Found December 05, 2011 on Mets Fever:
First and foremost, allow me to commend the Mets' front office for not losing their collective minds and beating the six year, $106 million dollar offer that brought Jose Reyes to Miami. With that said, this is the first folly by Sandy Alderson and quite possibly one of the worst personnel decisions in team history. I am NOT upset that Jose Reyes left the organization as much as I'm upset that the Mets will receive a mere 3rd round draft pick in return.

This is not an issue of hindsight is 20/20. If the Mets didn't think another team would overpay for Jose's services this winter, they are more out of touch with reality than I have ever imagined. Therefore, if they weren't prepared to or weren't in a financial position to do that same, they should have traded Jose at the deadline.

Having come off the disabled list on July 19th, Jose Reyes entered the final week of July with a batting average over .340. The team as a whole was hovering around .500 and fighting to stay on the fringe of the wild card race. Anyone who thinks the team didn't move Reyes because of the wild card race is sorely mistaken. On July 26th the Mets traded Carlos Beltran, the teams best slugger at the time, to the San Francisco all but concedeing the season, as the Mets quickly faded as a result in the weeks that followed.

The next argument seems to be that Reyes was seen as a three month rental and nothing more. My response to that is that Carlos Beltran, a declining veteran with questionable knees who seems destined to land as a DH in the American League, returned the best pitching prospect in the Giant's farm system. Its foolish to think the Mets couldn't have garnered a similar bounty, if not more, for Reyes.

Instead the Mets will roll the dice with a third round draft pick, likely selecting a player who will take years to mature when and if he ever reaches the major league level. And yes, I understand that David Wright is the result of a similar pick, but lightning doesn't often strike twice, particularly in Flushing.

Finally, if you think the Mets didn't trade Reyes because of a fan mutiny, I really hope your wrong. Sandy Alderson was brought in to act as the adult in the room, as so many people have coined his role. That means he's here to make the tough decisions. The decisions necessary for the betterment of the team, regardless of what a fan base without foresight might think.

Losing Jose Reyes is not a franchise killer. The burden of guilt for his departure undoubtedly lands at the feet of the Wilpons, whose poor financial decisions have jeopardized the future of the franchise. However, Sandy Alderson and the rest of the organization's front office, who seem as intent as ever to rebuild the farm system, need to recognize these issues. A rare opportunity to acquire high level prospects or possible Major League caliber talent was wasted last July. That should NOT go unnoticed...

Follow me on Twitter @RobPatterson83
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

The Jose Reyes Debacle: Don’t Pee on My Leg and Tell Me It’s Raining

The Mets have allowed a homegrown superstar to leave in the prime of his career. It's one of the darkest days in the history of the franchise, and yet the rationalizing has begun:The Marlins overpaid for Reyes. So what? Big-market teams keep their superstars. Big-market teams laugh at the notion of the Marlins outbidding them. But the Mets are no longer functioning as a big...

Reyes to Miami Great Theatre, Lousy Baseball

Jose Reyes, the anticipated new shortstop for the Miami Marlins, is a very talented man. He is a formidable force offensively, despite not possessing a level of patience that you would hope for in a leadoff hitter, and though he commits too many errors for a tenured player his range and power arm allow him to influence games defensively to a sometimes dramatic degree. He is, then...

AP source: Reyes, Marlins agree at $106 million

Updates with details. Will be updated. By RONALD BLUM AP Sports Writer The suddenly splurging Miami Marlins landed their second big free agent in a matter of days, agreeing Sunday night to a $106 million, six-year contract with All-Star shortstop Jose Reyes, a person familiar with the negotiations told The Associated Press. After adding All-Star closer Heath Bell for $27 million...

Marlins Sign Jose Reyes

The Florida Miami Marlins have signed free agent shortstop Jose Reyes to a 6 year, $106MM deal according to MLB Trade Rumors. The deal includes an option for the seventh year with a $4MM buyout and does not include a no trade clause. The Marlins have really been the sole team in the Reyes market, even with the Mets saying they’d make a run at him. Really, can we start the pool...

