Found December 18, 2012 on ChadMoriyama.com:
Mlb_pittsburgh_pirates_c566
The Dodgers are shopping right fielder Andre Ethier, according to Mark Feinsand of the New York Daily News, and that could mean they’re in the hunt for Nick Swisher to serve as his replacement in right. Normally, this wouldn’t be enough to warrant a post, but Mike Petriello said he heard similar yesterday afternoon, so there appears to be legs to it. —– The news marks a surprising turn of events given that Ethier just signed a five-year extension for $85 million six months ago, but nothing regarding this team under the new ownership should be seen as truly surprising anymore. As far as his value goes, what is it? Not much, really, because with an AAV of $17 million a year, he’s already being paid above market value. However, in a vacuum, Ethier is a solidly above-average player, which would absolutely carry value if his contract was more reasonable. Thus, the assumption here would be that in order to get a return on him, the Dodgers would have to eat a significant portion of his contract, thus making him attractive to a potential suitor. Swisher ties into this drama because he’s basically the last option left for those that missed out on Josh Hamilton and friends, so it’s no surprise he’s drawing interest from the Red Sox, Phillies, Mariners, Rangers, and Orioles. However, that interest is probably also why Ethier is on the block, because Ethier is similar to Swisher, except two years younger. But why would the Dodgers be interested in replacing Ethier with Swisher? I’m not totally sure, because they’re basically the same player except Ethier is younger. Swisher has had a 125 OPS+ the past three years compared to Ethier’s 126, while their defense and baserunning are about pushes. The primarily difference in their lines is that Ethier has a severe platoon split (.913 RHP/.649 LHP), while Swisher doesn’t (.820 RHP/.842 LHP). While that does carry some value, at the end of the day, it’s the player’s total contribution to the team that matters, and they’re about the same in that aspect. Look, I certainly wasn’t a fan of the extension that Ethier was signed to, but certainly these potential deals couldn’t be in mind with the thought of saving money by signing Swisher and dealing Ethier, at least if the payroll situation is to be believed. As such, they’re about the better player, and from that perspective, I see little value in making this trade unless there’s significant return for Ethier. That, of course, is always a possibility, but I remain skeptical since I certainly wouldn’t do it as an opposing GM.
1 Comment:
  • Trading this guy breaks up the cohesiveness, such as it is, in the Dodger outfield. Unless they can get a top tier player, like Josh Hamilton, from the Halos, I think they will be better served to stop any rumor mill that could jeopardize the clubhouse confidence. They give him 5 years and 85 mill, and trade him in the same breath, not good for the rest of the team to think some has been like Swisher could out perform Dre.
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Are Dodgers shopping Andre Ethier?

The Los Angeles Dodgers appear capable of anything. Even a trade of right fielder Andre Ethier is not out of the question. The Dodgers are shopping Ethier, major-league sources say -- and their intent might be to clear a spot for a free agent such as first baseman/outfielder Nick Swisher or center fielder Michael Bourn. However, one official with knowledge of the Dodgers' thinking...

Report: Dodgers shopping Andre Ethier, which makes some sense

There have been whispers the Dodgers have been shopping Andre Ethier basically the entire winter. Today, those whispers got even louder. From Mark Feinsand of the New York Daily News (surprisingly enough): "Source: Dodgers shopping Andre Ethier. If they deal him, they could be in the mix for Nick Swisher." Mike Petriello said he also heard the team is shopping...

Dodgers Already Shopping Ethier?

The New York Daily News’ Mark Feinsand just tweeted that the Dodgers might be looking to move Andre Ethier, with a possible view to getting involved in the Nick Swisher sweepstakes. That’s the same Andre Ethier they signed to a five-year $85 million extension in June. The obvious caveat here is that this could well be part of the general winter chicanery that teams go through...

Nick Swisher will not visit Seattle, greeted by Tressel in Cleveland

Seattle was once considered a possible landing spot for free agent outfielder Nick Swisher. The two no longer seem to be a match as the 32-year-old will no longer meet with the Mariners this week. If Seattle were to sign Swisher they would forfeit the twelfth pick in the 2013 draft. Signing Michael Bourn would also cost the Mariners the draft pick. Seattle has been trying to find...

Rumor Roundup: Wednesday, December 19 by Daniel Rathman

Edwin Jackson might reach a decision soon, A.J. Pierzynski is making his rounds, and Andre Ethier could be on the market.

Swishalicious: The Nick Swisher Debacle

There have been rumors going around for weeks now that the Cleveland Indians are interested in acquiring the services of former Yankee outfielder Nick Swisher. The latest rumors say that Swisher has visited Cleveland and met with Chris Antonetti and was offered a deal worth more than $50 million for the next four seasons. After years of claiming poverty it is inexplicable where the...

Nick Swisher Visiting Cleveland Indians

Free agent outfielder Nick Swisher is touring the country like a rock star.  In almost every city he stops, he is being wooed and showered with promises.  Maybe it's more like a college recruiting trip than a rock show, but Swisher is definitely the rock star.  He is now visiting the Cleveland Indians as the team tries to land him. According to Paul Hoynes of the Cleveland...

Indians pull out stops for Nick Swisher

CLEVELAND (AP) -- The Indians called upon a proven recruiter to land free agent outfielder Nick Swisher. Former Ohio State coach Jim Tressel was among a group who had lunch on Tuesday at Progressive Field with Swisher, who is considering a multiyear contract offer from the Indians. Swisher would immediately fill a hole in right field for Cleveland, which traded Shin-Soo Choo to...

SF Giants Rumors: Swisher Rumor Is Fading In The Wind, Casilla Contract Details

For those of you that were hoping the San Francisco Giants would sign free agent outfielder Nick Swisher, it’s not going to happen. Henry Schulman of the San Francisco Chronicle says (via Twitter) Swisher’s employment tour will not run through the Giants front office.   In another tweet, Schulman breaks down Santiago Casilla‘s contract details. Casilla will get $4.5 million...

Sources: Indians in mix for Jackson

First baseman/outfielder Nick Swisher isn't the only significant free agent that the Cleveland Indians are pursuing. The Indians also are making a run at right-hander Edwin Jackson, but probably cannot sign both him and Swisher, according to major-league sources. The Cubs also are strongly in the mix for Jackson, who is expected to command a deal of at least four years, sources...

The Pitch To Swish

Mr. and Mrs. Nick Swisher, we cordially invite you to 24 hours of “this could be your life in Cleveland,” starring Mark Shapiro, Chris Antonetti, and Terry Francona. Special guests include your friend and former Ohio State Football coach Jim Tressel, current baseball coach at Ohio State Greg Beals, and Thad Matta, OSU head basketball coach and ace recruiter. On the menu: a...

While We’re Waiting… Swinging for the fence with Nick Swisher?

While We’re Waiting serves as the early morning gathering of WFNY-esque information for your viewing pleasure. Have something you think we should see? Send it to our tips email at tips@waitingfornextyear.com. “On Sunday, Weeden floated, overthrew, underthrew, threw behind and basically resembled an ugly conglomeration of the Ghosts of Browns’ Expansion Quarterback Past. On...

My Two Cents 12/14/2012

Steve and Connie Mack are back and they discuss the Philadelphia Phillies offseason moves including their disdain for brining Nick Swisher or Cody Ross to town. “Andy Reid” joins the show for a segment and they discuss the Philadelphia Eagles train wreck season and the future of the team. My Two Cents 12.14.12 Follow the Phillies, Eagles, Sixers, and Flyers at MTRphilly.com...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.