Found July 02, 2013 on
The rumors swirling around in recent days have Cubs right-handed reliever Carlos Marmol being dealt to the Dodgers for basically nothing. The once closer of the future for the Cubs is now 30 and struggling, but Bruce Levine of ESPN Chicago and Dylan Hernandez of the Los Angeles Times both say that a deal is in the works, seemingly in the advanced stages. The deal would essentially be to dump Marmol, as Ken Gurnick of points out. If LA gets Carlos Marmol, the Cubs would pay most, if not all, of $5M salary owed and might get back player recently removed from LA roster. If Marmol approves the deal, and he’ll need to since he has a no-trade clause to the Dodgers, it would probably be Marmol and cash for either Matt Guerrier or Luis Cruz. One team’s trash for another’s, basically. There doesn’t appear to be much downside to this, as he’ll make the league minimum, but opportunity cost and a roster spot can be valuable, as Brandon League, Guerrier, Cruz, and friends have been busy proving in 2013. So … is this adventure worth it? Well, it depends on whether one thinks Marmol is fixable or not. —– Carlos Marmol has always been a volatile reliever. As recently as 2010, he posted a 2.55 ERA and a 2.01 FIP, but his career numbers include a 3.55 ERA and 3.89 FIP over 542.1 IP. That includes his disastrous 2013, in which he has a 5.86 ERA and a 6.16 FIP, both of which are well below replacement level. It absolutely indicates a pitcher that isn’t worthy of rostering. When Marmol is right, he’s generally in the 93-96 MPH range, but in 2013 he’s down in the 91-94 area. That would be cause for concern, but over his last three appearances, he’s been in the 93-96 range again, averaging 94.8 MPH, which suggests that it’s not his arm strength or arm health that’s the problem. But I don’t think his velocity was ever truly a concern, as it’s been his command that was always problematic. Even at his best, he would walk batters at around his career rate of 15.5%, or almost twice as much as league average. To counteract that, he’s struckout batters at an amazing rate (29.8%) and controlled homers (0.75 HR/9), but all of these factors have trended in the wrong direction over the last few seasons for Marmol, culminating in this disastrous 2013 that would make Murphy’s Law proud. But still, why? —– Simply put, his release points are all over the place. Here are the ever-changing, month-by-month horizontal and vertical release points of Marmol from 2010 to now. *Click To Enlarge* *Click To Enlarge* Even excluding outliers, Marmol has a variation of 9-10 inches on his horizontal release points and 14-15 inches on his vertical release points. In pitching mechanics, inches matter. Heck, wrist positioning, grip, and feel for the ball off your fingers matter, so variation of literal feet is ridiculous. To put that in perspective, take a look at Mariano Rivera and the release point of his cutter. *Click To Enlarge* *Click To Enlarge* Over the same time-span, the release point of Rivera’s cutter has varied month-by-month two to three inches at most. Needless to say, Marmol’s command issues likely stem from his lack of ability to ever find a consistent release point. Generally that’s a mechanical issue, and one wonders if the Dodgers are taking a flier with Marmol because they think they can fix him, either in mop-up duty in the majors or if he’s willing to accept at minor-league assignment. —– But what could they fix, right? Everything. Marmol’s mechanics are not something I would wish on any kid. While there’s something to be said for the deception in his motion, it’s been more inefficient and hurtful to his career than otherwise. That said, I doubt the team is going to completely retool his mechanics, but they can make minor changes that would hopefully help him develop at least the consistency he found in 2010. The following are caps from 2010 and 2013, intended to compare what has changed: *Click To Enlarge* *Click To Enlarge* Right off the bat, we can see that his leg kick used to be shorter before, which ends up being important. *Click To Enlarge* *Click To Enlarge* As he breaks with his glove in 2013, you can see he’s on his backside and tilting upward. Whereas in 2010 his short initial leg kick seems to allow his momentum to continue forward, in 2013 his raised leg kick is the catalyst for him to use this awkward loading mechanism where he stops forward momentum to lean towards second base. *Click To Enlarge* *Click To Enlarge* Given that he’s on his heels in 2013 instead of driving forward like in 2010, it should be unsurprising that his posture has taken a significant step backward. *Click To Enlarge* *Click To Enlarge* At release, you can identify why his release point has slowly elevated over the years. His left shoulder is now diving away from the plate, and the increased tilt has the opposite effect on his throwing arm, which has flattened out. Most importantly, when you watch the video, he seems more in control of his violent mechanics in 2010. His command will likely never be even close to average, but there was intent in 2010 to locate and go after the hitter. In 2013, every pitch seems like an adventure in searching for a way to throw a strike. *Click To Enlarge* *Click To Enlarge* Oddly enough, the 2010 follow-through is the more violent one, but that’s actually better for him. Yes, it’s unbalanced and he falls off to the left severely, but that’s a product of his mechanics and his intent to throw hard. In 2013, he’ll frequently fight his own momentum and hold his finish like he’s balancing on the mound more than powering through. —– So those are potential fixes that perhaps the Dodgers and the coaching staff identified as fixable issues with Marmol, because I can’t see any other reason the team would take a flier on him. His issues are multiple and they are likely deeply ingrained, so I’m not sure how much confidence fans should have, if any, that he can right the ship with the Dodgers. That said, unless Don Mattingly throws him out there in high leverage situations, a fixed Marmol would fit perfectly with the seemingly new Dodger bullpen attitude of “we don’t know exactly where it’s going, but we’re gonna generate swings and misses”. It’s a refreshing take for a pen that’s been saddled with pitch-to-contract veterans. Is this a good idea? Who knows? Honestly, I’ve written all this and I still don’t know whether this is a good or bad idea, but I found the team’s interest in him alone worth investigating. If nothing else, it should make for an increasingly exciting pen, but I’ll gladly take boring and excellent if they want.

