Found December 05, 2013 on Blue Seat Blogs:
Bruce Bennett/Getty Images We’ve received some feedback over the past few weeks that readers are looking for a more objective viewpoint on hot-button Rangers issues.  In our insatiable desire to please our readership, we’ve decided to start the Playing devil’s advocate series, looking at both sides of major debates and lending our own conclusion. As the 2013-2014 season progresses, one topic that always remains at the forefront is the Brad Richards buyout decision. The Rangers are allowed one more compliance buyout in June of 2014, and the rumors are they will use it on Richards. The 33-year-old center signed a back-diving contract as a free agent prior to the 2011-2012 season. After a strong first season, Richards struggled mightily in the lockout-shortened 2013 season. He got off to a hot start this season (5-3-8 in the first 8 games), but has slowed a bit, putting up 2-10-12 in the other 20 games. Despite that, Richards is still leading the team in scoring, with 20 points in 28 games. Regardless of your opinion of Richards, he’s a critical Ranger this season. But is he worth the risk of keeping him around? The case to keep him around: Even though he is not the elite Brad Richards of old, Richards is still on pace for a little less than 60 points this season. Fifty-eight points during the 2011-2012 season would put Richards in the top-25 among centers, making him a bottom-third top line center. During the lockout shortened 2013 season, the one where Richards was a step behind, Richards was still #22 in points among centers. Derek Stepan has eclipsed Richards as the top center for this team, but Richards gave the Rangers a dangerous 1-2 punch at center. No matter what you think of his play without the puck, he still produces at a top line center clip. Speaking of his play without the puck, Richards’ role on this team is no longer as a two-way center. Alain Vigneault has started Richards a whopping 70.9% in the offensive zone (via O/D St%, which is offensive zone starts divided by defensive zone starts, neutral zone starts are omitted). Richards’ role is that of an offensive player, he needs to score to be effective. That’s what he’s been doing, aside from a five game pointless stretch. Since he leads the team in scoring, and is still on a top-30 scoring pace for centers, he is doing his job there. Bruce Bennett/Getty Images North America The case to buy him out: That contract is a disaster waiting to happen. Sure the cap hit may not be much as the cap goes up, but do the Rangers really want $6.67 million in cap space tied up to a guy that has already shown a decline in production? AV might be able to get an extra year or two by sheltering Richards with zone starts, but that contract runs for the next six seasons, at which point Richards will be 40 years old. If he’s already slowing down now, can you imagine what it would be like at 40? Another contract issue: Cap recapture for early retirement. While Henrik Lundqvist’s contract does not qualify here, Richards’ contract does. If Richards retires early, then the Rangers are smacked with a $5.67 million cap penalty for each season left on his deal (assuming he retires after 2017). It saves them $1 million in cap space if Richards doesn’t retire, but that’s still $5.67 million in dead weight. At $6.67 million, Richards’ cap hit is among the top-20 for all forwards in the league. Looking at those with expiring contracts, only a few will pass him on that list in the immediate future. Second line centers nowadays, those in the 40-50 point range, sign at around $4 million-$5 million. Cap space is an important commodity, and that extra $1.5 million goes a long way. How much longer do we have until Richards’ play declines so much that he can no longer contribute offensively? Since he can’t really contribute defensively on a consistent basis anymore, scoring is the only thing he has left, and that’s already on the decline. Even if AV gets another two or three useful years out of Richards, there’s still another three years of mediocrity at best. The case to trade him: Richards has a no-movement clause, so he would need to approve any trade. While it does happen, let’s assume he doesn’t approve anything, since those are in there for a reason. If the Rangers trade him, they still need to take on the cap recapture penalty if he retires early. Capgeek has a recapture calculator, so you can play with the numbers there. My take: Before this season began, I thought it was the right move to keep Richards for one more season. He’s proving some doubters wrong, as his offensive play has certainly improved with AV. However, it is clear he cannot be counted on for any defensive responsibilities. It is also clear that he is on the decline offensively. For a player that is no longer relied upon to contribute defensively, offensive decline is a career killer. The team made the right move keeping him around for this season, with no other viable options. There are other options available internally for next season, and the risk of decline and keeping that contract are too great. I think a buyout is inevitable, barring injury. Tweet
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

New York Rangers set to open crucial stretch of season

You hate to say an 82-game season that stretches from October to April can be defined by nine games in December. You are taught to avoid such inflated talk. But the New York Rangers, who begin a nine-game homestand Saturday against the Devils, may well see their fate determined in the coming weeks. When the team began the season with nine games on the road – the first five out...

