Found September 21, 2013 on isportsweb.com:
(Follow me on Twitter @jim_krug; opening image credit post-gazette) Watching last night’s game unravel the way it did took this writer back 21 years.  For the life of me, I can’t remember a worse Pittsburgh Pirates loss since Sid Bream slid home in Game 7 of the 1992 NLCS. 1.  Courtesy of @ESPNStatsInfo: Pirates lost a game after leading by 3 or more runs entering 9th inning for 1st time since 2009. They had won 163 straight. @EliasSports And not only did they lose what was statistically a nearly un-losable game, but everything else went wrong in the Wild Card standings as well.  The Milwaukee Brewers choked after rallying to tie their game against the St. Louis Cardinals at 6.  One of the best hitters in the NL in Carlos Gomez couldn’t drive in the winning run, and the Cardinals won in 10 innings, stretching their Division lead to what could be an insurmountable 2 games. 2.  Meanwhile, the Washington Nationals- still not out of the playoff picture despite how much Pirates’ fans want them to be- hammered the hapless Miami Marlins 8-0.  The Nationals are now only 4 games back of both the Pirates and Reds in the Wild Card race, with 8 to play.  If the Nationals win out, the Pirates would have to finish the season 4-4 to beat them.   The Nationals are 8-2 over their last 10, the Pirates?  5-5.  As I’ve stated in previous articles, this is going to get too close for comfort, despite the Pirates’ “99%” likelihood of reaching the postseason. 3.  Clint Hurdle, ladies and gentlemen.  Clint Hurdle.  Over the past month in particular, the Pirates’ manager has made some ridiculous substitutions, including pinch-hitting for players that had hit home runs in the same game on multiple occasions.  So as a fan, it’s absolutely baffling that Hurdle- ejected in the 8th inning, but clearly still lurking somewhere in the clubhouse- would have both Jordy Mercer (14 errors in only 99 games) and Pedro Alvarez (27 errors) out there.  That’s a combined 41 errors on the hot side of the infield! Hurdle; image credit qualityatbats 4.  And it would be one thing if the Pirates went into the top of the 9th with only a 1- or 2-run lead.  I can see the thinking there in keeping your best bats in the game if there is a rally.  But a 3-run lead?  Again, reference the statistic given by ESPN in #1 above.  If there’s one thing I’ll give SS Clint Barmes and his $5.5MM contract credit for, it’s being an outstanding defender.  There’s no reason why he shouldn’t have been an automatic defensive substitute for Mercer in every game this September. 5.  What made this gaffe even worse is the fact that Hurdle immediately lied about it to the media, a lie that was quickly exposed as falsehood. Colin Dunlap ‏@colin_dunlap 13s Hurdle said Mercer always finishes games he starts. Not so. Been replaced 7 times this season: May 12, Jul 26, 27; Aug 10, 13; Sept 15, 17.      6.  The Manager also was quick to throw his own players under the bus to the media, and attempt to cover his own tracks: “It’s only because Jordy made the error that we’re asking these questions,” Hurdle said. Jon Morosi (@jonmorosi)  Hurdle said Liriano made clear he was done after 8 innings, said Liriano told staff, “That’s it.”    Learn Spanish for “No Francisco, get back out there.” Image credit hdnux 7.  This leads us to the question of, “Why was a shaky Mark Melancon out there anyway?”  Francisco Liriano was cruising through 8 complete innings at only 94 pitches- less than 12 per inning.  The Pirates’ coaches couldn’t convince the 16-game winning lefty to trot back out for one more to lock down the victory himself? And frankly, if Liriano did say that, shame on him for wussing out of such a high-stakes game.  He’s supposed to be a veteran, and late September baseball is usually the time when veterans shine.  If Liriano wanted no part of finishing such a vital game, then that has to raise concerns about his mental fortitude *if* the Pirates are faced with a future decision of what SP to throw during a 1-game Wild Card. 8.  To me, the Pirates’ bullpen is looming as a major liability to this point.  Former closer Jason Grilli is clearly not back to his pre-injury velocity or dominance.  And even though it took most of the season, the book is clearly out now on Melancon.  In back-to-back blown saves against the Reds and San Diego Padres, opposing right-handed hitters have been waiting on his cut fastball, and taking the tailing pitch the opposite way to RF with ease.  One fan last night remarked that this was the “same Melancon he was used to seeing as a member of the Scranton/Wilkes-Barre Yankees.”  Not good. 9.  Some insights that DID go right last night:  Hurdle or whomever was managing in his stead correctly positioned Mercer earlier in the 9th inning, to snag what should’ve been an easy single up the middle by powerhitter Jay Bruce- a great call that will be lost due to the disaster that unfolded immediately after.  And then in the post-game, broadcaster Kent Tekulve had this apt observation: Dejan Kovacevic (@Dejan_Kovacevic)  Teke speaking truth right now about Dusty vs. Cutch: “Long-standing pattern … first game of every series … way too much information.”                                                             Seething after a previous Dusty Baker retaliation; image credit fansided On one hand, I can respect the Pirates for not wanting to retaliate and target the Reds’ best players, but the team is clearly now intimidated by the beanballs against Andrew McCutchen, and with no assistance in the form of automatic ejections from MLB umpiring crews, they’re to the point where they might have to follow Adrienne’s advice to Rocky: “Hit him back!” 10.  The upcoming Cardinals-Nationals series is lurking as both ugly and significant in the wake of last night’s events.  It could easily become a Catch-22: Pirates’ fans may find themselves rooting for the cursed Cardinals to vanquish Washington’s Wild Card pursuit once and for all, but in doing so, would also be supporting St. Louis wrapping up the NL Central Division title.   While they may need help from other teams over these last 8 games, it is solely up to the Pirates to ensure that last night’s meltdown isn’t remembered with the same significance as Sid Bream’s slide.  Thanks for reading.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Pirates A.J. Burnett is still mulling over retirement

