PLAYERS: Donovan McNabb, Ben Roethlisberger, Drew Brees, Philip Rivers, Jay Cutler, Carson Palmer, Eli Manning, Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Kurt Warner
-
1Tom Brady
Now some might argue that Peyton Manning belongs here. Now here is why I disagree, Brady does not have the stats and records but he has done it where it counts. And when it is all said and done you don't remember the records, you remember the moments.
-
2Peyton Manning
He has the stats, the recrods and the ring. And he will continue to add onto his stats and earn more records and probably another ring or so before he calls it quits.
-
3Ben Roethlisberger
You know Big Ben isn't going to wow you with stats or break the season Touchdown record anytime soon. But what he will do is win when it counts and he has continued to do that over his short career. He has won two Vince Lombardi trophies in only five seasons.
-
4Donovan McNabb
Say what you will about Donovan McNabb but no active Quarterback has done more with less. Every season he is healthy he gets the Eagles to the NFC Championship. I have no doubt in my mind that now that he has a real group of receivers he will no doubt win a Super Bowl Trophy. Once he does that he will move up to third place.
-
5Drew Brees
Drew did amazing things last year with one of the worst statistical defenses in the league. He kept his team in most games when the defense gave up so many points. But he has been doing that since his days in San Diego. His only problem is he doesn't seem to perform in the playoffs.
-
6Kurt Warner
Warner did great things last year proving he still has it. I think he will fall from this list as early has next year. But for now he is number six.
-
7Eli Manning
Say what you want and it is hard for me to do this, but he does win in big games. I believe if it weren't for Plaxico he wouldn't be as good and we will soon see if that is true. I do know that if it weren't for his defense that one year he would not be a Super Bowl winning QB. But no matter the excuses he still has that ring!
-
8Philip Rivers
Rivers has had a successful young career. Right now it is all up from here for Rivers.
-
9Jay Cutler
I actually believe that Cutler is better than Rivers. But he hasn't really proven it yet. Pretty much because Rivers has won in the Playoffs and Cutler has not.
-
10Carson Palmer
That's right Palmer lovers! Listen I don't know what the big deal is with this guy. He really hasn't had many successful seasons. During his career the Bengals have only made one trip to the playoffs and after that season he did diddly-squat.
-
TopicRepliesLast Activity
-
THE GAMEPLAN: WORK THE BODY
Birdflipper started this Philadelphia Eagles thread33 minutes ago -
Jerry Rice remains in the corner of his pupil DeSean Jackson
DMcnabb4MVP started this Philadelphia Eagles thread67 minutes ago -
Murder at the Linc!
NPhillyBirdman started this Philadelphia Eagles thread22531 minutes ago -
EAGLES/COWBOYS PREDICTION
khollen started this Philadelphia Eagles thread3533 minutes ago -
Fifty Years Of Patriots Football: 1995-1999 | Boston Sports Then and Now
joemgill88 started this New England Patriots thread051 minutes ago
- NFL
-
Robert Griffith
"Tune In Tomorrow Night!!!!"
posted 1 day agoWhat’s up Yardbarkers? Hope you all had a safe Halloween! I’m headed out to Vegas...
See more | 1 comment
- NFL
- Chris Cooley posted 3 days ago
- NFL
- Chris Horton posted 9 days ago
- NFL
- George Wrighster posted 10 days ago
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers
Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?
Join the Yardbarker Network (YBN) for more promotion, traffic, and money.


















StewartBradley said May 27, 2009
DMcnabb4MVP replied May 27, 2009