Originally posted on Waiting For Next Year  |  Last updated 7/11/12

As we do each summer at WFNY when the Cleveland Indians hit the All-Star break, we take a look back at the four facets of the team on the field – the starting rotation, the bullpen, the infield, and the outfield. There’s been been a lot to talk about with this club. Their 44-41 record is good enough for second in the American League Central, but the team has shown some serious flaws. GM Chris Antonetti continues to tell us that the Indians have not played their best baseball yet. I hope he is right. Additions will need to be made and in-house improvements will be a must if the Tribe plans on playing October baseball.

Yesterday, we looked at the starting rotation. Today we will examine the guys who follow those starters; the bullpen.

This was thought to be the strength of the team coming into the 2012 season. Last year’s crew, The Bullpen Mafia, was essentially the same seven guys the entire season. As the club broke camp, the last two guys – Frank Herrmann and Chad Durbin – were replaced by waiver wire claim Jairo Ascencio and veteran free agent Dan Wheeler. They didn’t seem to matter much as they would be pitching in the mop up roles. Neither made it through May and both were designated for assignment. Wheeler didn’t deserve to make the club in the first place as he was below average during the Spring and then played the roll of gas can while with the Tribe.

Rafael Perez spent most of April searching for his lost velocity and was having trouble hitting 85 mph on the radar gun. It was clear something was wrong with him and at the end of April, the Tribe put him on the 60-day DL with a shoulder problem. His presence has been greatly missed. They have had to rely on essentially their three big guns – Chris Perez, Vinnie Pestano, and Joe Smith – to get them through the close games. As a whole, the bullpen ranks last in the American League in ERA (4.31 ERA), yet fourth in saves and sport a record of 37-2 when holding a lead after seven innings.

Lets dig a little deeper.

Chris Perez (34 appearances, 24 saves in 26 chances, 3.34 ERA, 1.11 WHIP, 35 K’s/7 BB’s) - To say it has been an eventful first half for the Tribe’s closer would be the understatement of the year. On the field, he blew his first save chance on Opening Day and had an angry mob calling for his job. From that point until the last game before the All-Star break, Perez saved 24 consecutive games and was as close to perfect as you can ask for from your closer (spare me the non-save situation talk!).

Sure, he would put an occasional base runner on here and there and made you sweat, but when he had a lead in the ninth, it was game over.

Off the field, well, you know the story. He set off a firestorm with his controversial comments regarding being booed at home, as well as the city’s fan base not coming to the park to support the team. Everything he said was right, but how he said it struck a real nerve in Cleveland. Incredibly, in his first save chance after making the remarks, the Progressive Field crowd gave him a standing ovation. He became a rock star figure even more than before. Pure Rage hasn’t been booed since in his home park.

The finale of his All-Star first half ended with his second blown save, but overall Perez has performed at an extremely high level. With that said, his “brutal honesty” act can wear thin and even has our own Jon calling for the Tribe to trade him. That won’t happen unless the Indians fall way out of the race and they are blown away by an offer. But Perez’s second half must mirror his first if the Indians plan on staying near the top of the AL Central.

Vinnie Pestano (38 appearances, 23 holds, 1.75 ERA, 1.03 WHIP, 43 K’s/15 BB’s) - You want a bullpen MVP? Vinnie is your man. As good as Perez has been, he wouldn’t be in the position to be an All Star without Pestano dominating the eighth inning the way he has. Whether he is facing a righty or a lefty, it doesn’t matter. Vinnie has owned them all. Lefties gave him trouble last year (.280), but he has shown improvement in 2012 (.234). He averages over a strikeout an inning while owning right-handed batters. In 64 AB’s against Pestano, righties are hitting just .109 (7-64) with just two extra base hits.

Pestano has been everything Manny Acta could ask for in a set-up man. He’s got that toughness and demeanor for the role and loves the big stage. He has future closer written all over him. The hope is that he doesn’t run out of gas in the second half. Acta has been so reliant on both he and Perez and really doesn’t have many good options he can trust.

Joe Smith (39 appearances, 13 holds, 3.13 ERA, 1.15 WHIP,29 K’s/14 BB’s) - Speaking of which, Smith is the third member of the back-end crew that has produced all year. The problem is that the rest of the pen has been so inconsistent. Smitty has used his side-arming ways to be that solid bridge to Pestano and Perez. He has two bad appearances in May where he gave up six earned runs in three innings. In the rest of the 31.1 innings of work,  Smith has allowed just seven earned runs.

Like with Pestano, you have to be concerned with Smith’s workload. While Vinnie and Rage are for the most part one inning pitchers, Acta isn’t afraid to use Smith in a longer role if needed. It would be nice for another one of the bullpen guys to step up and help Smith in the sixth and seventh inning spots.

Tony Sipp (34 appearances, 10 holds, 5.65 ERA, 1.22 WHIP, 32 K’s/10 BB’s) - If I had to name the guy who has been the biggest disappointment in the bullpen, Sipp would win in a walk. The key to the 2011 success of the Bullpen Mafia was the multiple left-handers to go with Smith and Pestano. In 2012, the lefties haven’t done their job. Sipp has struggled all year trying to locate his pitches. He hasn’t been able to get his fastball over consistently and hitters are sitting on his breaking pitches and teeing off.

The numbers will tell you differently (.170) but he has had a tough time in key spots against lefties. Sipp, like starter Josh Tomlin, has trouble with the home run ball. He has allowed six this season (three against lefties). Worst of all, with runners in scoring position, opposing hitters have tagged him for seven hits in 19 at-bats (.368).

The thing is, right now Sipp is the best lefty option the Indians have. So he will have to come strong and find himself in the second half. That’s because Rafael Perez is still injured and the two rookie lefties haven’t distinguished themselves.

