Found March 10, 2013 on Waiting For Next Year:
A few weeks ago when Jon wrote this article, talking about expectations for the Tribe in 2013 and how they may be a little too high, I immediately conveyed how I thought that article rained on my potential parade of writing about how this team with its flurry of additions in the offseason should be above .500. That led to the conversation that sparked this Jacob piece about our discussion on the Tribe’s amazingly bad starting rotation in 2012. I still want to go through my exercise, using one metric, Jon’s newly fashioned “jWAR” to see how many wins it could potentially get the Tribe to in 2013. Now, before we begin, I realize that this is just ONE metric, a metric that is not without its flaws, but in the new stats revolution, WAR is certainly something that has garnered its fair share of respect. So, take this article as more of a fun piece and not a hard and fast prediction that the Tribe is going to the playoffs or anything like crazy like that. My first reaction when I heard that the over/under for the 2013 Indians’ win total had been set at 77.5 was “huh!?”. The team won 68 games last year while walking through a zombie-like second half where they had tuned their manager out. They had a rotating pile of crap in the bottom three spots of the rotation and in left field. Travis Hafner played just 66 games, while Lonnie Chisenhall played 43 games. They had no offense from the first base or DH spots either. Their young core was hitting the wall it seemed. You had bottom four lineups with the names of Duncan, Marson, Lillibridge, and Carrera (not to mention Cunningham, Damon, Rottino, Canzler, etc.). Adding Nick Swisher, Mark Reynolds, Drew Stubbs, Michael Bourn, and Mike Aviles to an offense that was essentially dropping only Shin-Soo Choo (and yeah, Travis Hafner, I guess)? That had to be worth more than the predicted 9 win jump right there alone! That’s when I got into the starting pitching argument. Jacob already covered the numbers, but they’re worth noting again. # Team ERA- FIP- ERA FIP Year 20 Orioles 118 107 5.4 4.89 2006 19 Mariners 118 108 5.16 4.65 2007 18 Rangers 118 114 5.5 5.25 2007 17 Orioles 118 118 5.37 5.33 2009 16 Indians 120 109 5.3 4.75 2009 15 Red Sox 121 108 5.19 4.69 2012 14 Mariners 121 115 5.07 4.77 2008 13 Royals 122 110 5.01 4.59 2012 12 Devil Rays 122 121 5.45 5.38 2003 11 Rangers 123 112 5.51 5.02 2008 10 Orioles 124 121 5.51 5.38 2008 9 Royals 126 108 5.25 4.52 2010 8 Orioles 129 118 5.39 4.91 2011 7 Royals 129 122 5.85 5.5 2006 6 Rangers 130 114 6.24 5.41 2003 5 Tigers 130 118 5.71 5.12 2003 4 Devil Rays 131 115 5.62 4.91 2005 3 Indians 133 118 5.25 4.73 2012 2 Twins 133 122 5.4 5.02 2012 1 Royals 135 114 6 5.07 2005   Second worst ERA- this decade! Before I knew that exact figure, I said this in our discussion. “But you see what I’m saying in regards to that rotation being way out on the edge of bad, right? Ubaldo and Masterson had career worst years, Lowe was gone by June, Gomez got torched, Tomlin and Carrasco were hurt, and no one else stepped up. Our bully only got better and deeper and we added Myers. I hope they won’t ride with Ubaldo all year at a 5.00+ ERA clip if he sucks. I think Bauer makes an impact in the second half, and if Zac Mac can even come close to last year, he’s good enough for an end of rotation starter for us. That’s ALL I was trying to say the other day. I’d set the over/under at somewhere around 81. That team had so many ugly things happen last year and still won 68 games. Just a 9 game improvement to me means there were two or three SIGNIFICANT injuries for extended time and a trade of some sorts.” So, to use 2012 as a stepping stone and a barometer of sorts, I grabbed the jWAR of every player who had significant playing time with the Indians last season (Vinnie Rottino was my cutoff point on the hitters with 18 games played, Dan Wheeler my pitching cutoff with 12 innings pitched). This gave me 20 hitters and 22 pitchers contributing to my jWAR figures. The results are below. Hitter 2012 jWAR Pitcher 2012 jWAR Santana 3.6 Pestano 1.6 Kipnis 3.4 Masterson 1.2 Cabrera 3.0 Smith 0.8 Choo 2.9 Rogers 0.7 Brantley 2.8 C. Perez 0.7 Hafner 0.7 Lowe 0.5 Hannahan 0.4 McAllister 0.4 Carrera 0.4 Herrmann 0.3 Marson 0.3 Allen 0.3 Chisenhall 0.1 Seddon 0.3 Damon 0.0 Accardo 0.1 Canzler -0.1 Barnes 0.1 Rottino -0.1 Huff 0.1 Lopez -0.2 Kluber 0.0 LaPorta -0.3 Sipp -0.2 Duncan -0.4 Asencio -0.2 Donald -0.4 Hagadone -0.3 Cunningham -0.5 Wheeler -0.4 Lillibridge -0.8 “Carmona” -0.5 Kotchman -1.3 Jimenez -0.5 Tomlin -0.6 Gomez -0.8 Total 13.5 3.6   So, by jWAR figures, the Indians were about 17 wins above replacement. Baseball Reference defines replacement as about 52-110. That falls right in with how the Tribe actually performed (one more win roughly at 69). The only thing I really left out of the calculation here was pitchers’ offensive WARs, which were essentially a wash. Let’s plug in the new roster additions alone and see what they add to the equation. For the purpose of this argument, I’ve assumed an Opening Day bench of Marson, Aviles, Raburn, and Giambi, Kazmir winning the fifth spot in the rotation, and a bullpen of