Dodgers finalize trade for Carlos Marmol, staff does think they can fix him

While I was sleeping yesterday (of course), the Dodgers did indeed finalize a trade with the Cubs for right-handed reliever Carlos Marmol, cash, and international bonus pool money for Matt Guerrier. I didn’t write about it immediately because I figured my article on why he might be of interest to the Dodgers was sufficient. Plus, the breakdown of the details was a bit confusing...

L.A. Kings Mascot Not Exactly a Fan Of Carlos Marmol

Word got out on Monday that the Dodgers were giving serious thought to bringing on Cubs’ reliever Carlos Marmol, who was designated for assignment just last week. Bailey The Lion, the Kings mascot, was one of the folks who heard the rumor and he took to Twitter to express his not so fond ideas on the potential move. Carlos Marmol… DON'T DO IT DODGERS — Bailey LA Kings...

Dodgers acquire Carlos Marmol from Cubs

The Los Angeles Dodgers have acquired relief pitcher Carlos Marmol from the Chicago Cubs. Reports of a trade between the two teams involving Marmol first surfaced on Monday. In addition to acquiring Marmol the Dodgers received cash considerations in the form of international signing bonus slot No. 92, which is valued at $209,700. Chicago will cover roughly $2 million of the nearly...

LA Kings mascot cautions Dodgers against Carlos Marmol trade

A report on Monday said the Los Angeles Dodgers were closing in on a trade for Carlos Marmol, whom the Chicago Cubs designated for assignment last week. Marmol has been pretty bad this season — and the last two for that matter — so many were wondering why the Dodgers would want him. He is [...]

Carlos Marmol designated for assignment by Dodgers

Well I hope Carlos Marmol enjoyed his time with the Dodgers. He was just acquired by the Dodgers in a trade and about 21 hours later, he is no longer a member of the club. The Dodgers, in a shocking move, designated Carlos Marmol for assignment, according to Peter Gammons of MLB Network. Turns out the Dodgers only wanted the Int'l cap $, as they designated Marmol for aassignment...

Carlos Marmol To Dodgers Almost Done

Whispers started floating around the internet yesterday afternoon centered around the Dodgers and Carlos Marmol. We heard that the boys in blue almost had a deal done with the Chicago Cubs to land the former closer. The Dodgers have struggled in the late innings this year due to the inconsistencies of Matt Guerrier, Peter Moylan, and Brandon League. As long as the price tag fits...

