Found August 12, 2012 on Fox Sports:
Colorado_rockies_vs_29e4
After Johan Santana no-hit the defending champion St. Louis Cardinals on June 1, the New York Mets -- reveling in the first such pitching performance in the franchise's long, agonizing history -- sat at 29-23 on the season. It was, for the first time in a long time, a good time to be them. The 29 wins represented the team's highest win total at that point in a season since 2007, and New York found itself just one game behind Washington for the NL East lead at the time. By the start of July, the Mets were still hanging in there, just 2.5 games behind the Nationals at 43-36 and still in line for a wild card spot. Still so far, so good. But something has happened in the Big Apple since June gave way to July that can only be explained with the type of generalities that have become all too familiar to the team's fervent and increasingly unimpressed fan base: The Mets did what you knew the Mets would do. They've made the least of a tailor-made opportunity, with the Phillies surprisingly bumbling about the bottom of the division and the new-look Marlins underperforming, too, and they've failed to capitalize on a rare chance to put together a season worth remembering. New York has won just 11 of 35 games since the end of June -- fewer than every team in baseball except the woeful Houston Astros -- a slide that was defined by a pitiful 2-13 start to the second half of the season. And after Saturday's 9-3 loss to the Braves (the Mets' 11th defeat in their last 12 games at Citi Field) New York finds itself at 54-60, 17 games out of first in the division and almost certainly out of the postseason for the 11th time in 12 seasons. It's been a disappointing -- but, unfortunately, not altogether surprising -- collapse by the Mets, to say the least. But there's still some comfort to be taken in the three good months of baseball they played and the shred of hope it seemed to give the team and its fans for the future. But is it real hope? It's certainly too early to tell for sure, but it's hard to think that New York's temporary brush with success is a sign that prolonged good fortune is in its future. There were some bright moments that shouldn't be forgotten, of course, like the aforementioned no-hitter from Santana, the ongoing resurrection of knuckleballer R.A. Dickey's career and the resurgence of third baseman David Wright, who is having his best season since 2008. But the team's collective collapse of late has rendered most of the positives of the first half of the season irrelevant. Santana, for starters, has been a mess since his no-hitter, going 3-5 with a 6.54 ERA after blanking the Cardinals until landing on the DL with shoulder soreness. Over his last four starts, dating back to July 6 -- and including the eight earned runs he allowed in 1-1/3 innings Saturday in his first start after a three-week DL stint -- Santana is 0-4 with a 17.53 ERA and a WHIP of 3.00. Now many fans are wondering if the flashes the two-time former Cy Young winner showed of his former self -- Santana was 3-2 with a 2.38 ERA in 11 starts as of June 1 -- were little more than fool's gold in the wake of a shoulder injury that cost the lefty all of 2011. Fans in Flushing have also been left to wonder what to make of the astonishing season Dickey has put together. The knuckleballer was, hands down, the pitching sensation of the first half, going 12-1 with a 2.40 ERA before the break -- including a five-start stretch where he was nearly unhittable, going 5-0 with a 0.00 ERA and an opponent batting average of .119. However, since the start of July, Dickey has struggled -- though not to the degree Santana has -- going 3-2 with a 4.01 ERA that can't help but make fans wonder whether he's a long-term solution or just a feel-good flash in the pan. It's a tough question to answer, because there's not a nicer guy in the world than Dickey, and when he's on and the knuckler's fluttering like it was Thursday against Miami, he's deadly. But it has to be answered -- along with questions about Santana, Wright and others -- because the Mets are at a crossroads and they need to settle on a direction. For the first time in a long time, New York's payroll is under $100 million and the Mets finally have some flexibility moving forward. So the decision whether to proceed with the pieces they have or blow the whole thing up and start over is a big one. Santana, who has a full no-trade clause, is signed through 2013 with a club option that could pay him $25 million for 2014. The Mets also have a $5 million option on Dickey for 2013, so both can be part of the equation moving forward if the Mets want them to be. That said, is building a staff around a dinged-up former star and a 37-year-old one-time washout specializing in the game's most fickle pitch really the best idea? As for the rest of the rotation, Jon Niese will be back, as he's signed through at least 2016, but Dillon Gee's contract only runs through this year, as do the deals of Mike Pelfrey (arbitration-eligible for 2013) and Jeremy Hefner. Pelfrey underwent season-ending Tommy John surgery in May, a clot in Gee's right shoulder likely ended his season in July and the rookie Hefner is 2-3 with a 5.13 ERA in six starts this year, so there's a case to be made for moving on without all of them, too. Then there's the issue of the $16 million club option on Wright this winter and a $17 million option on the disappointing Jason Bay for 2014. Parting ways with the latter would be easy; the former, not so much. But maybe that's exactly what the Mets need to do. Because as good as it was to be them on June 1, it's equally bad, or worse, now. What New York is currently doing -- and has done for the better part of the last decade -- clearly isn't working, it finally has the means and the chance to move in a new direction, and it would be a shame to let that opportunity pass by for more of the same disappointment. You can follow Sam Gardner on Twitter or email him at samgardnerfox@gmail.com .
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Is Johan Santana Becoming A Burden?