Perez, Pestano, Smith, Albers, Shaw, Hagadone, and Allen (surely, Matt Capps or others could wind up here). I’ve also made some adjustments to the WARs used where reasonable. First, I used Myers’ WAR from 2011, his last season as a starter (not a stellar inflated value, mind you). Then, I used Kazmir’s ’09 value, because it was his last fully effective season as a starter (argument being that if he pitches as bad as he did in 2010, they’ll go to Bauer, Carrasco, Huff, or someone else). Finally, I added 2011 values for both Raburn and Giambi, because they won’t be on the roster if they don’t contribute at at least those levels. They’ll be replaced by Ezequiel Carrera, Chris McGuiness, or someone else who should hopefully at least provide replacement value. Hitter 2013 jWAR Pitcher 2013 jWAR Bourn 6.2 Kazmir (’09) 1.3 Swisher 3.7 Myers (’11) 0.8 Aviles 1.9 Albers 0.5 Stubbs 0.6 Shaw 0.4 Reynolds 0.2 Giambi (’11) 1.2 Raburn (’11) 0.6 Total 14.4 3.0   17 extra wins? Fantastic! But, wait, there’s the matter of subtracting our, ahem, subtractions from last year’s roster before we go about saying the team will win 87 games (52 replacement + 17.7 above replacement last year + 17.4 extra wins from new additions). Below, I roughly showed the 2012 players that our 2013 additions are replacing. I combined two players when they essentially added up to one season’s amount of ABs/IP. Hitter 2012 jWAR Pitcher 2012 jWAR Choo 2.9 Rogers 0.7 Hafner 0.7 Sipp -0.2 Hannahan 0.4 Gomez/Lowe -0.3 Duncan/Carrera 0.0 Tomlin/Kluber -0.6 Cunningham/Damon -0.5 Lopez/Lillibridge -1.0 Kotchman -1.3 Total 1.2 -0.4   Geez, so despite losing Choo, the rest of the roster wasteland that we replaced with real major league players nearly cancels out his win share value. So, like I had mentioned above, that gets the Tribe to about 86 wins. I swear I didn’t do the math when I made that statement in Jacob’s discussion article. Now, there are some things I haven’t accounted for. First, as FanGraphs points out in their explaination of win values, “First off, wins aren’t entirely linear. A player who is projected as a +2 win player won’t have the exact same impact on a 60 win roster that he would on a 95 win roster. There’s diminishing returns that start kicking in, and there are only so many at-bats and high leverage innings to go around.” So that’s something to keep in mind with the returning players who will hopefully be playing on a better than 68-win team. There’s also the injury issue, because there will undoubtedly be some that affect these predictions. I truly believe, however, that our starting pitching and bullpen depth is better than it was last year, so there shouldn’t be as great of a dropoff in production. Some might argue I’m cherry-picking a bit here, but you know what I left alone? Last year’s contributions from returning Indians. Can Kipnis, Santana, Brantley, or Chisenhall get better? Well, I certainly hope so. Even more important than that, I still have Justin Masterson and Ubaldo Jimenez penciled in with 1.2 and -0.5 WARs respectively. Masterson posted his highest career ERA (4.93), ERA+ (79, meaning he was 21% worse than the league average ERA) most walks (88), most HR (18), most HBP (13), most wild pitches (14), a K/BB rate at a 3-year low since becoming a Tribe starter (1.81). If Masterson can pitch anywhere close to his 2011 numbers (3.21 ERA, 122 ERA+, 64 walks, 11 HR allowed, 5 wild pitches, and a K/BB rate of 2.43), then the WAR will be much closer to his 2011 figure of 3.6 instead of 1.2. Ahh, Ubaldo. Ubaldo’s quite a different case. For one, I don’t believe in Ubaldo… at all. I’d love to be wrong and see him last the entire year in the rotation, but with better options on the horizon (Bauer and Carrasco, for instance), if Jimenez doesn’t pitch well a month or two in, the Indians should eject him from the rotation if they want to compete. Last season, Ubaldo had plenty of career worsts too, including ERA (5.40), ERA+ (72), wild pitches (16), homers (25), WHIP (1.61), BB/9 (4.8), K/9 (7.3), and K/BB (1.51). The strikeout and walk numbers were not even close to his past years or any reasonable level of respectability. If he pitches that bad again, he shouldn’t make it to May. I’m not even going to speculate on what good for Ubaldo can be anymore but I will point out that from 2008-2010, his WARs were 3.6, 5.3, and 7.3 respectively. Could Ubaldo be even a 2 WAR player? That could be good enough to stick around and keep the Tribe competitive. So, I guess that’s all I have to say about jWAR and the Indians. I’m putting the win prediction according to WAR at right around 86. I expect our starting rotation to do better than I mathematically figured. Plus, I figure the diminishing returns from more talent on a winning team and only so many high leverage situations will balance that out. 86 wins? That puts us within spitting distance of the Tigers. If they have a key injury, anything is possible. Now, if the young core of Kipnis, Santana, Chisenhall, and Brantley take the next step or Masterson or Ubaldo return to number one starter form? It could be a really fun year. (Photo: Chuck Crow/The Plain Dealer)
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

