Hulu Sets Premiere for ‘Only Murders in the Building’ Season 5 – Here’s What’s Coming

Alright, murder mystery fans, it’s time to block off your fall TV calendar. Hulu just confirmed that Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building drops on September 9, 2025. And they’re not easing us in gently either: the season kicks off with a three-episode binge drop, then slides into its usual one-episode-a-week rhythm every Tuesday, leading up to the finale on October 28.

It’s a pretty bold move, but more on that in a bit.

For those who’ve been following this quirky whodunnit since Day One, Only Murders in the Building’s signature charm, witty writing, a touch of nostalgia, and the surprisingly perfect chemistry between Steve Martin, Martin Short, and Selena Gomez- hasn’t worn off. It looks like Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building is about to crank things up a notch.

Season 5 Opens With a Death and a Whole Lotta Drama

The new season kicks off with a punch: Lester, the longtime doorman of the Arconia, turns up dead, and not in a peaceful, natural way. For longtime fans, this one stings. Lester wasn’t just the guy who held the door open; he was part of the building’s soul.

Naturally, our amateur sleuths, Charles, Oliver, and Mabel, can’t resist diving headfirst into the mystery. But what starts as a simple case of “who did it?” spirals into something much bigger. Like, billionaires-behaving-badly and old-school mob ties are kind of bigger. And the deeper they dig, the messier it gets.

You’ll see the trio tested in ways we haven’t quite seen before. Not just as investigators, but as friends. There’s real danger this time around, and it might just rattle their little true crime podcast world.

A Grittier, Moodier New York

While most of the action still happens in and around the Arconia, this season steps outside more. We’re getting a broader view of New York, not just the glitzy skyline, but the cracks underneath. Think gentrification, disappearing neighborhoods, and the slow unraveling of community life. It’s still funny, sure, but it also feels a bit more grounded. Like the city itself is part of the mystery.

And of course, NYC being NYC, you’ll meet some colorful new characters, some shady, some fabulous, and some who’ll make you wonder if they’re hiding bodies in their brownstone basements.

The Gang’s Back (And Maybe Some Surprises Too)

Good news: the original trio is back, Gomez, Martin, and Short are all locked in for another round of delightful chaos. Michael Cyril Creighton is also returning (because what’s the Arconia without a little side character spice?), and you can bet there’ll be some surprise guest stars.

The show’s known for its cheeky cameos, remember Paul Rudd and Tina Fey? So don’t be shocked if another big name pops up to stir the pot.

This season also promises more character growth. Mabel’s figuring out her independence, Charles is still wrestling with career highs and lows, and Oliver… well, he’s probably falling in love and making it weird. Expect laughs, sure, but also a few gut-punch moments.

Hulu’s Three-Episode Strategy: Smart or Risky?

Let’s talk about Hulu’s release strategy here. Three episodes at once, then weekly drops. It’s like giving us a shot of espresso before easing us into a slow drip. It gets you hooked, then keeps you coming back, week after week, for more theories, more memes, and more “OMG, did that just happen?” moments.

It’s a move that says Hulu isn’t just trying to dump content and bounce. They want this to be a weekly conversation again. And honestly? With a mystery this juicy, that’s probably the way to go.

Why Season 5 Feels Like the Biggest One Yet

There’s something different about this season. Between a beloved character’s murder, a web of powerful enemies, and a darker tone, it feels like the stakes are higher. Emotionally, narratively, maybe even physically, for our trio. It’s still Only Murders, but it’s grown up a bit.

The themes are deeper, the risks feel real, and yet, somehow, it never loses that playful heartbeat that made people fall in love with it in the first place.

Final Thoughts: Get Ready to Hit “Play”

Whether you’ve been with the series since Episode 1 or you’re just here for the jokes and jump scares, Season 5 of Only Murders in the Building looks like it’s shaping up to be its most ambitious and emotional yet.

So yeah, grab your popcorn, fire up the group chat, and mark September 9 in big bold letters. Because this fall, the Arconia’s back in business, and murder is once again on the menu.