Found November 14, 2013 on Fox Sports:
An easy lesson -- every time you think you've seen everything in college football, you're wrong. TMZ reported Wednesday that Florida State redshirt freshman quarterback Jameis Winston is being investigated for sexual assault . 1. What do we know? Let's start with what we know because there are still many unknowns about this case. On Dec. 7, 2012 -- just over 11 months ago -- a police report was filed alleging that a female victim had been sexually assaulted in an apartment in Tallahassee, Fla. The alleged victim met with police early on the morning of the complaint. The victim, who the report says was drinking that night, said a sexual assault happened between 1:30 and 2 in the morning. During their investigation, the police took physical evidence and photos of the victim's injuries. We do not know what this evidence is at this point. The suspect was described as being between 5-9 and 5-11 and weighing 240 pounds with a muscular build. For the past 11 months, the Tallahassee police investigated the alleged sexual assault and thus far had undertaken no action, while leaving the case open. Jameis Winston, who was a freshman at FSU last year, has been identified as the suspect in the case by TMZ, but Winston's attorney denies any improper behavior by his client. Florida State issued a statement Wednesday night that said Winston's status with the team had not changed. Those are the facts as best they can be summarized. Now let's unpack these facts by examining some of the most common questions most of you would have. 2. Why is this story coming out now? Probably because the victim or her advocates are frustrated by the inaction on the part of the Tallahassee police department. It has been 11 months and nothing has happened. If you take Winston's attorney at his word , the quarterback hasn't been interviewed by authorities. An 11-month open investigation into a sexual assault charge is ludicrous no matter the side of the issue you're on, unfair to the victim or the individual who has been wrongfully accused. (I don't buy into the timing conspiracies here. If that was the case, why not leak this news the week of the Clemson game? Or the week before the season started? Or right before the BCS title game? I think the victim and her advocates are tired of waiting and became fearful that no action was going to happen, if ever, until the entire season was over). A case like this typically isn't that difficult to resolve -- there either is enough evidence to bring sexual assault charges or there isn't. Why is nothing being done one way or the other? Leaking the story to the media is a clear attempt to force the police department to finally take action and bring this case towards resolution. 3. What is Winston's actual story? According to his attorney, Winston hasn't been interviewed by authorities about these allegations. Again, how in the world is that possible? If Winston's attorney is being selective with his verb choice, he could be purposefully misleading here. Has Winston provided a written statement to authorities outlining his version of the night's events? That's probably the most likely outcome here. After all, if you found out you were accused of sexual assault and had nothing to do with it, wouldn't you want to immediately tell your side of the story? One of the safest ways to do that would be via a written statement. It doesn't allow any follow-up questions and your legal team can review your story in advance. Of course, Winston could have immediately lawyered up and refused to cooperate with authorities at all, but that seems unlikely since in that situation you're basically daring authorities to charge your client with a crime. So it's reasonable to assume that Winston has provided some version of his story to police. If he truly hasn't provided any story at all, then what have police been doing about these allegations for the past 11 months? 4. Keep in mind that sex crimes are among the most difficult to prosecute. Why has there been 11 months of inaction? The most likely explanation is that this case is somewhere in the middle ground between consensual sex and sexual assault. We like to believe that there's a clear delineation between appropriate and inappropriate sexual conduct. Often, it's much more murky than that. If Winston was 100-percent innocent, it's likely this case would have quickly been closed and it never would have gone public. If Winston was 100-percent guilty, he'd have already been charged with a crime. Here we have an 11-month investigation with no action undertaken. The uncertain truth is not surprising since generally sex crimes are "he-said, she-said" in nature. That is, a man and a woman are telling two different stories about what actually happened. Both can believe that they are completely in the right. And remember that the standard here is guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Your actions can be immoral without being illegal. So what happened that night? Chances are investigators aren't even certain. 