Found December 24, 2012 on Midwest Sports Fans:

All year we’ve heard the debate over who will be the NFL’s Offensive Rookie of the Year. Until recently, it’s been one of two guys: RGIII or Andrew Luck. But with Seattle Seahawks’ QB Russell Wilson now joining the discussion, you’ve got to take a very in-depth look into each of their seasons to determine who’s really the most deserving. A 3-man race this close is rare for any high-ranking award. Credit: ESPN First, let’s look at the top-line stats through the first 16 weeks: Andrew luck has 21 passing touchdowns, 18 interceptions, and 5 rushing touchdowns. RG3 has 20 passing touchdowns, 6 on the ground, and only 5 interceptions. Russell Wilson has thrown for an impressive 25 touchdowns through the air, 3 on the ground, all while throwing 10 picks. From those stats alone, which do indeed matter, I’d say Andrew Luck has put himself at a huge disadvantage by throwing for almost 4x as many interceptions as RG3 and nearly twice as many as Wilson. Luck also trails in the completion percentage department, with his 54.3% trailing RG3′s 66.4% and Wilson’s 63.4% by a wide margin. To be fair, Luck was given the worst running game out of the three, so he’s had to throw the ball a lot more (599 times to Griffin and Wilson’s 374.5). Still, the margins are pretty steep. After seeing those numbers, it’d be easy to say that RG3 and Wilson are in a dead heat for the award. But when you look at how they’ve performed week-to-week, you realize that Wilson didn’t start playing well with any consistency until about week 9, as he really only had 2 or 3 noticeably good games before that point. Now don’t get me wrong…you can’t underestimate how big Wilson has been for his team of late, as Seattle has rattled off wins in 6 of their last 7 games behind their rookie QB’s emergence. But Luck’s Colts have won 8 of their last 10 and RG3′s Redskins are riding a 5-game winning streak … so they’re all pretty even in that regard. Andrew Luck has been instrumental in leading his team to 9 very close wins. Credit: ESPN So for me, it comes down to one cliche term: their overall body of work. And here is where I unfortunately have to eliminate Andrew Luck from contention for the award. Luck’s QBR (out of 100) this year is 64.6, while RG3′s is 71.1 and Russell Wilson’s is 70.0. Also, Luck’s passer rating is down at 75.6 while Griffin’s is 104.1 and Wilson’s is 98.0. I think the passer rating is a good statistic to go off of in this instance because each of them have been able to compile decent numbers running, as opposed to one being well behind the others in that category. I’m as big of an Andrew Luck fan as there is (outside of Indianapolis), and even with his record-setting 4,183 yards so far through the air (a rookie record), it’s just not enough for me to say he’s one of the top two candidates for the award. Even with all of those yards piled up on his stat sheet, he’s still only averaged 6.98 yards per pass attempt – less than RG3′s 8.27 and Russell Wilson’s 7.67. Luck could easily end up being the most reliable, consistent, and all-around best QB of the three long term, but for now it’s either Robert Griffin III or Russell Wilson’s award. So, back to the question of the hour – who is this year’s Offensive ROY? Going back to Griffin and Wilson’s overall body of work, it’s clear to me who has the best overall season by the numbers: Robert Griffin III. RG3 leads Wilson in just about every statistical category (besides passing TD), including QBR, passer rating, completion %, interceptions, yards in the air, and yards on the ground (both QB’s have been labeled “running threats”). He’s also on a much worse team overall, as the Redskins have what many believe to be the worst defense in the NFL, while the Seahawks were already a solid team that most saw to be missing only a quarterback. After his effort in Week 16 against the 49ers, nobody is overlooking Wilson. Credit: ESPN As previously mentioned, Wilson struggled with consistency for quite some time, whereas RG3 has been extraordinarily reliable dating all the way back to week 1. If you take their worst 3 games based on passer rating (the anomalies, if you will), RG3′s average is a 76.63 while Wilson’s is all the way down at a 49. In other words, RG3′s “bad” has been much, much better than Wilson’s bad. So yes, the flashy, fun, humble, and unpredictable Robert Griffin III is indeed my NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year. It’s rare that guys as impressive as Andrew Luck or Russell Wilson don’t win the award, but that just speaks volumes to how consistent and impressive RG3 has been all year long. He’s put together a phenomenal body of work, racking up tons of impressive statistics all while taking care of the ball as well as some of the NFL’s best veterans do. As exhilarating as it’s been watching RG3 all year, just imagine what he’ll be able to do with experience under his belt, a competent defense supporting him, a veteran running game at his disposal, and a healthy receiving corps. RGIII battled back from injury in Week 16 to lead his team to their 5th straight victory. Credit: USA TODAY And lucky us, we could very well get to watch each of these 3 QB’s in the playoffs. The post Who Is The NFL’s Offensive Rookie of the Year? An Updated Look at RG3, Andrew Luck, and Russell Wilson appeared first on Midwest Sports Fans.

THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Andrew Luck Sets NFL Rookie Passing Record in Playoff-Clinching Victory Over Chiefs

Cam Newton‘s record didn’t stand for very long. Andrew Luck broke Newton’s rookie record for most passing yards in a season. Newton set the mark in 2012 with 4,051 yards. Luck needed just 74 yards to pass the record heading into Sunday afternoon. Luck passed the mark on a 23-yard pass to fellow rookie T.Y. Hilton with just under a minute remaining in the first half. Luck finished...

