Found April 19, 2012 on

New York Yankees GM Brian Cashman may be the most overrated person at his position in all of Major League Baseball. While he has helped the Yankees win World Series championships, he is more or less a figurehead with an open checkbook.

Simply being able to offer players more money than your competitors does not make you a top flight general manager. Promoting the right players from the minor leagues, holding on to top prospects while acquiring other team’s best players and signing the right – not most expensive – players makes you good at your job.

To some degree, it can be argued that Cashman excels at none of those things.

The greatest example of Cashman being in far over his head at his post is his unwillingness to admit that he has no idea what constitutes a good starting pitcher. He has refused to trade pitching prospects who he himself have labeled as “can’t miss.”

Ah, the dreaded term “can’t miss” prospect. Especially when it comes to the Yankees’ organization. We have come to find out that term has absolutely no meaning or truth behind the phrase.

Cashman could have traded Joba Chamberlain, Phil Hughes and countless others for top flight players at other positions, but he refused to part with them. Oh, that is, except for Ian Kennedy. As nice as it has been to acquire Curtis Granderson, Cashman could have included Hughes or Chamberlain instead of Kennedy, who put up numbers of Cy Young status last season with the Arizona Diamondbacks.

And it isn’t just about prospects. I will admit that A.J. Burnett was not getting the job done. But trading him for next to nothing while still paying the majority of his salary proves stupid.

Or how about re-signing Freddy Garcia instead of Bartolo Colon? That worked out well. Garcia got rocked in both of his two starts, posting an ERA just around 7 so far. Colon, on the other hand, has thrown gems in three of his four starts, putting up a 3-1 record with an ERA of 2.63.

Andy Pettitte can not come back soon enough for the Yankees. Or Michael Pineda…

If that trade works out for Cashman. If not, it is time to move forward.

And on to a new general manager.


Kelley writes for The Pigskin Report as well as Hardball Chat. You can follow him on Twitter @RobKelley24 and Like The Rob Kelley Sports Network on Facebook. Kelley is a former sports reporter for various newspapers throughout the state of Florida, and had his first book published I'm Not a Quitter after moving back to Massachusetts.



Yankees Game 13 Lineup: 04/19/12

<a href="" rel=\"attachment wp-att-4601\">Right-hander Phil Hughes will be taking the ball for the Yankees tonight in their series finale against the Minnesota...

Yankees Throwback Uniforms: Studs or Duds?

<a href="" rel=\"attachment wp-att-4634\">Credit: NY Daily News Throwback uniforms are a staple today in sports...

Yankees CF Granderson homers in first 3 at-bats

New York Yankees center fielder Curtis Granderson homered in his first three at-bats in Thursday's game against the Minnesota Twins. Granderson clubbed a solo homer in the first inning, a two-run shot in the second and another solo blast in the fourth to give New York a 7-4 lead. He singled in the sixth inning in his bid for his fourth consecutive home run. It was the first...

Alex Rodriguez passes Ken Griffey Jr. on home run list

New York Yankees star Alex Rodriguez moved into fifth-place on the all time home runs list on Friday with a Deep blast during the Yankees-Red Sox game at Fenway Park.  Rodriguez passed former teammate and mentor Ken Griffey Jr. with a solo home run in the fifth inning off Red Sox pitcher Clay Bucholz.  This is his second home run of the season and number 631 for his career...

Why the Yankees were supposed to lose to Twins

Carl Pavano (Photo credit: Wikipedia) As I was throwing out papers today, I came across the reasons the Yankees were doomed to lose the first game of their series against the Twins. The notes were a mess; as I had written them late on Sunday night but my reasoning actually turned out to be pretty accurate so I thought why not pass it along. So, here it is just a day and a dollar...

Fantasy Baseball Daily Picks: Curtis Granderson, Cole Hamels, Adam Jones, Matt Moore, and more

Have a day Curtis Granderson! The Yankees outfielder turned in the first truly spectacular individual fantasy day of the 2012 season by going 5-5 with three home runs on Thursday night. He drove in four runs. Curtis Granderson had one hell of a day yesterday, but should you start him on Friday? Jerod has the answer. (Photo by Keith Allison via Wikimedia Commons) The best part? I...

Yanks To Wear Throwback Uniform For Opener on Friday

If you did not know--I was out all day yesterday and did not know either--the Yankees and Red Sox will be wearing 1912 throwback uniforms on Friday to commemorate the 100th anniversary of Fenway Park. The Red Sox have worn these throwbacks before (below), but this will be a first for the Yankees. It'll be odd seeing the Yanks in something other than the usual road greys...

Hiroki Kuroda's 5.00 ERA bought him a $20K per month NYC apartment

NY Yankees pitcher Hiroki Kuroda. He of the 5.00 ERA and $10 million dollar contract...just signed a one year lease to rent a Midtown penthouse on West 52nd Street for $19,750 a month. The apartment... Full story at Bob's Blitz ~

Ladies At The Bat: Friday Links

This is the beginning of a new weekly series where I post links to the latest posts written by women in the baseball blogosphere.  Here's the first installment: At Lady Loves Pinstripes Kate references a popular Tom Hanks movie to describe her disdain for Yankees starter Phil Hughes.Jane Heller is more optimistic about Hughes and feels even better about Curtis Granderson...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.