Found December 06, 2011 on Race Review Online:


Jose Reyes, the anticipated new shortstop for the Miami Marlins, is a very talented man. He is a formidable force offensively, despite not possessing a level of patience that you would hope for in a leadoff hitter, and though he commits too many errors for a tenured player his range and power arm allow him to influence games defensively to a sometimes dramatic degree.

He is, then, by all accounts, an impact player. As any observer of the Mets and Reyes would tell you, however, sometimes that impact leaves a depression rather than an impression on the team as a whole. It’s really a combination of realities that tend to take the shine off of Reyes resume, though arguably the one issue that stands out above all others is his pathological inability to stay on the field.

It is for this reason, among others, that Miami’s decision to throw big money at Reyes might very well be a decision that they regret. While it should be noted that Reyes did enjoy a four year run where he averaged 158 games, specifically from 2005 through 2008, he is 3 full seasons removed from that period.

When you consider that Reyes has averaged just 117 games or so over his nine year career, however, and just 98 over the past three seasons due to a 2009 season that saw him appear in just 36 contests, it’s appropriate to wonder what the Marlins were thinking when they locked Reyes up for six years guaranteed.

Had Reyes’ string of injuries been varied in nature and scope, or the result of unavoidable freak accidents of some kind, then it would be reasonable for Miami to presume that Reyes will be in the lineup more frequently over these next six years than he has in the past. Unfortunately, for Miami at least, this is simply not the case. In reality, Reyes has missed the vast majority of the time that he has due to serious issues he’s had with his legs, primarily his hamstrings.

Is Reyes still young? Yes, at 28 he is still young. His youth, however, has not seemed to serve him well in terms of aiding him in keeping healthy and on the field. As he ages, then, can the expectation really be that he will avoid injuries to his legs, the very legs that elevate his game and contribute to him being the force that he is?

Not coincidentally, when Reyes was averaging those 158 games per season he also averaged right around 65 stolen bases a year. Over these past three seasons, though, there has been a decided decline in Reyes’ running game.

Focusing on the 2010 and 2011 seasons, and throwing out 2009 due to Reyes having only played 36 games, the former Mets shortstop stole a combined 69 bases, Though Reyes averaged just 130 games played across those two seasons the reality is that this fact does not compensate for the decline in stolen bases. A quick comparison shows us that whereas Reyes stole a base once every 2.4 games from 2005 through 2008 it took him 3.7 games to do the same over 2010 and 2011.

These numbers are not offered as some form of petty analysis, not by any means. The fact is that Reyes’ value is very much tied to his speed and the affect that speed has on his team’s performance. His OBP is a relatively healthy .345 over his career in seasons where he plays at least 126 games as he did this past season. He’s achieved that level in Mets’ lineups where the support has not historically been what he can expect it to be with Hanley Ramirez and Mike Stanton behind him, not to mention King Albert Pujols if that should come to pass.

Translated, Reyes should expect to see his OBP number rise with a better cast behind him. If this is how things develop then the likelihood is that Reyes’ ability to swipe bases would be a welcome asset. While the Marlins would be careful to not run themselves out of innings, of course, Reyes’ ability to advance a base without need of outside assistance would add a lethal element to what figures to be a much improved Marlin offense.

As daunting as this challenge associated with Reyes’ health may be, it is not the only issue associated with his joining the Marlins. The Marlins, you see, already had a shortstop in the person of Hanley Ramirez, and he was perhaps one of the best two or three in the game at that. With Reyes aboard there are just two possibilities available, and neither figure to make the notoriously moody Ramirez all that happy.

The first option available would be to move Ramirez to 3B, and this was of course one of the components in the grand plan associated with acquiring Reyes. Ramirez is a large man, 6’3 “ and 230 pounds to be exact, and so in the long term perhaps he was destined for the move away from short regardless.

Neither Ramirez nor Reyes are consistently stellar defenders at this point in their respective careers, though with that said each is steady enough so as not to be a liability by any measure. The Marlins don’t lose anything or gain anything defensively by replacing Ramirez with Reyes, however what they may lose is the already narrow attention span that Ramirez has a tendency to display. Let’s face it, Ramirez was disgruntled when he was the star of the show, playing fiddle 1A might just cause him to go Viking.

The other option available would be to move Ramirez now, right in the middle of his incredibly inexpensive contract. With just over $46 million due to him over the next three seasons Ramirez is the definition of a steal, and there are any number of teams that could use a shortstop that can hit 35-40 HR’s and drive in 100+ runs while hitting above .300. Ramirez does not have a no-trade clause to junk up the works, and perhaps the most obvious suitor would be the team that Ramirez originally came from, the Boston Red Sox.

The Red Sox have a large payroll as it is, of course, however they have missed the playoffs for two consecutive seasons in a city that doesn’t accept mediocrity from their sports teams. Boston has a number of highly touted prospects that are blocked at the major league level, one of which just so happens to be a 3B prospect in Will Middlebrooks that could be the primary return from Miami’s perspective. Middlebrooks would be part of a larger package, of course, and the package would undoubtedly have to include a player or players either on the Red Sox roster in 2011 or who figure to play a role in 2012. Think OF Josh Reddick, rookie C/1B Ryan Lavarnway, OF Ryan Kalish, and perhaps a top tier pitching prospect or two.

Regardless of which direction the Marlins decide on, it can be said that the signing of Reyes may have created more issues than it solved. Understood that they are heavily involved in the Pujols chase, and understood that they have a brand-new ballpark to fund, however bringing Reyes on board has committed major budget to a brittle player and possibly created tremendous friction in terms of the anticipated reaction of Hanley Ramirez. Throw the ever-flammable Ozzie Guillen into the mix as manager and we could be looking at the beginnings of a long, bloody campaign.

