Found November 09, 2012 on Waiting For Next Year:
I was reading an otherwise great article today at Grantland by Bill Barnwell that pointed out how bad a job Jacksonville Jaguars GM Gene Smith is at his job, when a snippet caught my attention. While talking about Josh Scobee and his contract from the Jags, a footnote said the following about Phil Dawson. Given that kickers are incredibly inconsistent from year to year, I still suspect that the Scobee deal will end up looking bad in a couple of years. And yes, two other franchise kickers (Phil Dawson and Matt Prater) have also been perfect this year, but given that they were both below-average in terms of their accuracy last year before being franchised, does that really prove that kicker accuracy is a predictable thing? Granted, Barnwell didn’t say anything about Phil Dawson and his abilities. He very well could have been speaking more to the value proposition of franchising a position like kicker where the return on investment is inconsistent. Then again, just in case he was besmirching the impeccably awesome name of Phil Dawson, I’ve prepared an over-reactive defense of everyone’s favorite Browns kicker. And honestly, why shouldn’t I considering the fact that pretty much every miss of Phil Dawson’s 2011 wasn’t his fault? Let’s start with the stats. Phil Dawson was 24 for 29 in 2011 which is 82.8%. That tied him with Jason Hanson for 17th in the league in terms of field goal percentage. Dawson’s misses need additional exploration though, especially given the fact that the Browns ended up parting ways with long-snapper Ryan Pontbriand in the middle of the season. Phil Dawson had a perfect season going until the sixth game of the season against Seattle. Dawson was 7-7 heading into the game against Charlie Whitehurst and the boys. He left the game 9-11 after not one, but two field goals were blocked by Red Bryant. As you’ll see in the pic below, he was pretty deep in the backfield too. Hard to blame Dawson for that. Dawson then went perfect in San Francisco and Houston going three for three. Then, Dawson went four for five against the Rams. That one miss? Ryan Pontbriand rolled the snap to Brad Maynard. That field goal miss was catastrophic too by the way. The Browns lost that game 13-12. Fast forward to the very next game against Jacksonville, Phil Dawson scowled at the referees as they called his field goal no good despite the fact that it appeared to go straight over the upright. Go ahead and hit Dawson for that one by leaving it in the judges hands, I guess. Usually Phil likes to put them right down the middle and he wasn’t able to do so on this day. Still, the evidence at least pushes it to the “controversial” category. Finally, Phil missed a 55 yarder against the Bengals in a 23-20 loss. After the game, Ryan Pontbriand said, “It was a bad snap – really bad.” That was November 27th and Ryan Pontbriand was let go by the Browns two days later on the 29th. This is not to pile on Ryan Pontbriand who Cleveland fans loved and appreciated for almost every second of his tenure in Cleveland. Still, it is more than just noteworthy when looking at Phil Dawson’s stats from 2011. Dawson went six for six through the rest of the season including one December game in Cleveland and one in Pittsburgh before ending the season on January 1st to end the Browns’ season going three for three in a 13-9 loss to the Steelers. No kicker is perfect and a kicking game relies on everyone doing their job well. Speaking specifically about Phil Dawson in 2011, it is very difficult to figure out how he could have been much more perfect. The one over the bar should have been centered, and the rest probably weren’t his fault. If everything goes the Browns’ way in the kicking game a year ago, Phil Dawson probably deserved to be 28-29. That didn’t happen, but let’s just say Phil Dawson earned his money. So just in case you think you can stare at statistics and box scores to determine a kicker’s accuracy, I’m here to tell you differently. Also, anyone who has a vote may feel free to reference this when affirmatively voting to put Phil Dawson in the Pro Football Hall of Fame in Canton.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Awesome Phil Dawson Gets Vanderjacked for the Browns

Phil Dawson has been a Cleveland Brown since joining the NFL in 1999 and sad part of that story is Phil Dawson has been a Cleveland Brown since 1999! Dawson had a great game on Sunday as he led the Browns by going 5-5 from Field Goal range. Unfortunately, that was all the points the Browns could muster as they fell to the Ravens 25-15. What’s more impressive is Dawson is at 100...

Banner on Heckert: “we have the same priorities”

Scott Petrak got a sit-down with new Browns CEO Joe Banner that is a must-read for Browns fans. You know you have the time with the bye week this week. In the article, Banner is quoted pretty warmly with regard to Tom Heckert and their past working relationship despite some of the rumor and innuendo to the contrary. “There’s nothing in our relationship that would be anything...

Joe Banner says the Browns will evaluate Brandon Weeden

According to Mary Kay Cabot of the Cleveland Plain-Dealer,  new Browns owner Jimmy Haslam and CEO Joe Banner plan on plan on evaluating rookie quarterback Brandon Weeden over the final seven weeks of the season. “He acknowledged that he and Haslam have seven more games to determine if Brandon Weeden is their quarterback of the future, especially considering that the Browns might...

Brandon Weeden Has 7 Games To Prove He’s The Browns QB Of The Future

Browns new CEO Joe Banner mentioned that they plan on evaluating the team for the remainder of the season and that includes rookie QB Brandon Weeden. “It’s right to put Brandon on the list of important things we have to figure out and we have seven games left to do that,” Banner said, via the  Cleveland Plain Dealer. “It’s an extremely important question for this organization...

Trent Richardson says he’s going to be a different player when he’s healthy

Cleveland Browns running back Trent Richardson can’t wait until he’s finally healthy so everyone can really see what he can do. “I haven’t been at 100 percent yet, so I’m waiting for that moment,” said Richardson, who missed pretty much missed training camp after recovering from a knee scope. “Whenever my ribs do heal, it’s going to make a big difference having this...

Trent Richardson To Be Even Better After The Bye?

I should play QB too Juan… Trent Richardson suffered a rib injury 4 weeks ago against the Bengals and after trying to play through it against the Panthers, was ineffective and was benhed.  Since then he has handled nearly 25 carries a week and has been running wild.  Can he get even be better after the bye week? Ricardson: “The bye week is going to be big for me concerning...

Brandon Weeden The Browns’ QB Of The Future?

I have never been good at auditions Juan… Brandon Weeden has flashed potential this season, but there is a very good chance that the Browns will have a whole new front office and coaching staff in 2013.  Weeden needs to prove that he can lead this team in the near future and may be on audition for the rest of the season.  The present coach Pat Shurmur tries to explain what...

While We’re Waiting…The Browns vs. ‘Bama

While We’re Waiting serves as the early morning gathering of WFNY-esque information for your viewing pleasure. Have something you think we should see? Send it to our tips email at tips@waitingfornextyear.com. “Steve “Spurrier suggested earlier this month that Alabama could beat a couple of NFL teams. Pete Carroll rightfully pointed out that idea was ridiculous, saying a game...

Banner talks about initial stadium improvements

Joe Banner is talking. This time, Banner sat down with Nate Ulrich for a Q&A about a variety of topics. Like Scott Petrak’s article this morning, it is must-read stuff for Browns fans. One note of interest is that while Browns fans speak of domes, Joe Banner is thinking a bit more pragmatically starting with the basics at the gates and concession stands. I don’t think I...

Pat Shurmur Needs to Go Now!

If Jimmy Haslam III wants to fix the flailing Browns, he can do so in one easy step! That step would be to fire Pat Shurmur before the next game and turn the team over to either Brad Childress or Dick Jauron for the remainder of the 2012 season. Shurmur has time and time again
NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.