2013 Indians Top 60 Prospects: #7 RHP Cody Allen

The IBI's 2013 Indians Top 60 Prospect countdown continues on with right-handed pitcher Cody Allen. Allen is the most dominant and eye-popping relief pitcher the Indians have had come through their system in a long time as he breezed through four different stops last season hitting every level from High-A Carolina to Cleveland within three months. His rapid ascent up the system...

2013 Indians Top 60 Prospects: #6 SS Ronny Rodriguez

The IBI's 2013 Indians Top 60 Prospect countdown continues on with shortstop Ronny Rodriguez. Rodriguez has been one of the bright spots that has come out of Latin America the last few years as he has become one of the most athletic and exciting players in the Indians’ system. He still has a ways to go with the bat, but there is a lot of potential with his arm and bat, and...

Spring Training: Reynolds Sidelined With Back Soreness, Perez Throwing

Earlier today, it was announced that Indians corner infielder/DH Mark Reynolds will miss a few days with back soreness. Mark Reynolds sidelined with sore back. Probably won’t play until later this week. He last played March 6. #Indians. — paul hoynes (@hoynsie) March 10, 2013 Reynolds tried to downplay the issue, saying its customary Spring Training stiffness. Reynolds said...

Indians add Rich Hill to 40-man roster, release Ben Francisco

The Cleveland Indians today announced the following roster moves relative to the Major League spring training roster: - Selected the contract of left-handed pitcher Rich Hill from the Triple-A Columbus Clippers, adding him to the 40-man roster. - Placed right-handed pitcher Blake Wood (right elbow rehab) on the 60-day Disabled List. - Optioned outfielder Tim Federoff, right-handed...

Scott Kazmir continues to dominate as a Cleveland Indian

Continuing to dominate on the hill, Cleveland Indians reclamation project Scott Kazmir threw four shutout frames against the Los Angeles Angels in a Cactus League game on Monday. The 29-year-old Kazmir, a two-time All-Star selection who signed a minor league contract with Cleveland in December, has whiffed 13 batters and is yet to allow a run in 11 innings this spring between Cactus...