A.J. Burnett said during spring training that he was considering retiring after the 2013 season. Six months later he’s still thinking about the possibility. According to Karen Price of the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review Burnett said yesterday that retirement has been in the back of his mind all season and that he’s “50-50″ on whether to return in 2014. The 36-year-old indicated...

Dave Parker is Still a Pirates Fan

Now, I'm not sure whether this should be filed under "awesome" or "sad". Earlier this week, an eagle-eyed fan spotted former big leaguer Dave Parker at a Cincinnati grocery store...decked out in full Pittsburgh Pirates gear.  And I've gotta add, "The Cobra" is looking every bit as good as he did during his eleven-year stint with the Bucs...

All Aboard The Cole Train

Gerrit Cole has been on prospect radars for years. He’s been there for good reason; near triple digit heat, huge frame, and good off-speed stuff. He finally arrived in Pittsburgh this year and the results have been extremely positive. As of today, Mr. Cole has a 3.23 ERA. His peripherals paint an even prettier picture, albeit slight, with a 2.98 FIP and 3.18 xFIP. To put that in...

Pirates replace Mark Melancon with Jason Grilli as closer

The Pirates' bullpen ERA of 2.88 ranks second to the Braves (2.42) and Pittsburgh is tied with Atlanta for the league lead at 51 saves. The Shark Tank as the Pirates' pen has become known is one enormous reason why Pittsburgh is looking at postseason play for the first time in two decades. But suddenly things have spun off kilter and now the Pirates will look to old closer...

Game 156 Preview: Pirates vs. Reds

Reds (88-67) at Pirates (89-66) 1:35 PM–PNC Park, Pittsburgh MLB.com Gameday TV: ROOT It’s the final regular season home game of the year for the Pirates, and that’s usually a sad day. Today, though, it’s just one more huge game, and there’s a very good chance that the Bucs will return to PNC for a postseason home game, although that’s no guarantee (I put the odds at...

