Found March 04, 2013 on Waiting For Next Year:
I’m going to be honest with you: I have my misgivings about advanced defensive metrics—especially those that are publicly available to schmoes like you and me.  1   It’s not that I think the methodology behind these stats is flawed or that the approach itself is a silly one—it’s just that all these metrics seem a bit too reliant on two somewhat flimsy inputs. First, there is the simple problem of sample size: it is unlikely that a single player will accrue enough defensive opportunities on different sorts of batted balls in a given year to give us a realistic impression of what his actual skills are.  It’s been said that you need three years of defensive data—I assume playing almost every day—to make up for this paucity.  The second dubious input problem has to do with the data collection itself: the defensive metrics all rely on “stringers” who are actually at the game and tasked with classifying batted balls into categories.  For example, was that ball that Shelley Duncan gracefully tripped for a liner or a hard hit fly ball? Maybe it was a fliner?  Who knows? Which sector of left field was it hit to, section 32 or 33?  Sometimes these stringers are allowed to record data only at their home ballpark, which can introduce all sorts of biases into their data collection.  In short, this is a tricky business and particularly prone to human error. Really though, it’s all we have.  Even though we clearly don’t have the best data out there, we are light years ahead of where we were just ten years ago with respect to measuring individual player defense.  The reason, of course, that I lay out such a long-winded introduction to the state of current defensive metrics is that I want to briefly consider some of them, especially in regard to our outfield makeover. I believe it’s fairly well-accepted that our outfield defense should be improved this season.  For one, we’ll have something resembling an everyday left fielder, which is a great start.  For two, all three of our outfielders have spent considerable stretches of their careers (in some cases, their entire careers) playing center field, typically a sign of elite defensive talent.  For three, there will be none of this, as much as we may well miss it. All of those are sort of subjective measurements though.  It’s great to think we’ll be improved defensively, but really, how many more games might we win because of that improvement?  This is where we have to introduce those defensive metrics, warts and all. So first, I tried to grab both total zone rating and UZR (two different ways to skin the same defensive cat) for the guys who played OF for us last season.  I left a few guys out who played very sparingly (Jason Donald, Brent LilliPUTIANbridge), but for the most part, these are the guys who roamed the power alleys for us last year, along with two measurements of how many runs they saved or (more often) allowed compared against the average player. Name OF-UZR R-TOT AVG Aaron Cunningham 1.5 -3.0 -0.8 Michael Brantley -1.9 -10.0 -6.0 Ezequiel Carrera -3.1 3.0 -0.1 Vinny Rottino 2.4 3.0 2.7 Johnny Damon 1.1 1.0 1.1 Thomas Neal -2.9 0.0 -1.5 Russ Canzler -1.8 -1.0 -1.4 Shelley Duncan -3.1 -2.0 -2.6 Shin-Soo Choo -17.0 -15.0 -16.0 TOTAL -24.4   Some stalwarts may be surprised to see how terribly Choo and Brantley played.  I’ve heard pundits occasionally laud both for their defense, but it’s become more and more accepted in recent years that Choo had only one strength (arm) with quite a few weaknesses (range, first step, going back on balls), while Brantley still profiles as a below average center fielder due to his average range and below average arm.  It should be noted that he looks just dandy 2 in left, as his weaknesses are less pronounced there and the average left fielder is much worse defensively than the average center fielder. Anyway, these metrics suggest that our outfield allowed 20 to 30 more runs than the average MLB outfield would have over the course of the 2012 season. Now let’s look at what our new outfield will look like.  I had to make a few assumptions here.  First, I looked at a player’s entire career and did my best to limit it to the particular position he’ll likely be playing in 2013 for the Indians.  So for instance, I looked only at Brantley’s performance in LF over the course of his entire career.  In Stubbs’ case, this wasn’t possible, as every inning he’s played defensively has been in center, despite that fact that he’ll be moving to right for the Indians.  I’d therefore consider this a somewhat conservative estimate.  Balancing that conservatism, we’re assuming that whoever fills in for these guys on their off-days will be average defensively, which is likely a stretch.  Hopefully these two assumptions balance each other out.  Anyway, here’s the data: UZR-150 R-TOT/yr AVG Drew Stubbs (OF) 3.9 13 8.5 Michael Bourn (CF) 10.7 10 10.4 Michael Brantley (LF) 3.3 8 5.7 TOTAL 18.8   Granted, this methodology isn’t perfect, but just by taking the average of the two most accepted publicly-available defensive metrics suggests that our new outfield could be a net improvement of around 45 runs, which would result in four to five more wins, strictly from improved defense at three positions. There are all sorts of caveats here that I’m not going to get into.  Michael Bourn could lose a step as he enters his 30s.  Drew Stubbs may not adjust well to right field.  The defensive metrics may be flat out wrong.  Or injuries, MY GOD THE INJURIES!!! But using the data we have available, it’s possible that without swinging a bat or stealing a base, our new outfield could win five games strictly by turning batted balls into outs at a more efficient clip than their collective predecessors.  That’s at least something for our pitching staff to dream on. AP Photo/David J. Phillip ___________________________________ Craig just got back from the Sloan Analytics Conference, and I’m dying to talk to him about it.  One item I’m hoping to discuss is the movement toward proprietary, team-housed analytics, especially in regard to defensive valuations in baseball.  This is where it’s going, methinks.  There was a decade or so where the schmoes were outsmarting the teams, but I’m pretty sure that’s over now.  They’ve bought out the geniuses and their IP, and moved it behind closed doors.  The “Moneyball Era” was exciting.  But let’s face it: it’s over. Marte
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

MLB Rumor: Daisuke Matsuzaka unlikely to make Indians roster

This shouldn’t be too surprising to folks keeping up-to-date with all the latest Spring Training news, but it is worth emphasizing again: odds are that free agent Daisuke Matsuzaka won’t make the Indians’ final 25-man roster. Matsuzaka, 32, has battled several injuries in the last few years. He notably had Tommy John surgery in June 2011, which kept him out of MLB action for...