5. Is it fair that sex accusations against anybody are made public before any charges are filed while victims are protected by law? Put simply, no. Let's assume for just a moment that Jameis Winston has done nothing wrong. You can't unring the bell of a sexual assault allegation. Once it goes public, your name is tarnished. If Jameis Winston is 100-percent innocent, then he's been wronged by this process. But I think the alleged victim believes a crime was committed against her -- by someone -- for a couple of reasons. First, keep in mind that making a demonstrably false accusation is liable under the law. That is, if you make false statements to the police, you've committed a crime. So it's not like a woman -- or man -- can use this shield as a weapon. Second, remember that sex crimes are dramatically underreported in this country. A woman is much more likely to keep quiet about sexual assault than she is to press charges. This woman contacted authorities within a couple of hours of an alleged sexual assault. The quicker you report a sexual assault crime, the more legitimacy you have with investigators and with physical examiners. Would this woman subject herself to intense questioning, physical examinations by strangers -- it's reasonable to assume she was treated by medical professionals that night to assess her well-being and examine her for signs of physical trauma -- if nothing at all happened to her? What happened to her might not be a crime, and Jameis Winston may not be involved at all, but it's reasonable to believe that she believes it. 6. But Florida State says Jameis Winston is 6-foot-4, 218 pounds and the police report says the suspect's 5-9 to 5-11 and 240 pounds. Easy there, Matlock. Please stop with these tweets and e-mails. It's amazing to me how eager fans are to believe that their own players are saints while their hated rivals are devils. The weight is reasonably close to Winston's listed weight and the height might only be off by a couple of inches. Is Winston actually 6-4 or is his height exaggerated, as is common with college athletes, and he's actually 6-2? If so, could you confuse a guy who is 5-11 with one who is 6-2? Uh, yeah. Even if the height is off by several inches, consider the difficult circumstances of a sexual assault. Was the suspect standing during the alleged sexual assault or laying down? Was it dark in the apartment? Had the victim been drinking? We don't know many of the circumstances surrounding this alleged sexual assault. There could be tons of reasons why the height doesn't match perfectly. My point, those of you incessantly tweeting about this are giving far too much weight to this bit of information. 7. How long has Florida State known about the investigation and that Winston was considered a suspect? Florida State's statement says nothing about when it became aware of this investigation, just that Winston remains eligible to play. So did Florida State find out this week like the rest of us? Or has the school known for awhile? Keep in mind that Ohio State suspended Carlos Hyde three games for allegedly striking a woman at a club before the season started. (No charges were filed in that case). Vanderbilt immediately suspended four players and kicked them out of school when they were merely investigated for sexual assault, before any charges had been filed in the case. How many Florida State administrators knew about this case? Did they conduct their own investigation or just accept their quarterback's word? If they conducted their own investigation, how did they do it? Was Winston treated differently by FSU because he was a five-star Heisman-caliber quarterback? Would they have let a kicker or a third-string defensive end keep playing? All of these questions just lead to bigger questions. If your star quarterback is being investigated for felony sexual assault, is the investigation itself enough to strip away the privilege of playing football on scholarship at a university? Can you play him while the investigation is ongoing even if you believe he's innocent? After all, how reliable can your investigation actually be? What if he gets charged with a crime the week before the BCS title game and you played him all season long knowing the charges might drop at any moment? On the other hand, what if he never gets charged with a crime and you punished him for a felony that never materialized? How do you handle a situation like this? 8. What happens next? You got me. Until there's a full release of the police's investigation into this sexual assault, Jameis Winston's future, Florida State's championship dreams, the Heisman Trophy, and, most importantly, a young woman's sexual assault allegations against a star quarterback and a powerful business enterprise, all hang in the balance. And maybe the most important lesson of all is this one -- can we please stop pretending that we know which athletes are good guys and which athletes are bad guys -- based on a few football games. Remember when getting paid for autographs seemed like a scandal? Welcome to college football. What a mess.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
AROUND THE WEB
RELATED ARTICLES

