Originally written on isportsweb.com  |  Last updated 10/17/14
Mlb-philadelphia-phillies
The Pirates’ curious decision to forego 2 reasonably-priced option years for catcher Ryan Doumit was compounded last week Image credit gearupforsports when the club signed backstop Rod Barajas to a 1-year $4,000,000 contract, with a 2013 club option for $3,500,000.  Barajas is inferior to Doumit in almost every aspect.  Consider the following: 1.  Age- Doumit will be 31 in the 2012 season, Barajas 36.  Despite the “depth” GM Neal Huntington has supposedly built in this organization, it’s disconcerting that he’s still relying on Dave Littlefield-esque veterans in their mid-30′s a full 4 years into his “successful” tenure. 2.  Production- Doumit had an excellent 128 OPS+ last season, which has largely gone overlooked by both fans and the Pirates alike.  Barajas had a 97 OPS+, or slightly below average for the catching position.  But what Barajas has in power is completely nulified by his abysmal on base skills.  Barajas hasn’t had a .300+ OBP since George W. Bush was in office.  His OBP’s over the past 4 seasons are… 2011  .287   2010  .284   2009  .258   2008  .294 In fact, the only time in his career Barajas finished well over a .300 OBP was in a small sampling of 48 games for the Philadelphia Phillies in 2007.  In fact, Barajas has finished below .300 in 9 of his 11 MLB seasons (not counting 5-game stints in 1999 and 2000…when he also finished under .300). We’re dealing with a player whose career .284 OBP is the catching equivalent of Ronny Cedeno- who the Pirates just released due to his lack of production. 3.  Defensive Ability- The major knock against Doumit is his declining play behind the plate.  Those concerns are well-warranted, although I don’t think it would be difficult to move his bat to 1B, where he has played off and on throughout his career.  But Barajas isn’t any better.  Defensive catching metrics have Barajas as the better career defender, but slightly worse in 2011.  And being 5 years older, he isn’t likely to improve. 4. Durability- Another slight on Doumit is his tendency for fluke injuries season after season.  But both Barajas and Doumit have only eclipsed 400 at bats twice in their careers (and Doumit’s is 4 years shorter).  In fairness, much of Barajas’s low at bat totals are due to his status as a backup for some of his career.  But is a 36-year old backup catcher really the solution?   So in summary, Barajas is older, less productive at the plate, an OBP black hole, and defensively, is just as questionable as Doumit.  So why the move?  In my mind, here’s the one number that mattered: Doumit  $15,000,000 over 2 seasons Barajas  $4,000,000 over 1, with a max of $7,500,000 over 2 Simply put, this was a matter of saving money on an already league-low payroll.  And we as fans are going to pay the price for that come 2012. Thanks for reading.  
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

Peyton Manning sets NFL touchdown passing record

Report: CJ Spiller suffers broken collarbone

DeMarco Murray sets record with another 100-yard game

Report: Things got 'ugly' in Bears' locker room after loss

Redskins bench Kirk Cousins for Colt McCoy

Rams beat Seahawks thanks to gutsy fake punt call

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Brian Kelly unloads on officials for pass interference call

Brett Favre: I got calls about playing last season

Joseph Randle partners with underwear company after arrest

Report: Seahawks asked about Julius Thomas, Jordan Cameron

Florida fans chant for Will Muschamp to be fired

Gennady Golovkin scores second-round knockout win

10 takeaways from NFL Week 7

Video: Alec Burks breaks Kobe Bryant's ankles

WATCH: Sean Payton has tense exchange with reporter

Darnell Dockett mocks Raiders fans with whiteboard

WATCH: Tony Romo nearly runs over Alex Rodriguez

WATCH: Prince Amukamara pulls Dwayne Harris' hair

What was the meaning behind Doug Baldwin's TD celebration?

Luke Kuechly ejected after questionable call

WATCH: Giovanni Bernard gets leveled by Vontae Davis

WATCH: Rams run awesome trick play for punt return TD

Kyle Orton shaves his epic mustache

Florida State beats Notre Dame 31-27 in thriller

MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Favre: I got calls about playing last season

10 takeaways from NFL Week 7

Report: Marshall calls out Jay Cutler

Darnell Dockett mocks Raiders fans

Brian Kelly unloads on officials

WATCH: Rams run punt return trick play for TD

Joseph Randle now an underwear spokesman?

Ex-Trojans RB escorted out after USC game

FSU tops Notre Dame in thriller

Fans chant for Muschamp's head

Popovich zings Suns owner

Golden Tate reacts to Percy Harvin trade

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.