Originally posted on The Colts Authority  |  Last updated 12/24/11

Some have made the claim recently that Orlvosky has played at a level Curtis Painter is not capable of.

I believe Painter not only played at that level, but surpassed it. Painter's play was never the same after the New Orleans game. Something about that experience damaged him going forward. While Orlovsky is clearly better than Painter was in his last few weeks, he's not better than Painter was in his first four games. Here are those numbers comparing Painter's first four games (Pittsburgh, Tampa, KC, and Cincinnati) to Orlvosky's last four games (NE, Balt, Tenn, Hou)

Comp Att % Yards YPA TD INT Rating Sack Rate Fumbles Painter 56 102 55.0 806 7.9 5 1 93.0 5.6 3 Orlovsky 81 132 61.4 815 6.2 5 2 85.3 6.4 5

Orlvosky is clearly inferior. He's especially bad in the pocket, taking more sacks and fumbling more often.

How did the offense do with each player?

Painter: 18.7 PPG (just for the 3 starts, leaving Pittsburgh off since he didn't play the whole game)

Orlovsky: 18.3 PPG (doesn't get credit for defensive score against Tennessee, obviously)

How about on a per drive basis?

3rd dn Att Con % Yds Plys Y/P Drives Y/D Points Pnts/
Play Pnts/
Drive Painter 17 40 42.5 1049 182 5.8 35 30.0 65 .36 1.9 Orlovsky 22 58 37.9 1211 254 4.8 43 28.2 73 .29 1.7

From week 2 when he entered the Pittsburgh game through the Cincinnati game, the offense ran better under Curtis Painter than it has during Dan Orlovsky's 4 starts.

It scored more per drive, per play, and was better on 3rd down. Painter personally played better in his first four games than Orlovsky did in his four starts.

Now, I am not saying Orlvosky shouldn't be playing, he should. We all know what happened that night in New Orleans, and Painter was horrible from then on. It's like he wasn't even the same player anymore. Orlovsky now is better than Painter now. No one is questioning that.

However, for anyone to assert that Orlovsky is doing things Painter is incapable of, or that Orlvosky would have run the offense better than Painter early in the season is to deny reality.

People forget that Painter was credible for several games. He wasn't good. He was just playing a little better than Orlvosky is right now. The Painter we saw against Jacksonville and Carolina was inept and deserving of being benched. It wasn't always that way.

MORE FROM YARDBARKER:
Cult of Sport: Before there was Ezekiel Elliott, there was Eric Dickerson
GET THE YARDBARKER APP:
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45
MORE FROM YARDBARKER

White Sox trade Adam Eaton to Nationals for haul of impressive prospects

Looking at NFL injuries that could impact the Super Bowl chase

Report: RG3 to start Sunday barring health setback

Major changes could be coming to the World Cup in 2026

Peterson planning to return if Vikings stay in playoff hunt

LIKE WHAT YOU SEE?
GET THE DAILY NEWSLETTER:

Desmond’s deal with Rockies is puzzling, opens door for trades

Report: ‘Well has been poisoned’ for Lane Kiffin as USF candidate

Johnny Manziel tells Lamar Jackson not to go to Browns

NCAA president on Penn State: ‘How could you not be pleased?’

Chris Bosh likely to wait until next season to try comeback

Report: Jackson ‘intrigued’ by possible Eagles reunion

TailGreater: Tips for bowl travelers

Ranking the single-player modes of the 2017 sports games

Box Score 12/7: The date we got to know Bo

MLB Winter Meetings report, Day 2: News, notes and rumors

Ten most intriguing non-NY6 bowl games

Breaking down the NFL playoff picture heading into Week 14

The best (and worst) times athletes hosted 'SNL'

The five must-have sports games of 2016

MLB Winter Meetings report, Day 1: News, notes and rumors

The five 2016 Heisman finalists: How do they measure up?

Box Score 12/6: Klay Thompson and the ball of fire

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

By clicking "Sign Me Up", you have read and agreed to the Fox Sports Digital Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. You can opt out at any time. For more information, please see our Privacy Policy.
the YARDBARKER app
Get it now!
Ios_download En_app_rgb_wo_45

TailGreater: Tips for bowl travelers

Ranking the single-player modes of the 2017 sports games

MLB Winter Meetings report, Day 2: News, notes and rumors

The five best (and worst) times athletes hosted 'SNL'

The five must-have sports games of 2016

Winter Meetings report, Day 1: News, notes and rumors

The five 2016 Heisman finalists: How do they measure up?

The 10 best sports docs available for streaming

Sporting life: Gifts for real fans (that aren't ugly NFL Christmas sweaters)

The good, bad, and ugly from NFL Week 13

Today's Best Stuff
For Publishers
Company Info
Help
Follow Yardbarker