Video: Sandy talks Reyes, Citi Field, fan reaction

In the video below, Sandy Alderson speaks with Kevin Burkhardt on SNY’s Mets Hot Stove about Jose Reyes, the fan response to his departure, Citi Field, and more: SNY’s Mets Hot Stove will air live from the Winter Meetings tonight at 6:30 PM ET.

Whatever happened to Reyes giving the Mets the final shot?

#bbpBox_143524575773335552 a { text-decoration:none; color:#0084B4; }#bbpBox_143524575773335552 a:hover { text-decoration:underline; }#Mets never even got fonal courtesy call, can confirm #Marlins Reyes done at 6-106M28 minutes ago via Twitter for BlackBerry®ReplyRetweetFavorite@Joelsherman1Joel Sherman Well this just makes me angry. You’d think Jose Reyes would give the Mets...

Marlins Sign Jose Reyes, It’s A Black Day For Mets Franchise

The Marlins and Jose Reyes ave agreed to a six-year, $110 million deal, according to a tweet from FOXSports.com’s Ken Rosenthal. ESPN.com’s Buster Olney is also reporting that the deal is done. Sandy Alderson spoke to the media tonight and said the following… According to Adam Rubin and Andy Martino, Sandy Alderson is addressing reporters and said that if the reported...

Bats: At $106 Million, Mets Were Wise to Pass on Reyes

Why the Mets may not miss Jose Reyes, and why the Marlins are taking a very big risk.

Easy Choice

I’d take a reported $106 million for six years, even if it meant having to become a Miami Marlin through 2017 to do so. If that was Jose Reyes’s choice — as opposed to nothing for no years, which is what the Mets apparently offered him — it was an easy choice. So congratulations to the New York Mets for not setting the market. That was important to them. Good luck setting...

Mets lose star player along with credibility

Dallas –- In the aftermath of Jose Reyes’ departure, the Mets have to do more than rebuild their roster. They have to rebuild their credibility. Sandy Alderson explained that the Mets never made an early offer to Reyes because he felt that would evoke the perception the organization was comfortable...

Sandy Alderson To Address Media At 10:30 PM Tonight

Here is a tweet from Andy Martino that many of us Met fans were hoping never to see: UPDATE FROM MARTINO:  It appears that Jose Reyes will soon leave the only team he has ever known. According to industry sources, the Mets are out on their homegrown shortstop, who will likely become a Miami Marlin. Sources said that the Mets were made aware that Miami upped its offer to Reyes from...

Reyes to bring new Miami "heat"

MLB's Winter Meetings won't even start until tomorrow morning here in Dallas/Fort Worth, but the first Big Splash has already been made down in Florida. As of now, arguably the two best shortstops in the National League now play for (former shortstop) Ozzie Guillen's re-monikered Miami MarlinsThe Marlins and former Met shortstop Jose Reyes agreed to terms on a six-year...

Could the Mets Have a New Bullpen at the End of the Week?

While a lot of the attention over the next few days will be rightfully on Jose Reyes, this could be a very busy few days for the Mets bullpen. MLB Trade Rumors is reporting there has already been a lot of activity with teams trying to go bargain hunting. Extrapolating that statement, bargain hunting a lot of times ends up in the pen, and that is an area the Mets need at least two...

The BP First Take: Monday, December 5 by Daniel Rathman

When Ken Rosenthal first reported on Sunday night that the Marlins had reached a six-year, $106 million deal with Jose Reyes, there were two immediate reactions. Most fans wondered whether it was an apt signing for Miami, while the Citi Field faithful were left dismayed by the loss of their favorite player. Only time will tell if Reyes's upside will make the signing worthwhile...

Mets Winter Meeting Buzz: Interested in Qualls, Izzy and Coffey

Now that the Mets have lost out on the Jose Reyes sweepstakes the big moves can begin, or not.  Sandy stated recently that he has 20-25 million to spend on talent to fill his open roster spots this off-season.  Part of that money goes to Pelfrey and Pagan who are up for arbitration, leaving approximately $15 million or so left over. The Mets have been fairly quiet so far.  They...
Mets News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.