Found May 07, 2013 on
The Nats Blog:
I know I'm a bit late to the game here, but I was unable to write until today, so I figured it was better late than never to talk about Bryce Harper's ejection by third base umpire John Hirschbeck from Sunday afternoon's game in Pittsburgh. The more I watch the video, the more amazed I am at the ejection and the set of circumstances that unfolded following the game. First, here is the video of how it all transpired.
PIT Broadcast - Hirschbeck-Harper - 20130505 from Rocket 1124 on Vimeo. (link from Dan Steinberg)
So, to me, it certainly looked like Harper did swing the bat. If he didn't, it was close enough that it's pretty hard to be mad at Hirschbeck's initial strike call. Harper may not have broken his wrists, but his entire torso had turned around and the bat advanced pretty far across the plate. Harper showed his displeasure at the call by throwing his hands in the air. Should he have done that? No. Did he show up the umpire by doing it? Maybe, but that's in the eye of the beholder.
Hirschbeck then became the aggressor. He started screaming down the line at Harper, mimicking his arm gestures, and walking in his direction. Harper stood in the box in disbelief, but Hirschbeck continued down the line, prompting Nats third base coach Trent Jewett to get in between the umpire and Harper as Hirschbeck appeared to point Harper back to the dugout. To be clear, Harper wasn't moving toward Hirschbeck. He actually started to walk away.
What happened next prompted the ejection as, according to Adam Kilgore of the Washington Post, "Hirschbeck told a pool reporter he had 'no recourse' but to throw out Harper after he raised his arms over his head, then 'threw his bat' and 'slammed his helmet down.'" You may be able to argue that Harper tossed his bat, but he definitely didn't throw it or spike it. It's hard to see how anyone can truly argue that his helmet was "slammed" into the ground. He hardly had "no recourse."
Hirschbeck, from the moment Harper looked miffed at the strike three call, seemed to be looking to toss the Nationals young star from the game. There have been far too many circumstances with umpires becoming the story in recent seasons. I'm not even talking about when the umpires blow a call. These guys are usually very good, and even the best will make mistakes. However, these kinds of emotional displays from umpires, further evidenced by the Tom Hallion and David Price situation this season, need to be addressed, and there needs to be more accountability for umpires as there are for players.
BEST OF MAXIM
Not surprisingly, MLB did not fine or suspend Byrce Harper after his ejection at the hands of fightin' John Hirschbeck on Sunday in Pittsburgh. And, not surprisingly, Harper said all the right things when he heard about the decision:
"It's great. I'm glad I don't have to pay the $1,000. That's
another $1,000 in my pocket, so that's good. That...
That there's the pink glove Bryce Harper will be wearing on Mother's Day.
(Photo via @Akadema)
Befriend Nats Enquirer on Facebook. Follow on Twitter.
Video: Bryce Harper assists Tim Hudson's homerun
Video: Bryce Harper's new GEICO commercial
Bryce Harper shows off new 34/BH Under Armour logo
Bryce Harper's new "rockabilly...
We all know that Bryce Harper can be a hot head at times. Do we need to bring up the fact that he slammed a bat into a wall and hit himself in the face? But he is young and plays with his heart on his sleeve, and this is why we love him. I am never really the one to take the side of a player when he gets ejected, but when I look at the video again, I have to say Harper did nothing...
Your browser does not support iframes.
Bryce Harper had a very quick afternoon during the Washington Nationals’ 6-2 win over the Pittsburgh Pirates on Sunday. Harper had only one at-bat, as he was thrown out by umpire John Hirschbeck in the top of the first inning for arguing over a check swing. The call looked questionable and the ejection even more so.
Harper reportedly dropped...
Washington Nationals left fielder Bryce Harper has been ejected by third base umpire John Hirschbeck for arguing a checked-swing third strike.
Harper tried to hold up on a 2-2 pitch from Pirates left-hander Wandy Rodriguez in the first inning Sunday, and home plate umpire Bob Davidson pointed to Hirschbeck for help. Hirschbeck ruled that Harper had swung.
Harper stood outside the...
Everyone has sat in a classroom next to a guy who looks like a troublemaker and another who looks like a wonderful, stand-up young man. Both were shooting pencils into the ceiling or putting saran wrap over the toilet seats, but only one gets instantly called out when it’s time to charge into the classroom and pick out the miscreant. It’s the one who looks the part.
Such is the...
A week after the Tampa Bay Rays and home plate umpire Tom Hallion got into a game disagreement resulting in an ejection for Rays P Jeremy Hellickson, followed by a Price twitter tirade, followed by Price and Hallion reportedly being fined, 20-year-old Bryce Harper was in primadonna form was ejected by what seemed to be a more-aggressive-than-usual John Hirschbeck in the first inning...
Washington Nationals outfielder Bryce Harper was ejected in the very first inning against Pittsburgh for arguing a check-swing strike three call.
On a day when rain postponed the start of a much-anticipated series against the Detroit Tigers, the Washington Nationals got some good news.
Manager Davey Johnson said left fielder Bryce Harper would not be suspended or fined by Major League Baseball for being ejected in Sunday's 6-2 win at Pittsburgh. Harper was ejected by third base umpire John Hirschbeck for disputing a checked...
VIDEO: “Hirschbeck was just dying to throw Harper out there.” [NE]
Hirschbeck might have made right call, but is still a raging DB. [FB]
Nats win two in a row, sit just 2 games back of Atlanta in NL East. [CSNW]
Caps head to MSG for Game 3, but scary history up 2-0 in a series. [WP]
“Casual Mike” Green plays it cool, wins games, drives Lamborghini. [RMNB]
Verizon Center crowd...
Plenty has gone wrong for the Nationals in the early going. Dan Haren is basically broken, Gio Gonzalez might be and Stephen Strasburg — while pitching well — has not kept up the star pace expected of him in the early going. The offense might be just as concerning, however. Despite Bryce Harper’s continuous blossoming, a combination of injuries and underperformance has conspired...
Anibal Sanchez is a bad dude. This is the same man who struck out 16 Atlanta Braves a few Fridays ago.
But when there is big game to be hunted, Bryce Harper picks up his elephant gun and goes to work. Harper hit a majestic blast to right-center off Sanchez and drove in another on a sacrifice fly in the Nationals 3-1 victory over the Tigers.
The home run was Harper’s 10th of the season.
Bryce Harper hit a solo homer and drove in another run with a sacrifice fly, Jordan Zimmermann won his NL-leading sixth game and the Washington Nationals beat the Detroit Tigers 3-1 Wednesday night.
Denard Span added a triple and a single for Washington, which has won five of six.
Zimmermann (6-1), whose scoreless streak was snapped at 20 innings in the third, allowing a run on...
The Nats did exactly what we thought they needed to over the last week, as Craig mentioned in Episode 51 of the podcast. We talk about Jordan Zimmermann's insane performance, Bryce Harper's ejection and injury, and Ryan Zimmerman's throwing, among many other things. Enjoy the listen and pay attention for the word of the week and share it with us on Twitter.
The Bucs dropped the series to the Nats on Sunday, falling in frustrating fashion for the second day in a row. They had a golden opportunity to break the game open early and missed it, and things went downhill from there.
The game could not have started any better for the Pirates, and that’s not hyperbole. Wandy Rodriguez tossed 1-2-3 first and Bryce Harper was ejected after arguing...