Found December 08, 2012 on Fox Sports:
Exactly what would the Mets get for R.A. Dickey? The question remains pertinent; the Mets are considering trading the National League Cy Young Award winner if they do not sign him to a contract extension. Mets chief operating officer Jeff Wilpon also has said the team might choose neither course, and simply carry Dickey into the final year of his contract. Such an outcome would buy time -- and it actually seems quite possible, considering the slow progress in both the contract and trade negotiations. The Mets are far apart on a two-year extension with Dickey, major league sources say. And teams interested in trading for Dickey say the Mets' asking price is high. Obviously, the Mets would have moved Dickey by now if they had received a suitable offer. But Dickey's trade value is indeed subject to debate. "Hard guy to evaluate," one rival GM said Saturday. Dickey is 38. He throws a knuckleball, which many baseball officials dismiss as a "trick pitch." And while his salary in 2013 is an absurdly modest $5 million, he is eligible for free agency at the end of the season. So, what is his true value in a trade? For the sake of discussion, let's consider two rumored trade possibilities; whether either actually has been discussed is unclear. Possibility No. 1: Dickey for Rangers infielder Mike Olt. For the Rangers, Dickey likely would become an option only if they failed to sign free-agent right-hander Zack Greinke. But even then, would they give up six years of Olt, a top offensive prospect, for one year of Dickey? Maybe, if they could sign Dickey to an extension. But that assumes the Rangers would be comfortable giving Dickey his desired terms, believed to be in the range of $25 million for two years. One rival executive says that if Dickey wants that kind of money, he should prove himself again next season, then go out on the open market. But any perception of Dickey as a one-year wonder is unfair; he's 39-28 with a 2.95 ERA over the past three seasons, averaging 205 2/3 innings. A two-year, $25 million extension, then, would amount to a three-year, $30 million investment -- a potential bargain, considering Dickey's recent level of performance and low risk of arm trouble as a knuckleballer. Olt, meanwhile, has no obvious spot with the Rangers. Third baseman Adrian Beltre is signed through 2015. First baseman Mitch Moreland, while not a star, is under control through '16. Using Olt at first or in the outfield would diminish his value, particularly with so many teams desperate to upgrade at third. In fact, the Mets might be better off flipping Olt if they acquired him, given that he is not going to displace David Wright. But that leads to another question -- just how much could the Rangers get for Olt? Other teams also like him, and perhaps the Rangers can include him in a package for a pitcher they regard even more highly than Dickey -- say, Rays right-hander James Shields. Which brings us to: Possibility No. 2: Dickey for Blue Jays catcher J.P. Arencibia and center fielder Anthony Gose. The Jays definitely would say "no" to this. They would be trading a combined 10 years of control over Arencibia and Gose -- both of whom play premium up-the-middle positions -- for one year of Dickey. Young players such as Gose and the Rangers' Olt not only are inexpensive, but also offer upside and the possibility of signing club-friendly extensions in the future. Arencibia, the veteran in the package, still is a year away from arbitration, and under club control through '16. Travis D'Arnaud, a top prospect, eventually will surpass him. But catcher is another position of scarcity -- and rising salaries -- increasing Arencibia's value. Here, perhaps, is a better idea: Dickey for Arencibia, straight up. The Jays obviously are trying to win; otherwise, they would not have made their blockbuster with the Marlins. And while Arencibia has averaged 21.5 homers the past two seasons, his career on-base percentage, in nearly 900 plate appearances, is .275. Come to think of it, the Mets almost certainly would want more than such a player for a Cy Young winner, which brings us back to something resembling the Arencibia-Gose package. See how difficult this is? Perhaps the Mets, who also are discussing Dickey with the Royals and other clubs, will find a deal that both sides consider fair. But I'm starting to think that all of the trade conversations might just be an exercise in futility. Better the Mets should sign Dickey to a below-market extension and enjoy what they have.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Mets Resume Negotiations With Dickey, Make Modest Progress On Extension Deal

Andy Martino of the Daily News is reporting that the Mets and R.A. Dickey have resumed negotiations and that they have made some modest progress on a contract extension since things cooled off at the Winter Meetings. I believe that the Mets and Dickey got locked into a game of chicken when they were in Nashville, with neither side willing to budge on the dollars of a two-year extension...

Looking More Like Dickey Stays A Met Without An Extension

Updated Post 11:00 AM Ken Davidoff sums it all up like this: As we leave R.A. Dickey’s hometown, let’s rank his list of admirers, from big fans down to skeptics. 1. R.A. Dickey 2. The New York Mets 3. The 29 other Major League Baseball teams. That’s where things appeared to stand as the Mets and the rest of baseball packed up their laptops, slide projectors and blazers and...