Tribe Happenings: Indians are over halfway home this spring

Some news, notes, and thoughts from my Indians notebook… Over halfway home… So far things have gone about as well as they could go in camp for the Indians. Spring training is not about winning games and getting all too caught up in the numbers players put up.  It is about getting your pitchers ready and surviving the seven week camp without any major injuries.   Ask the Yankees...

McAllister Clinches, Kazmir vs. Dice-K, The Race For Bench & The Harlem Shake

As each day goes by, we get closer and closer to Opening day. The Indians open their season in Toronto three weeks from tomorrow. There are still open spots in the bullpen, on the bench, and that pesky fifth starter job. Each week in Spring brings a new hot name and a new guy struggling. This past weekend saw the start of the World Baseball Classic and a couple of names moving closer...

2013 Indians Spring Training Game #18: Rangers 7, Indians 6

There's really no good segue into today's recap for the  Tribe's lineup, so I'll just lead off with it: LINEUP Brantley - DH (McGuiness)Stubbs - RF (Hermida)Gomes - C (Jeroloman)Phelps - 2B-3B (Antonelli - 3B)Francisco - LF (Fedroff)Raburn - 3B (Wolters - 2B)Carrera - CF (Rodriguez - SS)McDade - 1B (played whole game)Hernandez - SS (Hunter - CF) PITCHERS Myers -...

2013 Spring Training Game #18: Rangers 7, Indians 6

There's really no good segue into today's recap for the  Tribe's lineup, so I'll just lead off with it: LINEUP Brantley - DH (McGuiness)Stubbs - RF (Hermida)Gomes - C (Jeroloman)Phelps - 2B-3B (Antonelli - 3B)Francisco - LF (Fedroff)Raburn - 3B (Wolters - 2B)Carrera - CF (Rodriguez - SS)McDade - 1B (played whole game)Hernandez - SS (Hunter - CF) PITCHERS Myers -...

Yankees sign OF Ben Francisco

Ben Francisco will compete for an OF spot. (Photo credit: Cleveland.com) The list of guys  competing for the vacant outfield spot left by Curtis Granderson just got longer, as Joel Sherman of the New York Post reports that the Yanks have signed Ben Francisco to a minor league contract. Francisco, 31, signed a minor league deal with the Cleveland Indians in January before getting...

Aviles, Puerto Rico beat Venezuela in WBC

Mike Aviles drove in three runs and Puerto Rico beat Venezuela 6-3 Saturday night to advance to the second round of the World Baseball Classic. Puerto Rico (2-0) eliminated the Venezuelans (0-2), who began the tournament as a top contender with stars such as Miguel Cabrera, Pablo Sandoval and Carlos Gonzalez. This result determined the two winners of Group C for the next phase...

Indians 9, Cubs 2

Jason Kipnis hit his first home run of the spring and Cedric Hunter also connected, leading the Cleveland Indians over the Chicago Cubs 9-2 Saturday. Kipnis came into the game hitting .227 with two RBIs. He led off the fourth with a home run against reliever Brooks Raley. Hunter had three hits, including a three-run shot. Indians starter David Huff went three innings in a bid...

Angels 0, Indians 0

Daisuke Matsuzaka left his outing Monday because of a cramp in his right calf, overshadowing a fine performance by Scott Kazmir as the Cleveland Indians played to a 0-0 tie with Jered Weaver and the Los Angeles Angels. Attempting a comeback after having elbow-reconstruction surgery in 2011 and a disastrous final season with Boston, the 32-year-old Matsuzaka allowed one hit in one...

Scott Kazmir Strikes Out Josh Hamilton

Previously, it was Oliver Perez. Earlier in his career, Oliver Perez was a good major-league pitcher. Then he was a worse major-league pitcher, then he was a bad major-league pitcher, then he was nothing, thought to be hopeless. Perez resurfaced in winter ball, allegedly reaching his old velocity levels as a reliever. The Mariners gave him a chance, and he worked his way into a big...

WBC Results & Preview 3/9

The team with the most Indian presence, Puerto Rico, opened up action on Friday against Spain with Mike Aviles starting at shortstop.In the first inning, Aviles knocked in team Puerto Rico's second run with a sacrifice fly that scored Alex Rios. He also later walked and stole a base in the game that Puerto Rico won 3-0. Although their were no Indians involved, a few other...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.