What the Marlins organization has done with the signing of Reyes and others, and the pursuit of Pujols as well, is signal the remainder of the baseball world that they will no longer be content with building from within, shooting for a title within a small window of time, and then dismantling the franchise every few years. It remains to be seen if this dramatic departure from previous form was wise, but what cannot be denied is that it has already been enormously entertaining.








Marlins will make Reyes cut his hair

Rules are rules. The Miami Marlins may be serious about spending money this offseason, as evidenced by the $106 million they threw at Jose Reyes and the $200 million-plus they are dangling in front of Albert Pujols, but it would appear they are still serious about their clubhouse rules as well. As they did with [...]

Jose Reyes: Mets "Didn't Want Me"

The courtship for Jose Reyes by the Miami Marlins began at one minute past midnight on Nov. 3 and was finalized Sunday with a six-year $106 million contract because of the New York Mets feeble effort to sign their four-time All-Star shortstop. "They didn't make me an offer," said Reyes decked out in a new Marlins jersey at a press conference  in Miami this afternoon...

Photo: Jose Reyes in a Marlins hat, thanks the Mets

“I have to thank the New York Mets for giving me the opportunity to play in the big leagues,” Jose Reyes said this afternoon, while wearing his new Marlins hat and jersey. “Right now, I’m really excited and happy to go to Miami.I’m part of this family now, and I have to move on.” He said he has a lot of love for his fans in New York, who supported him through the good...

Jose Is Gone -- I'm Officially Over It

So, its been about 72 hours since former Met, Jose Reyes, decided to sign with the Marlins for 6 year/$106 million dollar deal.  I was mad at first.  Too mad to write about it, as our lovely little site here rightfully frowns on profanity.  Then I wrote about it and now...I'm good.  I've never been one of those "the sky is falling" type of fans.  After a few...

Was Jose Reyes Worth The Money?

After writing previously that the Marlins might be spending on the wrong things after the Heath Bell signing, of course, the Marlins prove everyone wrong and go out and sign Jose Reyes to a pretty big deal: six years at $106 million guaranteed, with an option for a seventh year as the Marlins pay Reyes big time money for him to man the 6-hole into his age 35 season. The contract...

Mets crumbling under Wilpons' debts

Among the events in Mets history that will live in infamy, Jose Reyes' defection to the Marlins ranks close to the top -- right there with the trade that sent Tom Seaver to the Reds in 1977. Yes, it's true, Reyes is leaving of his own free will, signing a wildly overpriced six-year, $106 million contract. But his absence will be no less traumatic to Mets fans than Seaver...

Reyes Leaves Mets for Marlins' $106M Deal

Jose Reyes is taking his talents to South Beach. The superstar shortstop, who finally shook off chronic injuries and won a batting title with the Mets last season, has reportedly signed a six-year, $106 million contract with the Miami Marlins. The deal includes an option that could bring the package to $120 million, according to The Associated Press. The Marlins, who have dropped...

GM pushes idea he can do more with Reyes’ money

DALLAS — Now comes the business of the Mets trying to field a competitive team without Jose Reyes. As Mets fans howled yesterday — many vowing to begin an un-Occupy Citi Field movement to show their displeasure over losing Reyes to the Marlins — questions swirled over the direction of the franchise. “The...

Future in the Past

And with that one tweet, it hits you. The thing that we've been preparing for during the better part of a year is finally here. Jose Reyes has left the New York Mets.He's on his way to the Miami Marlins, a franchise he once fought tooth and nail against (literally) on a six-year $106 million deal. It was a deal that the Mets had no interest in topping, matching, or even...

First Big Free Agent Splash

There was no “decision” on ESPN. Mets fans aren’t burning jerseys in the streets. None of the billboards in Time Square are being ripped down. In fact, the news came quietly on a night when most sports fans were glued to the NFL or their Fantasy Football teams. But another star is coming to Miami. No offense to Joe Nathan or Heath Bell, but Jose Reyes was the first big name...

Catch of the Day: Marlins finalize deal with Reyes

While the Miami Marlins wait on Albert Pujols to make up his mind, they introduced another piece of their offseason puzzle on Wednesday by announcing a six-year deal with shortstop Jose Reyes.

Once again, Amazin’s lose homegrown standout

DALLAS — The beginning of the end for Jose Reyes’ Mets career began in 2009 with an idea and was really sealed when Marlins owner Jeffrey Loria flashed him on the Upper East Side. When Marlins officials realized in 2009 that their long quest to build a stadium would be reached...

Mets moves not sexy, but make sense

DALLAS — None of this replaces Jose Reyes, especially when it comes to filling seats. No one ever bought a ticket to specifically watch Jon Rauch pitch. But the Mets made a series of incremental moves yesterday designed to — at the least — bring competence and competitiveness to their 2012 team while...

Mets Start to Move On From Reyes, Linked to Dirks and Qualls

Joel Sherman is bringing the noise today with some interesting Mets rumors… #bbpBox_143817143706845185 a { text-decoration:none; color:#0084B4; }#bbpBox_143817143706845185 a:hover { text-decoration:underline; }Chad Qualls is among many free-agent relievers #Mets have inquired about.about 2 hours ago via Twitter for iPadReplyRetweetFavorite@Joelsherman1Joel Sherman   And if that...

Things Sandy Alderson Says

I just read the complete transcript of Sandy Alderson’s press conference last night courtesy of ESPN New York. I feel like I’ve been sandbagged. Although I have a problem with a lot of things he said last night, my biggest issues were with these two items… What would be the message to Mets fans about 2012 if they watch what the Marlins are doing, what the Nationals are projected...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.