Rangers Deal Mashinter to Hawks for Former First Round Pick Kyle Beach

The New York Rangers announced this afternoon that they have dealt F Brandon Mashinter to Chicago for fellow F and former first-round draft choice, Kyle Beach. Beach, the 11th overall selection in the 2008 draft, has yet to debut in the NHL. Mashinter meanwhile has 23 games of big league experience, 10 with the Rangers, […]

Lineup notes: Dorsett out; “Unspecified defenseman” banged up

Per the Rangers Twitter feed, Derek Dorsett will be out tonight with a lingering wrist issue. Taylor Pyatt will return to the lineup in Dorsett’s place. Also, AV noted an unspecified defenseman is banged up and the defensemen will be a game time decision. We can speculate all we want, but we know it isn’t John Moore that is banged up, since AV confirmed he will return tonight...

New York Rangers do right thing by locking up Lundqvist

Rangers GM Glen Sather has taken a lot of flak over the years – and deservedly so – for handing out contracts both imprudent and lavish. He dipped deep into the team’s well again to extend goalie Henrik Lundqvist, but this time, Sather was justified. This was the right move. The only move, really. For the team can afford to pay Lundqvist $59 million over the next seven years...

New AV Squad episode tonight, some Cam Talbot and Alain Vigneault quotes

If you’ve been following the blog for a while, you know that we love the shows where the Rangers talk with the coaches to discuss the x’s and o’s of the game. We were big fans of “Behind the Bench” with John Tortorella, and we are equally fans of “The AV Squad” with Alain Vigneault. MSG was kind enough to provide us with some quotes from tonight’s all-new episode...

G Lundqvist, New York Rangers agree on contract extension

Goalie Henrik Lundqvist has agreed to a contract extension with the New York Rangers. The team did not announce terms of the deal Wednesday. The 31-year-old Lundqvist has been a Vezina Trophy finalist as the NHL's top goaltender in five of his eight seasons, winning the award in 2012. Lundqvist has a 284-182-57 career record with a 2.26 goals-against average, .920 save percentage...

Rangers trade Brandon Mashinter to Chicago for Kyle Beach

In a bit of a surprising move, the Rangers have traded forward Brandon Mashinter to the Chicago Blackhawks for forward Kyle Beach. Mashinter. In ten total games with the Rangers over two seasons, Mashinter was held off the score sheet with ten PIMS. With Hartford this year, Mash had a line of 1-6-7 in 11 games with 15 PIMs. Beach, currently with the Rockford Icedogs of the AHL, has...

Report: Henrik Lundqvist, Rangers Agree to Seven-Year, $59.5 Million Contract Extension

New York Rangers coach Alain Vigneault surprised some people recently when he gave two consecutive starts to backup goalie Cam Talbot over All-Star netminder Henrik Lundqvist. With Lundqvist struggling a bit lately, some even went as far as to wonder if there was a goaltending controversy brewing in Gotham.  So much for those thoughts. TSN’s Darren Dreger reported Wednesday morning...

So, what about Cam Talbot?

Scott Levy/Getty Images Now that all the hemming and hawing over Henrik Lundqvist’s contract situation has been completed, Cam Talbot’s future has been an oft-discussed topic.  Whatever you may think about the specific details of the contract, Hank is going to be manning the pipes at the Garden until 2020-2021. This brings us back to Talbot.  His emergence this season as a...

Lundqvist, Rangers agree on contract extension

 The New York Rangers and goaltender Henrik Lundqvist announced Wednesday that both sides agreed to a seven-year contract extension, with an annual average of $8.5 million. “Since his arrival in New York in 2005, Henrik has consistently been one of the elite goaltenders in the NHL,” said Rangers president and general manager Glen Sather in a statement. “He is a proud representative...

Rangers re-sign Henrik Lundqvist to contract you can probably twist into seeming reasonable or ...

So... there's still a goaltending controversy in New York, right?  Not so fast, said the New York Rangers on Wednesday, as they re-signed star goaltender Henrik Lundqvist to a massive 8-year, $59.5 million contract. The deal lasts through 2020-21, and King Henrik will make $8.5 million in AAV against the cap. And now we spend the rest of the day debating just how much the...

Rangers Sign G Henrik Lundqvist to Seven-Year $59.5M Extension

  The Associated Press is reporting that the New York Rangers and goaltender Henrik Lundqvist have come to an agreement on a lucractive contract extension that will make the Swede the highest-paid player at his position. Lundqvist, in the final season of a six-year, $41.25 million deal, agreed to a seven-year contract reportedly worth $59.5 million. His salary-cap charge would rise...

Henrik Lundqvist Signs Contract Extension

NEW YORK — The New York Rangers have a goalie for life. On Wednesday, goalie Henrik Lundqvist agreed to a seven-year, $59.5 million extension with the Rangers. Currently in his final year of a six-year, $41.25 million deal, he is set to become the highest paid goalie in the NHL beginning next season. ”There were […]

Henrik Lundqvists new shopping list

Henrik Lundqvist has recently signed an extension worth 8.5 million dollars a year to continue stopping pucks for the Rangers. What would such debonair a man do with that kind of change? Thats 55.2 million Swedish Kroners!  - A castle on the outskirts of Gothenberg. - Rent in Midtown for two months - A years supply of hair product - A closet full of skinny ties....
Rangers News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.