Found January 04, 2013 on Waiting For Next Year:
While Joe Banner and Jimmy Haslam conduct interviews in Arizona for a new head coach, the one person I’ve been interested to hear from or about is defensive coordinator Dick Jaruon. On Monday, Banner and Haslam made it clear that all coaches were free to interview elsewhere if they wished and that they could be brought back if the new coach wanted them. What we really don’t know is if Jauron wants to come back to the Browns without Shurmur and Holmgren here. We reached out through the Browns, but have received no statement or answer. (Not surprisingly.) I hope that Jauron wants to finish what he has started here in Cleveland and will be welcomed by the new head coach, whoever that happens to be. I would put the odds of that happening at fifty-fifty or less unfortunately. If there is a change of defensive coordinators, we could be staring at another transition between the 4-3 and 3-4 defense. As Browns fans will remember, that transition is sometimes a slow painful one. The primary difference in the two defenses are the responsibilities of the defensive line and outside linebackers. In a 4 man defensive line, the linemen are generally responsible for just one gap in run protection, and the defensive ends typically are the primary pass rushers on the team. In a three man defensive line, each lineman is responsible for 2 gaps of run protection, and the outside linebackers are usually the best pass rushers on the team, with some exceptions obviously. Defensive ends in a 3 man front tend to be built more like defensive tackles. They need the ability to occasionally beat an offensive tackle to put pressure on a QB, but they have to have size enough not to get pushed off the ball by a double team. My fear about switching back to a 3-4 defense is obviously that we don’t have the personnel. And it might not be as simple a fix as adding a LB or two. So let’s take a look at what we have, and how they might fit into a 3-4 system. Defensive Linemen under contract for next season: Kendrick Adams (Practice squad) 6-5/250/24 Hall Davis 6-4/270/25 Auston English (IR) 6-3/250/25 John Hughes 6-2/320/24 Ishmaa’ily Kitchen 6-1/330/24 Ahtyba Rubin 6-2/330/26 Frostee Rucker 6-3/280/29 Brian Sanford (IR) 6-2/280/25 Jabaal Sheard 6-2/255/23 Emmanuel Stephens (IR) 6-3/255/25 Phil Taylor 6-3/335/24 Billy Winn 6-4/295/23 (Parker FA) 6-2/250/34 If you were to pick a strength of the Browns’ defensive, I think we would all agree it rests on the defensive line. John Hughes and Billy Winn provide depth to a strong group including Rubin, Taylor and Sheard. If you project this group into a 3-4 line, I think there are reasons for optimism. I think Hughes, Winn, Rubin and even Frostee Rucker could play the defensive end in a 3-4. The defensive tackle or nose tackle spot could be played effectively by Taylor, Rubin, Kitchen or Hughes. Here’s where I get nervous. I don’t think Jabaal Sheard fits as an NFL DE in a 3 man line. Sheard is generally a speed rusher, and has his worst games against the bigger, stronger offensive tackles in the league. He also is neutralized by a double team block. The question in my mind would be if he could make the transition to an outside LB. It isn’t an easy transition, and I’m not sure he is athletic enough to do all that is required of an OLB. Linebackers under contract for next season: Emmanuel Acho (IR) 6-1/240/22 Tank Carder 6-2/235/23 L.J. Fort 6-0/230/23 Chris Gocong (IR) 6-2/263/29 D’Qwell Jackson 6-0/240/29 James-Michael Johnson (IR) 6-1/240/23 Adrian Moten 6-2/230/24 Craig Robertson 6-1/229/24 (Fujita FA) 6-5/250/33 (Maiva FA) 6-0/229/26 This is where the Browns would need an overhaul. The LB roster is full of guys that would make better inside linebackers than outside ones in a 3-4. Obviously D’Qwell Jackson would get one of those spots. The competition for the other would be pretty tight. The guy with the best build for an OLB would be Fujita technically, but even if he can come back from his injury, I wouldn’t bring him back strictly based on his age and speed. Gocong might be the best candidate for an OLB spot, but you have to be concerned about his injury history effecting his athleticism. I took a look at three current teams with successful 3-4 defenses. Here are the measurables for their starting 3 lineman and 4 linebackers- Average DL on Steelers- 6-3/303, on Texans 6-4/295, on 49ers 6-3 301. Average for the group 6-3/300. Average ILB on Steelers- 6-1/236, on Texans 6-1/238, on 49ers 6-1/241. Average for the group 6-1/238. Average OLB on Steelers- 6-1 253, on Texans 6-4/262, on 49ers 6-3/258. Average for the group 6-3/258. I understand that every player doesn’t always fit nicely into categories. Sometimes a guy who is undersized by a position standard is just as effective and more so. Here’s my concerns about possibly making this transition again. First, the best pass rusher the Browns have is Jabaal Sheard, and I’m not certain he fits into the 3-4 at the pro level. What would you do with him? Do you play him out of position and perhaps nullify his effectiveness? Do you try and trade him? Next, the Browns would have to add at least two OLBs. Starters. If the Browns didn’t make a change, they would have to look hard at improving the secondary this off-season. That would still be true. They would need to draft/sign a CB and a safety at least. Most see a need for another pass rusher without a switch in defensive schemes. With a switch? Try looking for 2 or 3 minimum. That would be a lot of personnel to acquire. And that’s just on the defensive side of the ball. Never mind what a system like say Chip Kelly’s would mean to the offensive needs. The bottom line is that the Browns need playmakers on defense no matter which system is in place. The biggest reason Pittsburgh, Texas and San Francisco have effective 3-4′s is because they have studs somewhere in those front sevens. The Browns’ defensive line could handle a move to the 3-4, but one of its biggest playmakers might be nullified. In all likelihood, it would take at least 2 off seasons to obtain the players they need to effective make a transition.
1 Comment:
  • And, change could mean they stay with the 4-3. Jeez!
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