Scott Barnes (5 appearances, 7.71 ERA, 1.57 WHIP, 7 K’s/5 BB’s) & Nick Hagadone (27 appearances, 6.39 ERA, 1.62 WHIP, 26 K’s/15 BB’s) When Raffy went down, Hagadone emerged as the ready made option to replace him. Nick pitched well enough to make the team out of Goodyear, but the Indians decided to keep him in AAA and have him work the eighth inning to prepare himself for a future big role in Cleveland. When he finally arrived, he burst onto the scene.

After his June 1st scoreless outing against the Twins, Hagadone’s ERA sat at 2.04. He had 25 K’s in 23.2 innings of work and had become Acta’s trusted late inning lefty. The accolades were coming from everywhere, including this corner. This was the 2007 Jensen Lewis-type impact in the bullpen. But then Hagadone’s confidence began to erode after giving up three hits and two runs in a June 3rd loss to the Twins. He was then lit up in four of his last five outings in June and finished the month with an ERA of 14.73. It was a bad run for Nick, as he allowed 10 earned runs in four innings, including three homers and five walks.

Hagadone was last seen putting four runners on (two walks and two hits) in less than an inning in Friday night’s 10-3 loss. After being replaced, Hagadone allegedly punched something in the clubhouse and injured his pitching hand. He was immediately sent to the minors after the game, replaced by Barnes. The Indians still have yet to disclose his injury, and has been placed on the suspended list. Now it is Barnes’s time.

The left-hander acquired from the Giants in 2008 for Ryan Garko has come through the organization as a starter, but the Indians rightly thought his quickest path to help the big league club in 2012 would be as a reliever. So they converted him after the first month of the AAA season. As of now, he is the long man, but with Sipp’s inconstant performance, Barnes could become a key guy in the second half.

It’s tough to say that we know much about him, as he has only made five appearances thus far, but his high ERA comes from one bad outing where he allowed five runs in a loss to the Reds. In his the other six and two-thirds innings of work, Barnes has given up just one earned run on one hit.

Esmil Rogers (11 appearances, 2 holds, 2,03 ERA, 0.60 WHIP, 18 K’s/1 BB) - The Indians tried it with Ascencio and failed, but they may have hit with Rogers. He was claimed off of waivers from the Colorado Rockies for cash because the front office was intrigued with his power arm. Like Hagadone, Rogers is a 94-95 fastball guy who has control issues at times. So far though, as a member of the Indians, Rogers has been a find.

Interestingly, Rogers came over with the reputation of being wild. He walked 18 in 25.2 innings of work in Colorado before being designated for assignment. But in Cleveland, Esmil has walked just one, while striking out 18 in 13.1 innings. Acta has thrust him into a few key situations of late to see how he would respond and Rogers has come through. The highlight was a 1-1 seventh inning game against the Reds with the bases loaded and two outs where Rogers was summoned from the pen and K’d Devin Mesoraco to end the threat.

Esmil could play a big role in the second half if he continues to pitch the way he has. Acta could really use it too.

Jeremy Accardo (18 appearances, 3.47 ERA, 1.41 WHIP, 21 K’s/11 BB’s) - I like Accardo. Probably because he is not Dan Wheeler. The veteran journeyman only enters games that the Indians are losing (15 of his 18 appearances have come in losses) and has done what he has needed to do to eat some innings and save the pen.


Getting the bullpen back to its 2011 form is of the utmost importance. Hopefully having a healthy Rafael Perez back at some point in the second half will help. Sipp must find himself from the left side and hopefully Rogers can emerge as that third right-hander that Acta can trust. One thing is for sure, if the bullpen implodes, the Tribe has no shot to stick in this race.

Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Roger Goodell to attend first game in New England since Deflategate

NBA commissioner Adam Silver wants a female head coach ‘sooner than later’

How significant is Celtics’ milestone of passing Cavs for the top seed?

Grant Hill reflects on Christian Laettner’s shot on its 25th anniversary

Chargers need to draft a young QB according to head coach Anthony Lynn


Seahawks GM stomps Marshawn Lynch rumors

Mel Kiper: Joe Mixon is most talented RB in draft

Gonzaga's Jordan Mathews long road back to the desert

Lonzo Ball on Markelle Fultz: ‘I’m better than him’

Harden: Playing every game should count in MVP discussion

Texans owner: We didn’t know Brock Osweiler well enough

The 'Are you mentally prepared for 'One Shining Moment'?' quiz

NBA Referee Hotline Bling: Serge Ibaka can't connect

Can the Padres' Christian Bethancourt really succeed at pitcher and catcher?

The Raiders will forever belong to Oakland

The Rewind: George Mason's improbable run to the Final Four

Box Score 3/28: Wilt's last game

Baseball movies you can stream now to hold you over until Opening Day

Best, worst and hard to stomach MLB offseason moves

The 28 craziest ballpark foods for the 2017 season

Best of Yardbarker: Did Team USA's victory save the World Baseball Classic?

Breaking down the Naismith Award race

Box Score 3/24: Waiting on West Virginia

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

The 'Are you mentally prepared for 'One Shining Moment'?' quiz

NBA Referee Hotline Bling: Serge Ibaka can't connect

Can the Padres' Christian Bethancourt really succeed at pitcher and catcher?

The Raiders will forever belong to Oakland

Best, worst and hard to stomach MLB offseason moves

The Rewind: George Mason's improbable run to the Final Four

Baseball movies you can stream now to hold you over until Opening Day

Best of Yardbarker: Did Team USA's victory save the World Baseball Classic?

Breaking down the Naismith Award race

Eat, Drink, Watch: Weekends are for upsets

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Follow Yardbarker