Found April 21, 2012 on
For Red Wings fans, watching the final minutes of game five was painful. While Detroit fought tooth and nail to tie the game, the clock eventually expired with the score 2-1 in favor of the Nashville Predators.
The loss was made even more agonizing when the game concluded and the camera zoomed in on captain Nicklas Lidstom. Lidstrom may have laced up his skates for the final time last night, as many believe he will retire after 20 years as a Red Wing.
Head coach Mike Babcock gave credit to a Nashville team that he called “deeper than us,” but added that he thought his team made mistakes that simply didn’t happen during the regular season. A frustrated Babcock said he thought game five was the Wings’ “worst game of the series.”
I think Babcock was a bit dramatic in his assessment of the Red Wings, but he was spot on in saying that the mistakes piled up and were too much to overcome. Detroit gave Nashville several gift-wrapped goals in the series, something that the Predators did not do.
But the honest difference maker in this series can only be one man: Nashville goaltender Pekka Rinne.
Rinne put on a show this series that very few can claim to have matched throughout the league’s history. Rinne allowed just nine goals in five games and boasted a save percentage of .944. While Detroit was able to get a very respectable 160 shots on goal, Rinne stopped nearly all of them. Playing a very aggressive style, Rinne was able to influence the game in more ways than simply stopping the puck. The Nashville netminder showed no fear of playing the puck well outside of his crease, and won his team the puck when they otherwise may not have had it.
But while Rinne was every bit as good as advertised, the Red Wings won’t be content with writing this series off due to one player. Detroit’s lack of depth and the absence of Darren Helm clearly hindered them. Without anyone outside their top six forwards who could score the puck, Detroit lacked the goal-scoring ability they needed in this series.
While Nashville was able to capitalize on the Red Wings’ mistakes and score timely goals, Detroit was not. The Wings never seemed to have an answer in this series when faced with adversity.
In game five, when Jiri Hudler scored the game-tying goal in the second period, Detroit seemed to grab the momentum. While the ice seemed to be slanted in their favor, the Wings
Detroit had life after Hudler tied the game, but never got the lead
weren’t able to come up with the goal that would have given them a lead. Then the Predators scored during the first shift of the third period, and the momentum was gone.
Once faced with the one-goal deficit, Detroit could not find a way to claw their way to another goal.
I don’t like to point fingers, but that’s part of my job and there were several players who deserve to take some heat for this 4-1 series loss to Nashville.
First is Johan Franzen. Franzen led the team this regular season with 29 goals, but only tallied one in the playoffs. His lone goal was basically a fluke, as the puck went in off his skate. Franzen’s presence simply was not felt in this series.
Also deserving blame is Todd Bertuzzi. Really the only thing Bertuzzi did in this series was fight Shea Weber for his dirty hit on Henrik Zetterberg after the final whistle in game three. Tuzzi racked up more penalty minutes (nine) than shots (seven) in this series, and was a whopping -5 when on the ice.
While Pavel Datsyuk had a relatively quiet series, I believe that reflects the play of his linemates (see Franzen and Bertuzzi) more so than it reflects his play. Pavel still managed to lead his team with three points and two assists despite his team giving him little help.
Some will point fingers at defenseman Kyle Quincey, especially for his play in game five. I don’t think Quincey can be blamed too much, mostly because you can’t put too much stock in the play of your worst defenseman. As a whole, the defense played well in my mind other than the few breakdowns that they had. Nashville averaged only 23 shots per game in this series, which is good defense no matter how you look at it.
I thought that Henrik Zetterberg was far and away the best player on the ice for Detroit, with Jiri Hudler, Valtteri Filppula, and Brad Stuart also with good showings.
The story here was goaltending and depth. Rinne was far better in net than Detroit’s Jimmy Howard, and the third line of Nashville was superior to Detroit’s.
The Red Wings now enter a very long offseason that will be filled with questions. Lidstrom’s status is still up in the air, and it remains to be seen what GM Ken Holland has in mind for his team. Holland may be thinking that the Red Wings need to clean house, or he may be thinking that they simply need to add a player or two to become contenders.
The next weeks will not answer any questions, as the offseason won’t technically start until the Stanley Cup finals have concluded in June.
After a long season, the Red Wings now face the same task as their fans: getting over the emotional disappointment of an early playoff exit.
Follow me on twitter @ScottPeceny
BEST OF MAXIM
Regardless of whether you agree with Red Wings coach Mike Babcock’s assessment that scoring and depth up front doomed the Wings—and as Shark Circle points out, Babcock had hoped that the Wings would land a top-six forward as well as a top-flight defenseman to replace Brian Rafalski when he retired last spring—or whether you believe that the Wings might be better served to not...