Tribe Happenings: Working around Carrasco’s suspension

Tony returns from his vacation with another edition of the Happenings to check in on how things are going for the Indians in spring training. He talks about the Carlos Carrasco suspension and how the Indians may work around it, the injuries that are starting to pile up, takes a closer look at Corey Kluber and what value he truly brings to the team, updates us on how Rule 5 picks...

Then & Now: Nick Hagadone

Then & Now is a weekly feature at Indians Baseball Insider during the offseason that takes a look at a player's past and present while also offering a possible glimpse into the player's future. It was a busy offseason for the Cleveland Indians as a number of significant moves were made to address some glaring holes exposed last season. Lack of right-handed hitters? Mark...

2013 Indians Top 60 Prospects: #13 OF Luigi Rodriguez

The IBI's 2013 Indians Top 60 Prospect countdown continues on with outfielder Luigi Rodriguez. Defensively and offensively the Indians feel like Rodriguez has as much talent as anybody in the organization, it is just a matter of him putting it together to be more consistent as a player day by day rather than in streaks throughout the year. Tony discusses all the abilities he...

Random Athlete Of The Day- Mark Grudzielanek

Over his fifteen year MLB career, Mark Grudzielanek played for six teams and served as a true veteran shortstop. Grudzielanek was just about everything you could ask for in your above average shortstop, hitting an average of .289 and playing solid defense. Expectations were high when Grudzielanek made his first all-star appearance in just his second season (with the Montreal Expos...

2013 Spring Training Game #12: Indians 13, Cubs 5

Overview Now that’s more like it. The Cleveland Indians snapped a two-game losing streak and got back to their winning ways with a 13-5 victory against the Chicago Cubs in Mesa, Ariz. on Monday. In all honesty, this may have been the most impressive outing by the Indians this season. While they did allow five runs in the contest, the pitching was better than the score indicates...

Carrasco goes 3 innings after being hit in head

Carlos Carrasco pitched three innings after being hit in the side of the head by a comebacker in the first, Mark Reynolds and Nick Swisher each homered to help the Cleveland Indians beat the Chicago Cubs 13-5 Monday. Carrasco was hit on the side of the head by Darnell McDonald's line drive. Carrasco went down on his knees and was tended to by trainers but stayed in the game...

2013 Cleveland Indians Team Preview

                        So I was trying to start this preview off by harkening back to the last glory days of Cleveland in the mid 90′s so I searched for “Indians team picture 1997″, and this was one of the top results with no team picture in sight. I guess it is pretty fitting seeing as how this is a preview of a Cleveland sports team.  Well the Indians never...

Site News: 2013 prospect book update

Tony has been receiving a lot of inquiries as to the availability of his new 2013 Cleveland Indians prospect book. Today he provides a very quick update on the status of it as it is all written and is just in the final stages of completion with putting it together to send to press. He provides an update on that and when it may become available. Over 200 scouting reports in the book this year!!

Cleveland Indians 2013 Top 21 Prospects List

  The Cleveland Indians farm system isn’t the strongest in the majors, with only a couple of elite level prospects, but it’s a pretty deep system. They have a solid core of mid level... [[ This is a content summary only. Visit my website for full links, other content, and more! ]]

Closer Look

Chris Perez has been shut down for 3-4 weeks. The Indians are saying it's due to a shoulder strain. Seems pretty coincidental that Chris Perez rocks a mullet and there's a guy with a "business on top, party in the back" haircut on The Amazing Race this season. I'm calling BS. "Yeah, what's up?" Sorry, didn't mean to actually call BS. ...

Indians 13, Cubs 5

Carlos Carrasco pitched three innings after being hit in the side of the head by a comebacker in the first, Mark Reynolds and Nick Swisher each homered to help the Cleveland Indians beat the Chicago Cubs 13-5 Monday. Carrasco was hit on the side of the head by Darnell McDonald's line drive. Carrasco went down on his knees and was tended to by trainers but stayed in the game...

Mike Aviles Reunites With Former Teammates During Red Sox’ Scrimmage With Puerto Rico (Video)

A familiar face was back in Fort Myers on Tuesday. Former Red Sox shortstop Mike Aviles returned to JetBlue Park as a member of Team Puerto Rico, which dropped a 4-3 decision to the Sox in a World Baseball Classic tune-up. Aviles has had a tumultuous offseason, first being traded to Toronto in exchange for manager John Farrell (a deal that he called “weird”) before being shipped...

Cubs Pitchers Now Know How Custer Felt

Nick Swisher singled twice, homered, and drove-in four runs, Lonnie Chisenhall singled, doubled, and homered, and collected three RBI, Drew Stubbs singled and tripled and drove-in three runs, and Mark Reynolds homered and doubled and knocked-in two runs, leading a 20-hit attack as the Clevaland Indians scalped the Cubs 13-5 in Cactus League action this afternoon at Dwight Paterson...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.