With the decline of 2012 New York Mets, many fans have rightfully reset their sights on what the future holds.  Even prior to the trade deadline, when there was still an outside chance of the team turning its free fall around, some fans sought additions for next season, 2014 and beyond.  The notion is sound, but there are multiple situations impeding such moves.  First and foremost...

Decision to rush back Johan Santana leads to a single teardrop

During the last couple of seasons of Omar Minaya’s tenure, the joke went that the Mets had turned into the Kremlin when discussing injuries. Every time a player was injured, it started off as day-to-day and then somehow turned into a season-ending injury, much like how Soviet leaders would start off with a cold and end up dead. The Mets under Sandy Alderson promised to be more...

Johan Santana the next Mike Hampton?

Comparing Johan Santana to Mike Hampton sounds rather stupid at first glance. First of all, Mike Hampton at his best was never as good as Johan Santana was at his best. But Hampton was pretty darn good in his hay days. Both were rather slight, left-handed pitchers. Hampton was 5'10, 185. Santana is 6'0, 200. Both received huge contracts after their great years and both ran...

Should the Mets shut Johan Santana down for the season?

Saturday night, during the New York Mets 9-3 loss to the Atlanta Braves, starter Johan Santana allowed eight runs in just 1 1/3 innings — matching the shortest start of his career –  in his first start since coming off the disabled list. For those of us hoping a trip to the DL would allow Johan to return to his pre-no-hitter form, we were sorely mistaken as his downward spiral...

Johan Santana’s Rehab Start In Brooklyn (Photos!)

As you know, last Sunday Johan Santana made an excellent rehab start in Brooklyn as he allowed one hit and one walk in three shutout innings against the Doubledays while striking out 3. He then went on to continue his start in a simulated game in the pen. Oh, I was there too and took a lot of photos: First, there was an Old Time Baseball Game before the start Being Introduced ...

Pre-Game: Braves (65-47) @ Mets (54-59)

Johan Santana returns after his rehab start with Brooklyn on Sunday The Mets look to bounce back after losing the opening game of their three-game set with the Atlanta Braves last night by the score of 4-0 at the hands of Paul Maholm. Today the Mets throw a left-hander of their own as Johan Santana makes his return from the 15-Day DL after recovering from an ankle injury as well...

Braves chase Santana early, rout Mets

NEW YORK (AP) -- Freddie Freeman had five RBIs in the first two innings and the Atlanta Braves battered Johan Santana in his return from the disabled list, routing the sluggish New York Mets 9-3 on Saturday night. Michael Bourn had three hits, Chipper Jones chased Santana with an RBI single in a seven-run second inning and Atlanta sent the two-time Cy Young Award winner to the worst...

Santana Is Back As Mets Look To Solve Kris Medlen And The Braves

Johan Santana was in command and wowed the crowd at MCU Park during his rehab start where he hit 90 MPH on the radar gun. Starting Lineup Ruben Tejada, ss Daniel Murphy, 2b David Wright, 3b Ike Davis, 1b Scott Hairston, rf Mike Baxter, lf Andres Torres, cf Josh Thole, c Johan Santana, lhp Game Preview The Mets and Braves play game two tonight at Citi Field. Last night the Mets...

Mets News and Notes: Santana, Wilpon, Olson, Wheeler

Mets News and Notes: Johan Santana insisted his right ankle and pitching shoulder were healthy after he only recorded four outs, matching his shortest career start, which happened to be in Atlanta in April.  The Braves beat the Mets, 9-3, Saturday at Citi Field. The Mets (54-60) dropped a season-worst six games under .500. Santana was charged with eight runs, two shy of his career...

Mets Designate Garrett Olson For Assignment

The Mets designated left-hander Garrett Olson for assignment to make room for on the roster for Johan Santana who was officially activated from the DL. The move leaves Josh Edgin as the only lefty reliever in the bullpen. Olson was charged with four runs while recording only one out in his lone appearance.

Mets vs. Braves: Series Preview

It would be an understatement to say the Mets have been disappointing so far in the second half. It’s time to see what’s in store for them this weekend against the Braves. This is a series between two teams going in completely different directions. The Braves are playing some of their best baseball of the series, going 12-3 over their last 15 games. What about those Mets? Well...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.