Originally posted on Phillies Nation  |  Last updated 11/17/11
9a


In the middle of his magical 2008 season, Brad Lidge inked a three year extension instead of becoming a free agent at the end of the year from then GM Pat Gillick. While Gillick made several shrewd moves to pick up the likes of JC Romero, Matt Stairs, Chad Durbin, and Jayson Werth, Lidge’s contract is a gaffe in Gillick’s tenure only comparable to the minuscule return the Phillies received for Bobby Abreu and Cory Lidle and his nearly unforgivable signing of Adam Eaton.

When discussing the Jonathan Papelbon contract, many Phillies Nation readers aptly pointed out that from 2009 through 2011, Lidge received nearly the same per year contract value that Papelbon will be paid. This is true. It is also true that even a cursory exploration of comparing the seasons leading up to both extension, Papelbon was leaps and bounds the better pitcher.

Using fWar from FanGraphs and a concept they introduced, when comparing nth best seasons, only Lidge’s stellar 2004 compares to how well Papelbon pitched in any of his first six seasons. To put things in perspective, Lidge’s stellar 2008 would only be good enough for a tie for Papelbon’s fourth best season.

So what exactly does this mean? For one, it does not necessarily mean the Phillies got a bargain when they signed Papelbon, but it does mean they are shrewder now than they were in 2008. The move to extend Lidge midseason made sense and gave them position and cost certainty for 2009 with a player having what appeared to be a career year at age 32, but it also committed 8% of their payroll to their closer. Papelbon’s $12.5 million is close to 7% of the Phillies estimated 2012 payroll for a significantly better closer whose is closing out games for a significantly better pitching staff with no Major League injury track record.

Looking back, Lidge’s contract at the time should have been seen as a mistake. The good news? The Phillies, even heading into 2009, were relatively unstable with attendance and they weren’t quite the local television power they currently are now. They were able to weather the financial blow caused by Lidge’s missed time and still add payroll in mid-season trades in 2009, 2010, and 2011. Even in the worst case scenario, a complete bomb-out by Papelbon, the Phillies, who were in a much weaker and less stable economic position in 2008 when the Lidge extension was signed, will undoubtedly be able to recover.

Yet, there is no doubt that comparing Lidge’s and Papelbon’s contracts are like comparing apples to oranges but what can be compared is how effectively the Phils are choosing to spend their money. $12.5 million per year right now for Jonathan Papelbon is a much safer and better risk than spending $12 million per year for Brad Lidge in 2009.

MORE FROM YARDBARKER:
Most strikeouts by a hitter in a single season
GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Report: ‘All signs point to’ Robert Griffin III starting in Week 14

Blake Bortles calls 2016 season ‘the biggest nightmare possible’

Report: Rondo suspended for 'heated exchange' with coach

Zimmer returns to Vikings, should make trip to Jacksonville

Report: Johnson ‘leading contender’ to be UK ambassador

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Matt Barnes accused of choking woman at nightclub

Final College Football Playoff rankings: Alabama reigns

WATCH: Tyler Lockett opens 2nd half with 75-yard TD

Newton benched on first play, Anderson immediately throws INT

Former commissioner Bud Selig and Braves GM John Schuerholz are headed to the Hall of Fame

WATCH: Josh Lambo has worst FG attempt of season so far

Cult of Sport: Before there was Ezekiel Elliott, there was Eric Dickerson

MLB Winter Meetings primer: Every team's trade temperature on the hot stove

James Franklin, Penn State come up roses

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

Sporting life: Gifts for real fans (that aren't ugly NFL sweaters)

Best of Yardbarker: CFB Championship Week chaos

New faces help Spurs continue unparalleled success

The Pirates prepare for rarely chartered waters in dealing Andrew McCutchen

Joakim Noah’s contract is becoming worst deal in NBA

Top 10 takeaways from Sunday’s Week 13 NFL action

Box Score 12/2: High-kicking it into the weekend

Jeff Fisher is the unkillable cockroach of NFL head coaches

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

Cult of Sport: Before there was Ezekiel Elliott, there was Eric Dickerson

Winter Meetings primer: Every team's trade temperature on the hot stove

James Franklin, Penn State come up roses

Final College Football Playoff rankings: Alabama reigns

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

Sporting life: Gifts for real fans (that aren't ugly NFL Christmas sweaters)

New faces help Spurs continue unparalleled success

The Pirates prepare for rarely chartered waters in dealing Andrew McCutchen

Everything you need to know for CFB Championship Week

Jeff Fisher is the unkillable cockroach of NFL head coaches

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker