Found March 04, 2013 on Waiting For Next Year:
Alec Scheiner (left) of the Browns chats with Daryl Morey This weekend I was at the MIT Sloan Sports Analytics (#SSAC13) conference where new Browns president Alec Scheiner was busy observing and participating in discussion panels. Scheiner wasn’t alone either. As many as three other Browns staffers were rumored to be on hand this weekend for the festivities that Bill Simmons dubbed “dorkapalooza.” So the “analytics revolution” has arrived in Berea. But, what exactly does that mean? One of the biggest themes of the weekend in Boston was not about whether analytics is good or not, but how to make it most useful in sports organizations. The panels were rife with stories by some brilliant people about mistakes committed by the “stats geeks” where they were unable to effectively communicate their message to the more traditional stakeholders in their various sports organizations. We heard stories of ultra complex PowerPoint presentations and other missteps that set back the relationships between departments that sometimes have trouble working together, despite working toward the same goals. For stats guys who tend to speak their own language it is important. It’s not that stats guys are right and the traditional scouts and coaches are wrong, or vice versa. It’s more like traditional scouts and coaches have been successful doing things their own way in the past, and could get even better if some data helped reduce even one or two mistakes per year. These traditional guys come to find themselves in the NFL because they’ve achieved success. The advanced stats and analytics should be used to supplement, not replace, and that’s where adoption sometimes becomes an issue of communication and territories. As of right now, the NFL is furthest behind in professional sports where the NBA and MLB have been working in analytics for a long time. The Browns are somewhat behind the game too. One of the other highlighted panelists this weekend was Paraag Marathe of the San Francisco 49ers. Marathe is the COO of the Super Bowl runners-up and has been with the team since 2001 when he was hired by Bill Walsh to re-think the draft pick value chart using mathematical algorithms, with regard to trades. Anecdotally, it is interesting that the team that was one win away from being champs also happens to have 15 draft picks in 2013. Think about that for a second. When Butch Davis was coaching Tim Couch, Kelly Holcomb and Courtney Brown, the 49ers were establishing cutting edge stats and analytics to supplement a legendary football mind in Bill Walsh. The Browns meanwhile have turned over a number of times, seemingly from tip to tail, in that same time period. When Eric Mangini was trading draft picks in 2009 seemingly without much of a front office around him, the 49ers had a philosophy on the topic that had been in development for eight years. Granted Mangini didn’t trade with the 49ers, but still, in terms of doing everything you can to get ahead, it appears the Browns weren’t doing anywhere near as much as others. So the Browns now have Alec Scheiner and a crew of people including former Mozilla and Dallas Cowboy employee Ken Kovash who carries the official title of “Director, Football Research and Player Personnel Assistant.” What does that mean for practical purposes? Does that mean that this year’s draft will be run by the analytics department? Will they even have a seat at the table in the “war room?” The real answer is that I don’t know for sure, but I’m guessing things will progress more subtly and slowly than all that. During the conference this weekend, despite being a champion of advanced analytics, Alec Scheiner made sure to tell everyone that he isn’t a math expert, as he self-identified himself as “just a lawyer.” He is the President of the Browns, but he was insistent that adoption of analytics needs to be subtle and most likely on a project-by-project basis. So more likely than anything, there could be some stats done on a specific position group to give some guidance on the pool and maybe eliminate some candidates. Again, I’m just guessing, but I am truly led to believe it is a lot of supplemental info to try to limit mistakes and boost decision-making confidence. The people doing the math need to concentrate on joining the team culture. Scheiner told the audience that Ken Kovash has been wearing Browns gear to work every day so he fits in with the coaches and scouts that are his co-workers. He will hope to support and convince them of different conclusions that data indicates over time, but hopefully not as an “outsider” inside the Browns football organization. When people think of analytics, they envision a closed-off know-it-all who thinks on different planes and professes to know everything.  But that would never work. Scheiner and his department seem to know that pretty explicitly. Instead of being some kind of silo of confusing math that spits out self-proclaimed “genius” and expect others to just listen, it will be important to create a cohesive front office through relationship-building. In the world of analytics nothing is guaranteed because the math is being applied to humans which can’t be completely encompassed with variables. That’s a long-winded way of saying that even the best math won’t guarantee draft success. Nothing can guarantee draft success. I don’t know of any draft class that was 100% successful and I don’t think anyone in football comes close to making that an unrealistic aspiration. There’s a lot more to this story, and I will try to share just what an analytics department can try to achieve in the NFL based on what I heard last week. Just a teaser, but it’s not just the salary cap. For now, just know that the “revolution” will be less like a radical change and more like the beginning of a slow rotation that could take a few years to go all the way around even once. The good news is that the Browns have set it in motion. They weren’t the first, but they also aren’t the last. —– (Photo Craig Lyndall – WaitingForNextYear)
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Browns “impressed” with Greg Little’s maturation