MLB Rumors: Will New York Mets Trade R.A. Dickey To Texas Rangers For Mike Olt?

The Texas Rangers drafted reigning National League Cy Young award winner R.A. Dickey back in the first round of the 1996 Amateur Draft. Dickey may have made his Major League Baseball debut with the Rangers back in 2001, but he gained notoriety and found success as a member of the New York Mets. Now, over six years since he last pitched for the Rangers, could Texas be making a play...

Dickey Wouldn’t Play Long Enough To See Mets Make It Back To Relevancy Anyway

I guess other teams must be wondering why any team would trade a reigning Cy Young Award winner, God knows I frequently ask myself that question. But here is what the the Dallas Morning News believes is the reason: In trying to find starting pitchers to plug into their rotation, the Rangers have been connected to reigning NL Cy Young winner (and former Ranger) R.A. Dickey in the...

There’s A Gap Between How Mets And Other Teams Value Dickey

There appears to be a gap between how the Mets value R.A. Dickey and how other teams value him. Hey, that’s how the game is played. Now, with Shields and Greinke gone, the Mets would appear to be in a stronger position. Mets general manager Sandy Alderson has asked for such a large package of prospects that some executives have wondered how serious he is about trading him. On the...

Mets Could Extend Dickey To Improve Their Elf-Image

Lending further to the accuracy of ESPN New York, reporting that R.A. Dickey is likely to remain a Met, the knuckleballer has agreed to play an elf alongside Ike Davis on Tuesday at Citi Field. John Franco will play Santa Clause at the team’s annual holiday party tomorrow at Citi Field, as the Mets host schoolchildren from Far Rockaway who were affected by Hurricane Sandy. Only...

Rangers Rumors: Renewed Focus on R.A. Dickey Likely

The Texas Rangers have not quite had the offseason they've envisioned.  They clearly want Justin Upton from the Arizona Diamondbacks, but that has yet to come to fruition.  They were considered the front-runners to land Zack Greinke, but he is signing with the Los Angeles Dodgers.  They've lost their all-time hits leader in Michael Young via trade to the Philadelphia...

R.A. Dickey May Pitch for Mets Without Contract Extension

It's easy to forget that R.A. Dickey is still under contract for the 2013 season.  That's because there have been so many rumors tied to him and so much discussion about the Mets working out a new deal for the knuckleballer.  However, New York does not necessarily need to worry about a new contract right now if they want him to pitch for them in 2013.  They already have...

Rangers Would Trade Olt For Dickey Id They Fail To Land Greinke

According to John Harper of the Daily News, the Texas Rangers would trade top hitting prospect Mike Olt for R.A. Dickey, but only if they first lose out on free-agent Zack Greinke AND are unable to trade for James Shields who is their top preference if they have to make a swap. Meanwhile the Royals and Blue Jays are not that interested in Dickey and and prefer the Mets young...

Rangers May Leave The Mets At The Altar Too…

Ken Davidoff of the New York Post points out that Zack Greinke’s bar-raising contract with the Dodgers hasn’t noticeably raised other clubs’ interest in R.A. Dickey. But that says more about how much the Mets want for their chatty knuckleballer than anything else. And it’s why the safe bet still calls for Dickey to at least start the 2013 season in a Mets uniform, he writes...

R.A. Dickey on The Daily Show

The Daily Show with Jon StewartGet More: Daily Show Full Episodes,Political Humor & Satire Blog,The Daily Show on Facebook

Mets Trades of the Past: Amazins’ Get Frank Viola

While we wait to see if the Mets trade R.A. Dickey and if so, what they get in return, I thought it would be interesting to look back at a trade where the Mets acquired the previous season’s A.L. Cy Young Award winner. Of course, we know R.A. Dickey is unique because of his age, his specialty pitch, and his back story, but all along I assumed if the Mets did trade him, they could...

NY Baseball Talk: Breaking the Norm 12/9/12

I was joined by former Kansas City Royals outfielder and current host on 810 WHB, Les Norman. Les and I discussed the wild spending this winter, the value of hitting coaches and the Mets potentially trading R.A. Dickey. Hear his thoughts on whether prospects like Wil Myers and Mike Olt are overrated, and the importance of mental makeup in a ballplayer. CLICK HERE TO LISTEN DOWNLOAD...

Rangers May Be Reluctant To Deal Olt After Trading Young To Phillies

The Dodgers’ reported deal with free agent righty Zack Greinke could have a ripple effect that impacts the trade market for the Mets’ R.A. Dickey, writes Anthony McCarron of the Daily News. With Greinke headed to Los Angeles — he reportedly agreed to a six-year deal worth $147 million Saturday night — the Texas Rangers, a spurned Greinke suitor, may become more aggressive...
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.