Andrew Luck breaks rookie passing yards record

Indianapolis Colts quarterback Andrew Luck added another notch on his resume Sunday. Luck broke the single season record for passing yards by a rookie quarterback. The record had been set last season by Carolina’s Cam Newton with 4,051 yards. Newton set the record in 16 games, Luck broke the record just before halftime of his 15th game.

As Luck Would Have It

Andrew Luck, of the Indianapolis Colts, the new rookie record holder for most yards thrown by a rookie, also proved to hold the doom card of the KC Chiefs on this final Sunday of the 2012 season at Arrowhead Stadium.

Colts' Luck sets NFL's rookie record

The expectations placed upon Andrew Luck almost seemed unfair. Being the heir to Peyton Manning in Indianapolis is heady stuff for a rookie taking the reins of a franchise that won two games last season. Now, after guiding the Colts back to the playoffs, and breaking Cam Newton's single-season passing record for a first-year player, it's safe to say Luck exceeded just about...

Colts beat Chiefs 20-13 to clinch playoff berth

Andrew Luck couldn't help but smile thinking about the joyous celebration taking place just down the hall, through the big metal doors marking the entrance to the Colts' locker room. Even interim coach Bruce Arians had been dancing. ''It's a fun locker room, a great locker room,'' Luck said after leading Indianapolis to a 20-13 victory over Kansas City...

Seahawks will go Mayan on the 49ers Sunday…if the following happens.

The Hawks playoff hopes are at stake. This is it. The upstart Seahawks have erupted and shocked the NFL this season, led by Rookie of The Year candidate and American hero Russell Wilson. Here are the keys to arguably the Seahawks biggest game of the season. If Wilson Brings his A+ Game Russell Wilson has been the catalyst for the Seahawks surprising success this season. Wilson...

Seahawks to Harbaugh: Happy birthday — that's what you get

Seattle Seahawks thoroughly enjoyed their 42-13 victory over the San Francisco 49ers Sunday night. Second-year cornerback Richard Sherman wanted to continue the Seahawks two-week trend of scoring 50 points on opponents, telling Yahoo! Sports, "I'm not gonna lie to you, I told Pete, 'Let's score and go for two.' He said, 'We have more class than that...

With a primetime thrashing of the 49ers the Seattle Seahawks have served notice to the NFC playoff field

As a football fan base we have a tendency to overreact to the outcome of primetime games - with that said, Seattle’s statement victory over San Francisco should be viewed as a very significant development heading into the post-season.  Seattle remains undefeated at home and they are currently riding a four game win streak into their season finale. The three most recent games...

San Francisco 49ers at Seattle Seahawks: 5 Things We Learned

In the final game of week 16 on Sunday Night Football, the Seattle Seahawks took it to the San Francisco 49ers, dominating the game in all three phases. Russell Wilson had the first four touchdown game of his young career. The 49ers offense was held to two field goals and a late touchdown, by a Seahawks defense that swarmed to the ball all night.After putting on such an impressive...

Bengals, Colts grab final AFC playoff spots

One year after putting together the NFL's worst record, the Indianapolis Colts are headed to the playoffs. Joining them on Sunday were the Cincinnati Bengals, finishing out the field in the AFC. The Colts (10-5) equaled the 2008 Miami Dolphins as the only teams to win at least 10 games after losing 14 or more the previous season. Top overall draft pick Andrew Luck completed a...

Colts, Bengals make playoffs with wins

One year after putting together the NFL's worst record, the Indianapolis Colts are headed to the playoffs. Joining them on Sunday were the Cincinnati Bengals, finishing out the field in the AFC. The Colts (10-5) equaled the 2008 Miami Dolphins as the only teams to win at least 10 games after losing 14 or more the previous season. Top overall draft pick Andrew Luck completed...

San Francisco 49ers vs. Seahawks Week 16 game balls & stats

We’re In! This team just continues to impress me. Now sitting at #2 all time in a three game scoring spree at 150 points! I said it before, but who in the hell stole my Seahawks and replaced them with real football players? Arizona, and Buffalo are one thing, but San Francisco was the unanimous “best team” in the league last week, and we just destroyed them tonight. Defense...

Tempers flared and a shoving match broke out on Sunday Night Football

A good ol’ fashion shoving match broke out during the San Francisco 49ers and the Seattle Seahawks. Some may call it a brawl or a fight but one thing is for sure. These guys didn’t like each other. The fight occurred right before the Seahawks put up 42 points over the San Francisco 49er defense. Flags were thrown and linemen were getting into it with each other. Russell Wilson...

Colts Edge Chiefs, Clinch No. 5 Playoff Seed: 5 Things We Learned

The goal was simple for the 9-5 Indianapolis Colts on Sunday: win, and get in.  In other words, the Colts could clinch a playoff spot in the AFC with a win over the Chiefs.  That's exactly what they did, sneaking by Kansas City, 20-13.  In this article, I'll tackle the tough questions following this game, including:Do the Colts deserve a playoff spot?Are the Colts legitimate...
NFL News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.