Dodgers Acquire Carlos Marmol for Matt Guerrier, Cash Considerations; Marmol to Minors

The Dodgers completed a somewhat controversial swap of DFA’d relief pitchers today, sending Matt Guerrier to the Chicago Cubs for Carlos Marmol and cash considerations. The Dodgers have acquired Carlos Marmol and cash considerations for Matt Guerrier. (Image source: at

Your Team’s New Trade Asset

For fans of Carlos Marmol, it’s been a confusing few days, even beyond the usual confusion baseline. On Tuesday, Marmol was shipped from the Cubs to the Dodgers. On Wednesday, there were initial reports the Dodgers were cutting ties, but now it’s clear they simply intend to send him to the minor leagues for a little while, in theory to get him “straightened out.” Marmol,...

Dodgers Swap Matt Guerrier for Carlos Marmol

Welcome to Los Angeles Carlos Marmol. It’s hard to get really excited about this trade, but there may be some hope for it. In a swap of relievers who had been designated for assignment, the Cubs announced they have acquired Matt Guerrier from the Dodgers for Carlos Marmol and Chicago’s fourth international signing bonus slot. That slot is worth $209,700 in pool money, announced...

Cubs trade Carlos Marmol to Dodgers

Yesterday I wrote that the Dodgers and Cubs were close to a deal involving Carlos Marmol. Today, it is complete. The Dodgers have acquired Carlos Marmol from the Cubs for Matt Guerrier, according to Jon Morosi of Fox Sports. The deal appeared imminent yesterday as the two sides were talking, but something must have delayed it. Now, the deal is done and the Dodgers have Carlos...

Los Angeles Dodgers Acquire Carlos Marmol from Chicago Cubs for Matt Guerrier

After a feverish day of rumors, the Los Angeles Dodgers did indeed pick up relief pitcher Carlos Marmol from the Chicago Cubs on Tuesday, in exchange for reliever Matt Guerrier. L.A. also receives the Cubs’ fourth international signing bonus slot. #Cubs today acquired RHP Matt Guerrier from the #Dodgers for RHP Carlos Marmol and Chicago’s fourth international signing bonus slot...

Dodgers acquire Carlos Marmol

The Los Angeles Dodgers have acquired Cubs reliever Carlos Marmol, according to Jim Bowden of ESPN. LA sends reliever Matt Guerrier in exchange for Marmol and around $209,000 of internation signing bonus money. Winners of eight of their last nine, the Dodgers remain in last but are now just 3.5 games behind the first-place Diamondbacks. The NL West is the tightest (read: worst) division...

Dodgers deal Guerrier to Cubs for Marmol

CHICAGO (AP) -- The Chicago Cubs acquired right-handed reliever Matt Guerrier from the Los Angeles Dodgers on Tuesday in exchange for former All-Star Carlos Marmol. Guerrier is 25-33 with six saves and a 3.54 ERA over 10 seasons in the major leagues. He went 2-3 with a 4.80 ERA this season before being designated for assignment on Sunday. The Cubs designated Marmol for assignment...

Chicago Cubs actually get something for Carlos Marmol! LOL at L.A. Dodgers

The Chicago Cubs today acquired pitcher Matt Guerrier from the LA Dodgers in exchange for local punchline Carlos Marmol. Yes, somebody actually gave up something for Carlos Marmol. I’m laughing as hard at the Dodgers as you are. Carlos Marmol was perhaps the worst closer ever in Cubs history; and this is a franchise with a history of bad closers. Los Angeles also acquired something...

Struggling Cubs Jettison Starter Scott Feldman to Orioles, Closer Carlos Marmol to Dodgers

CHICAGO — The Chicago Cubs dealt starting pitcher Scott Feldman to the Baltimore Orioles on Tuesday and traded former All-Star Carlos Marmol to the Los Angeles Dodgers in exchange for veteran reliever Matt Guerrier. The Cubs got right-handed pitchers Jake Arrieta and Pedro Strop as well as two international signing bonus slots from the Orioles in exchange for Feldman and catcher...
All Sports News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.