NFL Report: Colt McCoy might be in Browns’ future plans

Again, amid all of the coaching rumors, the Browns have been abuzz on Twitter for other topics too in the last 48 hours. This one was big last night, as ESPN Cleveland reporter Will Burge shared some insight on Colt McCoy’s potential future with the organization: Source in #Browns organization told me that just over a week ago Colt McCoy was told by Joe Banner he is “in the next...

NFL Report: Lombardi already scouting free agents for Browns

While Browns fans remain fixated on the team’s coaching search (which will occur before a GM search), Adam Caplan dropped a bit of a bombshell on Twitter this afternoon. How much work has Lombardi been doing behind the scenes? Source said he has been working on free agency targets for the Browns. — Adam Caplan (@caplannfl) January 4, 2013 Caplan’s tweet said that Mike Lombardi...

NFL Rumor: Bruce Arians wanted Browns coaching job “badly”

Per WEWS’ Mike Cairns, we have word that former Cleveland Browns offensive coordinator Bruce Arians wanted to return home but was not granted an interview. I am told that Bruce Arians wanted #Browns job very badly but was never granted an interview. — Mike Cairns (@MikeCairns5) January 5, 2013 Arians, the current offensive coordinator of the Indianapolis Colts, was one of the...
ORE-GONE

Report: Chip Kelly to the Browns

The hottest name on the NFL coaching landscape has reportedly made his decision and for once it looks like Browns fans have something to be happy about. 

Browns Waiting Their Turn To Get To Kelly, Haslam & Banner In The Desert Can They Land The Head Duck?

With the Cleveland Browns ownership sitting in the Arizona desert comes the speculation of who will be the next head coach of the Cleveland Browns. Tonight is the big game for Chip Kelly’s Oregon Ducks and tomorrow could be his chance to lead the Cleveland Browns into the future is Haslam and Banner can make the right offer. Some say the team is willing to pay 10 million dollars...

Cleveland Browns 2013 Needs

The Browns have played in just 1 playoff game since 1994 (they were deactivated for 3 years in that stretch, but still). Lack of continuity continues to be an issue for them and it won’t get any better for them next season. They have a new owner who has brought in a new GM and front office, which will bring in a new Head Coach once again. That Head Coach is expected to be Chip...