Heisman Watch: Ranking the contenders entering Week 12

Heisman Trophy campaigns may be fed in September when star players feast on less-than-impressive non-conference competition, but true contenders often don’t start to shine until conference play in October and November.  That was the case for last year’s winner, Texas A&M QB Johnny Manziel, and former Baylor star signal-caller Robert Griffin III in 2011. Photo Via BCSKnowHow...

Report: Jameis Winston being investigated for sexual assault

With the way Florida State is rolling, the last thing they need is legal trouble surrounding their most valuable player. Freshman quarterback Jameis Winston has taken the nation by storm, demolishing everything in his path and putting the Seminoles in position to contend for a BCS National Championship. On Wednesday, TMZ reported that Winston is […]

FSU QB Jameis Winston Would Be Ineligible To Play If Formally Charged

I’m not sure who fed TMZ the tip about Jameis Winston’s sexual assault allegations, but they are sure to have a lasting ramification on the BCS Championship race. According to section 5 of the Florida State University student conduct code, Winston would be banned from playing for the Seminoles if he’s charged with sexual misconduct. (5) Offenses. The following offenses, or...

Syracuse-Florida State: Keys to Seminole success

FSU quarterback Jameis Winston (left) and head coach Jimbo Fisher (right) close ACC play against Syracuse on Saturday. (USATSI) FSU looks to stay perfect in first ACC meeting with Orange One week after clinching a spot in the ACC Championship for the second straight year with a 59-3 thrashing of Wake Forest, second-ranked Florida State will return home for its ACC finale with Syracuse...

State Attorney Says He Doesn’t Expect Jameis Winston to Cooperate

It is Jameis Winston’s legal right to not cooperate and he has an attorney probably telling him not to say anything. I wouldn’t speculate about what that means, but if you listen to the State Attorney, there is obviously something about the case that warrants a fresh investigation. William Meggs, state attorney for Florida’s 2nd judicial circuit, told USA TODAY Sports he does...

Update: Florida State’s Associate AD Of Communication Issues Official Statement On Jameis Winston Alleged Sexual Assault Investigation

Update: The school’s Associate AD for Communication, Rob Wilson, has issued a statement. Per Perry Kostidakis of FS View: Official statement pic.twitter.com/SslCjCW5L6 — Perry Kostidakis (@perrykos) November 14, 2013 seminoles.com Earlier: Florida State quarterback Jameis Winston, who is expected to be a finalist for the Heisman Trophy this year, is being investigated as a...

Allegations shouldn't define Winston's Heisman standing

Let's be clear: We don't know enough right about the accusations surrounding Jameis Winston to make a decision, one way or the other. Wednesday, TMZ reported that the Florida State quarterback and Heisman Trophy frontrunner is being investigated for sexual battery, nearly year-old allegations that his attorney denies. No charges have been filed, and there is no change in...

Police report from Jameis Winston sexual assault investigation

A look at the redacted police report from a sexual assault investigation involving Florida State Seminoles quarterback Jameis Winston.

Lawyer: Witnesses can clear Winston

The attorney for Florida State quarterback Jameis Winston asserted Thursday evening that he has two witnesses who can provide information to authorities that would likely clear the Heisman Trophy front-runner in a December 2012 sexual assault. Attorney Tim Jansen told FOX Sports that the two witnesses - one of whom was interviewed Thursday and one of whom is scheduled to talk to...

Interview pending with accuser

Prosecutors are setting up an interview with the victim in the investigation of an alleged sexual assault tied to Florida State quarterback Jameis Winston that was reported nearly a year ago. State Attorney Willie Meggs says he expects to close the investigation in a few weeks. It's unclear why Tallahassee police did not give the case to prosecutors until this week. Meggs says...

Heisman front-runner, FSU QB Jameis Winston investigated for Sexual Assault

ESPN claims Jameis Winston will address the media tonight Florida State quarterback Jameis Winston, the leading candidate to win the Heisman trophy, is at the center of a sexual assault investigation. Yes, the same Jameis Winston who made waves this summer when he said he didn’t suffer from “Manziel Disease,” could very well be dealing with his own off-the-field incidents and...

Amidst Winston Allegations, Syracuse Must Stay Focused to Hang with Seminoles

  Photo via Knox News Follow The Fizz on Twitter for the latest SU football news The Jameis Winston sexual assault allegations have caused a media storm. The biggest question in this, aside from whether he actually did it or not, is how might it impact his play? Florida State is flirting with a national championship game and it routinely puts up more than 50 points per game...

Syracuse Travels to FSU: Three Things to Know

Things might be getting a bit tougher in Tallahassee these days.Not that the Florida State Seminoles are doing anything different then they have been all season long, but because the end of the year’s schedule is not an imposing one – which may force head coach Jimbo Fisher to keep his players focused on the prize in front of them.An ACC Championship awaits them in December and...

Game Day Goulash: Jameis Winston case, Von Miller on Johnny Manziel, Mack Brown on Nick Saban-to-Texas rumors, and more.

Game Day Goulash - Week 12 edition.The elephant in the room.Florida state attorney William Meggs says that a decision to proceed with criminal charges against Florida State starting quarterback Jameis Winston's involvement in an alleged sexual assault. (ESPN) Bruins beat Huskies.UCLA defeats Washington 41-31. (AP/Yahoo! Sports)Obligatory Johnny Manziel item of the day.Denver...

Aaron discusses all the big Week 12 story lines with WSCO Radio in Wisconsin

College football season may be coming to a close, but the chase for the crystal ball is just now heating up. And like I do every week, I joined my good friend Justin Hull of WSCO radio in Wisconsin to break it all down. Justin and I hit on a number of topics prior to the Week 12 (wait, is it really Week 12?) slate and you can click here for the audio. Here are a handful of the...
Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.