The Cleveland Browns appear to be pretty pleased with one of last season’s big question marks in wide receiver Greg Little. In his latest Sunday column, Terry Pluto of The Plain Dealer describes Little and teammate Josh Gordon as integral parts of the team’s future, but it is only little who appears to have calmed nerves regarding his maturity and work ethic. “Reviewing the...

Chris Weinke on working with Weeden: 'Brandon's got a special arm, no doubt'

Former Heisman trophy winner and Carolina Panthers quarterback Chris Weinke has been wokring with Cleveland Browns QB Brandon Weeden at the IMG Football Academy in Bradenton, Fla., and Weinke likes what he sees, according to Mary Kay Cabot of The Cleveland Plain Dealer. "Brandon's got a special arm, no doubt,'' Weinke said. "I'm very impressed with him...

Defensive lineman Phil Taylor likes the change in defensive philosophy: “Everybody will be attacking in this defense”

The arrival of former Cardinals defensive coordinator Ray Horton brings the winds of change, and attitude. Horton learned his craft under legendary Dick Lebeau in Pittsburgh, the father of the zone blitz. Horton wants to bring the fierce style to Cleveland, but the 3-4 defense needs a nose tackle in order to work, enter 355 pound Phil Taylor. Everything starts with holding the...

Browns Prepared To Part Ways With Colt McCoy?

Terry Pluto of the Cleveland Plain Dealer writs that it’s doubtful that QB Colt McCoy is back with the Browns next season. According to Pluto, the Browns “don’t believe McCoy can be a viable starter” and are reportedly considering Matt Moore and Matt Cassel as backups that could push Brandon Weeden for the job next season. McCoy, 26, triggered escalators in 2012 that...

Browns will not raise ticket prices for 2013; cell service issues to be rectified

Cleveland Browns season ticket prices will remain flat for the 2013 home schedule, the team announced today. This marks the fifth straight year in which the price of Browns season tickets has not increased, representing the second-longest current streak in the NFL. In addition, with the current pricing structure, the average cost of a Browns ticket is the second least expensive in...

Kevin Costner to star as Browns GM in new movie shooting in Cleveland

A story this morning in the Buffalo News is exciting for the city of Cleveland, and Browns fans. It appears Cleveland was chosen over Buffalo as the location for a new movie called “Draft Day” which will star Kevin Costner and be directed by Ivan Reitman. “A furious fourth-quarter rally mounted by New York State officials – including a top aide to Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo ...

The Browns, analytics, and finding market inefficiencies as an organization

Yesterday, I wrote about how I thought that the analytics revolution in Berea would be subtle. Today, I’m going to suggest some practical ways that analytics could be used inside the building to help the Browns. More often than not, it will be supplemental reports to help increase confidence levels in decision-making processes in an effort to reduce the frequency of inevitable...

Fantasy Football Player Profile – Brandon Weeden, QB

Brandon Weeden, QB, Cleveland Browns Player Profile Height/Weight: 6-3/220 Birthdate: 10/14/1983 School: Oklahoma State FANTASY FOOTBALL ANALYSIS The Cleveland Browns rolled the dice on a late-20′s quarterback out of Oklahoma State in Brandon Weeden during last year’s NFL draft in hopes that they could go against the grain and find a bargain to lead their offense into battle...

Lombardi Promoted; Farmer Added

Michael Lombardi now has his third title in six weeks. He is now the Cleveland Browns' general manager. Meanwhile, Ray Farmer was named the assistant GM.

Banner Report: The Quarterbacks

You may remember back in 2010 (you know the last time there was a complete overhaul in Berea) we wanted to give incoming President Mike Holmgren a hand evaluating the roster. We are nothing if not equal opportunity. The Browns have a completely new group in charge this year. Joe Banner, Mike Lombardi, Rob Chudzinski, Norv Turner and Ray Horton take over a 5-11 team. They have plenty...
Browns News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.