Browns reportedly met with Chip Kelly Friday afternoon

According to Mary Kay Cabot of the Cleveland Plain-Dealer, the Browns were set to meet with Oregon head coach Chip Kelly this afternoon.#Browns set to meet w/ #Oregon‘s Chip Kelly a little later this afternoon.— Mary Kay Cabot (@MaryKayCabot) January 4, 2013It will be interesting if the Browns let Kelly leave without a deal.  There’s a report out that they’re willing to...

Colt McCoy Has Been Told He’s in Chip Kelly’s Plans if He is Hired

Chip Kelly hasn’t been hired by anyone yet, so this might not mean anything. Even before this report came out, I believed if Chip Kelly was hired by the Browns and he had to choose between McCoy and Weeden, he would choose McCoy. I think McCoy fits better within the scheme he would try to use. It would be different if Weeden was substantially better than McCoy, but I don’t think...

Browns to meet with Chip Kelly tonight

The Cleveland Browns will be meeting with Chip Kelly on Saturday night in hopes of signing him to a contract that will make him their next head coach, per the Cleveland Plain-Dealer.“Be ready for something to happen today,” a league source told The Plain Dealer today.The Browns will have lawyers with them at their meeting tonight, according to Ian Rappaport of NFL.com. Kelly’s...

NFL Report: Browns also interested in Chiefs’ Ray Farmer

Add one more to the list: ESPN’s Adam Schefter reports that the Browns also have requested permission to interview Ray Farmer, currently the Director of Pro Personnel for the Kansas City Chiefs: Browns have requested permission to interview SF’s Tom Gamble and Kansas City’s Ray Farmer for their GM job. — Adam Schefter (@AdamSchefter) January 5, 2013 A two-time All-ACC saftey...

Report: Cleveland Browns met with Bill O’Brien

According to beatwriter Mary Kay Cabot, a source has informed the Plain Dealer that the #Browns have made the move on Penn State’s coach Brian O’Brien.Breaking: The #Browns interviewed Penn State coach Bill O’Brien this week, a source told the Plain Dealer today.— Mary Kay Cabot (@MaryKayCabot) January 3, 2013His interview was not exposed to the media because well, they...

NFL Report: Browns ask permission to interview Vikings’ George Paton

With Chip Kelly news at a standstill for the moment, you can add another name to the GM search for the Browns, according to Jay Glazer on Twitter earlier this afternoon: Panthers and Browns have requested permission to interview Vikings asst GM George Paton for GM. He’s scheduled to meet w Panthers next week — Jay Glazer (@JayGlazer) January 5, 2013 George Paton (note: just...

Browns’ exhaustive coaching search is refreshing

It came out this morning that the Browns’ brass interviewed former Arizona Cardinals coach (and former Pittsburgh coordinator) Ken Whisenhunt. This, on the heels of their interview with Ray Horton and news of their forthcoming interview with Chip Kelly. Those are just the names of candidates that we know of since Joe Banner and Jimmy Haslam stationed themselves in Arizona around...

Report: Bill O’Brien to stay at Penn State

First came the revelation that the Browns have already interviewed Penn State’s coach Bill O”Brien, and then tonight the word comes that O’Brien has decided at the University- The Browns are among several teams interviewing Chip Kelly tomorrow, including the Eagles and Bills at least. [Related: The Browns exhaustive coaching search is refreshing]
NFL Forum Discussions
2014 Worst Offseason EVER
39 replies, 21 hours ago
He is super producer?
1 replies, 9 days ago
DeSean meeting Coach Kelly
1 replies, 9 days ago
Hello Sanchez! Good bye DeSean!?
1 replies, 9 days ago
Minako Kotobuki Second Live Tour!!
3 replies, 9 days ago
DJ in DC
1 replies, 9 days ago
Allen stay Eagles
3 replies, 9 days ago
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.