Found November 10, 2012 on
The Rhino and Compass:
Even the greatest quarterbacks can’t overcome bad teams, especially not in their rookie year. It’s something that I have always believed and will continue to believe until forever. Look at Peyton Manning, one of the most prolific passers of our time, and a number one overall draft pick. He came into a team that was legitimately terrible in 1998, and the Colts were capable of only 3 wins. Even recent teams that have been resurgent with new, talented quarterbacks, like the Panthers and Cam Newton were only better by a handful of games after Newton took over.
I’m trying to say that the Colts were never a bad team. They were relatively unchanged from 2010-2011, except for the Peyton Manning injury, and they ended up winning 8 fewer games. There was surprisingly little change between 2011-12 either, aside from the tight end position, which was simply replaced, and the quarterback. Andrew Luck is obviously a good quarterback, but I think the change from 2010 to 2011 and 2011 to 2012 has everything to do with how devastatingly awful Curtis Painter is
Andrew Luck has been able to find the same receivers, the defense, mostly unchanged (except for Zbikowski!) is very similar to what it was last year, much to everyone’s surprise, and the team is winning at a pace just off of what they were in 2010. Andrew Luck isn’t so much an example of a QB that made a 2-14 team better, but one that has maintained a 10-6 team.
Luck is having an excellent year thanks to the fact that he has a team around him that is capable of making plays in support. Not every top pick in the league can do that, because most other top picks don’t come to a team as well made as the Colts already were. We just forgot about their talent because Curtis Painter was such an incapable train wreck.
(For fun, Painter’s stats in 2011: 54.3 completion percentage, 6TDs 9 INTs, 171.2 Y/G 22.51 QBR.
Luck’s stats in 2012: 57.5, 10/9 292.3, 77.58
Christian Ponder in 2012: 64.1, 10/8, 200.7, 46.85.
Curtis Painter is devastatingly bad.)
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
After today’s win over the Panthers, Denver Broncos tight end Jacob Tamme tweeted a photo of a Dominos pizza box.
In his tweet Tamme referred to quarerback Peyton Manning not being in charge of ordering the pizza since he owns 21 Papa Johns franchises and is a part of a marketing campaign with them.
Apparently our QB was not in charge of the post game snack. twitter.com/JacobTamme...
Things have changed quickly over the past week. I have just two new entries into the Playoff Picture for Week 10 and it is due largely to the fact that the Dolphins and Eagles failed to take advantage of the promising situations in front of them. With the Eagles, it was more about the team that failed to take advantage of an opportunity. For the Dolphins, it's about having that...
The strong start by the Indianapolis Colts has everyone talking about the possibility of making the playoffs.
Interim coach Bruce Arians is more concerned with protecting No. 1 overall draft pick Andrew Luck.
One day after beating Jacksonville 27-10 to improve to 6-3, Arians talked about everything from two personal foul calls on the Jaguars for hitting Luck in the head or near...
The Jaguars secondary should be scared of the young gun
Indianapolis Colts (5-3) @ Jacksonville Jaguars (1-7) 8:20 p.m.
Not many people would have thought the Colts would be playoff contenders after saying goodbye to Peyton Manning and welcoming rookie Andrew Luck to be the franchise quarterback. But that is right where the Colts are right now, fighting for a playoff spot...
Andrew Luck may not be Robert Griffin III when it comes to running the football, but that hasn’t stopped him from getting out of the pocket like his Washington counterpart.
Luck scored two rushing touchdowns on Thursday night against the Jaguars. But on one particular scramble in the fourth quarter, the Colts quarterback took a major hit hit from Jacksonville safety Dawan Landry...
Tweet Last week Von Miller said he hoped to get a chance to do Cam Newton’s “Superman” celebration when his Broncos met the the Carolina Panthers on Sunday. It didn’t take long for that opportunity to present itself. Miller was a headache for the Panthers all afternoon as he finished with 6 tackles and [...]
Broncos Von Miller made a promise last week that when he sacked Panthers QB Cam Newton he would do Cam’s Superman move in celebration. Somewhere along the way Von abandoned those plans- possibly because he wasn’t credited with the safety- and instead busted out this little move in celebration. I wonder if he had [...]
CHARLOTTE, N.C. -- Denver Broncos coach John Fox had the right idea when he wanted to deflect attention upon returning to Bank of America Stadium to face his former employer. He brought along Peyton Manning and a stifling defense. In another efficient performance, Manning and the Broncos overwhelmed the Carolina Panthers in a 36-14 outcome Sunday afternoon. Fox, who was coach...
In this week’s D&D Mailbag, a fan asked a great question, “Who is playing better right now, Eli or Peyton?” Although the italics are mine, that’s what I focused on with my answer in the mailbag. Giving you the bottom line up front for this article: It is not even debatable that Peyton is playing better right now. Digging deeper into the numbers as well as each team’s...
It’s something that most of us never imagined saying just two months ago, but if the NFL playoffs started today, the Andrew Luck led Indianapolis Colts would be in it.
With their fifth win in six games, and their fourth straight overall, the Colts all of a sudden find themselves in familiar territory in the playoff hunt. In fact, if the Houston Texans drop their Sunday Night...
Hi everyone! Make sure you stop by later for an episode of Rhino and Compass Radio. 3pm central!
This very well could be the best play of the college football weekend. (Texas A&M upset #1 Alabama)
To the horror of everyone, Purdue may end up bowl eligible.
And here is a fight in the NASCAR garage.
Fredrikstad 1, Rosenborg 0 – And now RBK is just mailing...
At the outset of the Thursday night live blog, commenter War Machine said, “Every off-season, I promise myself that I’ll watch football when I can, given that the time between seasons feels like an almost insurmountable expanse. This is one of the games that tests the tenacity of that vow.”
Well put. Though if we’re already channeling that sense of dedication, it worries...
On Thursday night the Indianapolis Colts controlled the Jacksonville Jaguars to improve their record to 6-3.Even if it was against the hapless Jaguars, beating a team on the road with only four days rest is pretty impressive.The 2011 Colts were the NFL's version of a dog that's so ugly it's cute, but in 2012 they have made a complete turnaround.Coming into Thursday'...
Buffalo Bills quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick doesn’t have the strongest or most accurate arm in the league. He isn’t the fastest runner and he doesn’t even win that many games. But he’s the only NFL starting quarterback who owns a diploma from Harvard. ”The League” on FX played off of Fitzpatrick’s nerdiness in his brief appearance on the show that will appear tonight...
Indianapolis and Jacksonville always keep things interesting between them, even if apart they are far from interesting.Jacksonville has been absolutely atrocious this season.Kansas City, who has yet to hold a lead, have been compared to the infamous 2008 Lions (0-16). Kansas City has accumulated -107 net points on the season while on their way to a 1-7 record. Jacksonville has -102...