Game 155: Pirates 4 Reds 2

Let's all exhale just a little bit.  After last night's debacle, the Pirates got a little bit of everything that they needed tonight. AJ Burnett came out tonight with a slider that should've been required by law to have a turn signal affixed to it. He spotted the Reds a 2-0 lead, then completely shut them down from innings 3-7. He racked up 12 strikeouts in total...

Burnett leads Pirates past Reds 4-2

A.J. Burnett scattered four hits over seven strong innings to lead the Pittsburgh Pirates over the Cincinnati Reds 4-2 on Saturday night. Burnett (9-11) struck out a season-high 12 as the Pirates moved a game in front of Cincinnati for the top spot in the NL wild-card race. Jason Grilli worked the ninth for his 31st save, his first since going to the disabled list with a strained...

The 5 Worst MVP Seasons

So this is the third and probably final article I’ve written in this vein. If you’re interested in this kind of thing, you can check out the 5 Worst Seasons with 120+ RBI and the 5 Worst Seasons with 20+ Wins. I went back to 1931, the first year that the BBWAA started voting for the MVP award. I was informed by WAR, but it was not decisive. Debate is welcomed. Honorable Mention...

Game 154 Preview: Pirates vs. Reds

Reds (87-66) at Pirates (88-65) 7:05 PM–PNC Park, Pittsburgh MLB.com Gameday TV: ROOT, MLBN Remember all the babbling earlier this summer (and even last summer) about “the biggest series in the history of PNC Park?” Yeah, this is bigger. With nine games to play, the Bucs begin their final home regular season series of the year with a division title still in reach. They will...

Game 154: Reds 6 Pirates 5

I think ... disheartening. I think that's the word. I want to say devastating, but I honestly feel like once we have a tad more perspective that it's just a little too strong. The reality is that the Pirates were longshots to win the NL Central before this game began tonight, and they were longshots to win the NL Central when it seemed like they were certain to win it, and...

Game 155 Preview: Pirates vs. Reds

Reds (88-66) at Pirates (88-66) 7:05 PM–PNC Park, Pittsburgh MLB.com Gameday TV: ROOT The Bucs will try and pick themselves up from a tough defeat yet again and bounce back with a win to move back ahead of the Reds. Eight games remain on the year, and it’s a toss up as to who will have home field in the wild card game between these two clubs (assuming neither overtakes the Cards...

Pirates 4, Reds 2

The Pirates came back on Saturday for a much needed feel good victory over the Reds, moving them back in to second place by themselves and evening the series. After Friday’s brutal finish, it was nice to see another huge and fired up crowd be able to celebrate and go home happy. The night belonged to A.J. Burnett. Sadly, it’s possible that this could have been his final start...

Reds-Pirates Preview

Currently atop the wild-card standings, the Pittsburgh Pirates and Cincinnati Reds know what's at stake this weekend. Pittsburgh's Francisco Liriano goes toe-to-toe with Cincinnati's Mat Latos as these NL Central rivals open a crucial three-game set Friday night at PNC Park. After managing four runs during a three-game skid, the Pirates (88-65) beat San Diego 10-1 on...

Pittsburgh Pirates vs. Cincinnati Reds – Game 155

Ah yes.  Like me you probably thought there was no way for the Pirates to lose that game. In my lifetime watching the Pirates that was probably the second most devastating loss I’ve been witness to. We don’t need to get into the worst…… It’s easy to just say “alright, tough one, move forward.” but…

Pittsburgh Pirates vs. Cincinnati Reds – Game 156

I hope last night’s performance put your mind at ease a bit.  I certainly understand the nerves, this has been such a long time coming, but it’s such a longshot at this point that the Pirates miss the playoffs.  This has just been a crazy time.  Something we aren’t used to as baseball fans. Anyway,…
Pirates News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.