Nicklas Lidstrom says he needs a few weeks before discussing his future with Detroit Red Wings general manager Ken Holland.
Lidstrom's 20th NHL season ended Friday night when the Nashville Predators eliminated Detroit with a 2-1 win in Game 5 of their Western Conference first-round series.
The four-time Stanley Cup champion and seven-time Norris Trophy winner turns 42 this...
Building upon last night and this morning’s slate of Red Wings discussion, today, 9.71 the Ticket’s Dennis Fithian and Scott Anderson weigh in, the classic Monday morning gut-punch “quarterback” in Ryan Lambert has offered his take on the old Wings’ old problems because they’re so old, I’m not even going to comment on this, and then…
MLive’s Ansar Khan offers ten...
Helene St. James is going crazy. It must be the uncommon early Spring boredom that’s got her all redolent. She’s out there though, right on a limb. And there’s no hotter topic these days than the streaky Moose.
Johan Franzen did not have a good series, scoring one goal in five games despite playing next to Pavel Datsyuk. Franzen has eight years remaining on his contract...
Red Wings fans, here’s a “pro tip”: familiarize yourself with Capgeek.com’s Red Wings salary cap chart. Under both the economic constraints of this CBA and the one which will hopefully be negotiated without any sort of lockout on the owners’ parts, the Wings will remain tied to the some of the decisions their management team has made going forward, and between the fact...
Just after DetroitRedWings.com’s Bill Roose penned the article which this blog entry focuses upon, the Wings’ list of World Championship participants increased: in addition to Tomas Tatar (Slovakia), Valtteri Filppula (Finland), Jonathan Ericsson (Sweden) and the subject of Roose’s article, one Jakub Kindl (Czech Republic), Expressen’s Gunnar Nordstrom reports that Henrik...
Times are tough in Detroit, or so I'm told. Declining auto industry, recession, Red Wings getting knocked out of the playoffs, having to pay Megtron all that money, yadda yadda. I've only been there twice in between connecting flights for a grand total of probably like three hours but I'm sure that if people are out there selling their dentures on eBay things can'...
The Western Conference’s Central Division has become wild territory for any team to succeed.
Niklas Lidstrom skates off the ice in this file photo. He's one of the few components of the Red Wings that remain in doubt after an early playoffs exit.
The Detroit Red Wings may have a 21-year streak of clinching the playoffs, and have done so in 26 of their last 28,...
It's April and the Red Wings' season is over. That doesn't happen very often and it sucks every time it does, but there were some positives to take from this year. And if I ever remember what they are, I'll write a post about them.Jump for the full season recap:
The season started out promising as the Wings won their first five games, but then lost their next 6...
Their backs were against the wall. It was a Best-of-3 situation for the Detroit Red Wings to try and extend their run towards the Stanley Cup Finals. After dropping two crucial games in the confines of the Joe Louis Arena the Red Wings were holding on to what little hope was left on this season in the raucous Music City crowd.
Out of the gate, Detroit made it known that they were...
Detroit Red Wings veteran Pavel Datysuk will vie for his fourth Frank J. Selke Trophy.
Datysuk joined St. Louis Blues captain David Backes and Patrice Bergeron of the Boston Bruins as finalists for the award, which goes to the league's best defensive forward.
The 33-year-old Datsyuk collected 19 goals and 48 assists in 70 games this season.
Backes had a team-leading 24 goals...
from Michael Traikos of the National Post, They have not spoken the word in more than 20 years. But now, after three straight seasons of early playoff exits, is it time for a rebuild in Detroit? Or can this storied franchise merely get by with a re-tool?
That is the question facing Red Wings GM Ken Holland after the fifth-seeded Western Conference team lost 2-1 to the Nashville...
NASHVILLE– With a 2-1 win in Game 5, the Nashville Predators became the first team toadvance to the second round of the Stanley Cup Playoffs. Their first playoff series win over Detroit isa signal that times have changed in Nashville.It’sa result the Predators have found themselves on the short end of in the past.In2004 and 2008, the Red Wings were heavy favorites going into...
from Pierre LeBrun of ESPN, So let’s deal with what we do know as of Sunday afternoon. Detroit and San Jose, the two franchises who have played the most playoff games since the 2005 lockout (Wings-97, Sharks-79) are both out in the first round.
How do we even recognize a Western Conference playoff without them?
The Wings and Sharks have been a staple for so many years, the Wings...