVGTeam B - 12th place, needs several pitching categories and RunsTHE DEAL: Team A receives David Wright 3B, Jered Weaver SP, Ian Desmond SSTeam B receives David Freese 3B, Clayton Kershaw SP, Jimmy Rollins SS OUR VERDICT:All nice players in this deal and it's a one-for-one at each position. Looking more closely, though, I think it's a pretty big upgrade from Freese to Wright, and Rollins and Desmond seem to be trending in different directions in their careers. Kershaw is a nice upgrade over Weaver, but I'm not sure it's enough to justify the offensive hit. Win goes to Team A by a nose.Let us know who you think won each deal and why in the comments section below. As always, thanks for visiting the site and feel free to post your own trades for review in the comments below. If you’d like to submit one of your recent trades to be posted in our “grade the trade” column, you can email us at 643ball@gmail.com. Just provide us with as many details about the trade as possible.We’re also available to chat every Sunday evening at 9pm ET on our “chat” page. There, you can get real time answers to your lineup and trade questions for the coming week.Recent Posts:The Art of the Trade: Trade Negotiations Part 1The Art of the Trade: Trade Negotiations Part 2Mike Buttil@mbuttil643
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Cowboys' Spillman accused of rape at team hotel

Report: Patriots benched WR for mouthing off to coach

Jose Bautista busts up reporter over Twitter

What to watch in the NL Wild Card game

Sammy Watkins calls out EJ Manuel

Larry Donnell benches himself in fantasy, loses because of it

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Josh Gordon says NFL’s drug policy is harrassment

Steve Smith: Ron Rivera hid in his office after cutting me

Rondo hoping for an opening night return from broken hand

Jon Gruden on Raiders job: 'I'm not thinking about coaching'

Tom Brady defends not congratulating Garoppolo on TD

Ohio State student who ran on field loses full scholarship

Byron Scott explains why Kobe wouldn't make a good coach

WATCH: Mayweather shocked someone doesn’t know who he is

Who is the new face of MLB?

NHL 15 predicts the LA Kings win the Cup again

J.J. Watt buys his mom a new car for her birthday

Ranking the NFL coaches already sitting on the hot seat

WATCH: Smith tells Panthers to go home and mow his lawn

The best games on the NFL slate in Week 5

Aaron Rodgers says smoking gesture a tribute to Jay Cutler

What will the A’s look like in 2015?

Major League Baseball's 2014 All-Disappointment Team

Jeter introduces 'The Players Tribune,' 'The Voice of the Game'

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Scott: Kobe would not be a good coach

Pats WR benched for mouthing off?

What to watch in the NL Wild Card game

Sammy Watkins calls out EJ Manuel

Donnell benches himself in fantasy and loses

Gordon: Drug policy is harrassment

Who is the new face of baseball?

Steve Smith blasts Panthers coach, GM

What will the A’s look like in 2015?

All-Disappointment Team in MLB

Ryan Lochte: Phelps made dumb decision

WATCH: Brett Favre in new commercial

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.