Found November 10, 2011 on The Baseball Stance:

<span style="font-family: "Times","serif";">On Tuesday, Tim Brown of Yahoo!Sports, <span style="font-family: "Times","serif";">tweeted<span style="font-family: "Times","serif";"> the Philadelphia Phillies had come to an agreement withRyan Madson on a 4-year/$44 million contract with an option for a 5th year at $13million. Yesterday, Jon Heyman <span style="font-family: "Times","serif";">reported<span style="font-family: "Times","serif";"> via Twitter, the same 4-year deal but that the contract stillneeded approval from Phillies President and CEO David Montgomery. Ruben Amaro Jr.,the Phillies general manager certainly believed he had authority to offercontracts as he sees fit? Madson and his agent Scott Boras alsofelt this was the case. Ownership is showing otherwise.

<span style="font-family: "Times","serif";">The problem Phillies ownership mayhave with the deal is that there are two prominent and much more experiencedclosers on the market, Jonathan Papelbon and Heath Bell. Theirexperience, success and previous pay scale actually better fit the contract termsoffered to Madson. Ownership may be asking Amaro where discussions went withthese two players before they sign off on the Madson deal.

<span style="font-family: "Times","serif";">There is much debateover whether closers should be offered this sum of money and lengthycontracts. In my opinion, even Papelbon and Bell should not receivefour-year deals. Closers come and go. The fluctuation of the position is veryvolatile. We see it every year when a closer is hurt or under performing. On comes the next guyin line and he runs away with the role.

<span style="font-family: "Times","serif";">While I do not agree with the contractlength, let’s say that the dollar amount per season is representative of theirworth. How do the three players stack up against each other? The tables belowrepresent the last three seasons for each player.

Ryan Madson
Year Age ERA G SV IP WHIP HR/9 BB/9 SO/9 SO/BB 2009 28 3.26 79 10 77.1 1.228 0.8 2.6 9.1 3.55 2010 29 2.55 55 5 53.0 1.038 0.7 2.2 10.9 4.92 2011 30 2.37 62 32 60.2 1.154 0.3 2.4 9.2 3.88 9 Seasons 3.59 491 52 630.0 1.294 0.9 2.7 7.8 2.86Provided by View Original Table
Generated 11/10/2011.

Heath Bell
Year Age ERA G SV IP WHIP HR/9 BB/9 SO/9 SO/BB 2009 31 2.71 68 42 69.2 1.120 0.4 3.1 10.2 3.29 2010 32 1.93 67 47 70.0 1.200 0.1 3.6 11.1 3.07 2011 33 2.44 64 43 62.2 1.149 0.6 3.0 7.3 2.43 8 Seasons 3.06 435 134 482.0 1.197 0.6 3.0 9.2 3.07Provided by View Original Table
Generated 11/10/2011.
Jonathan Papelbon Year Age ERA G SV IP WHIP HR/9 BB/9 SO/9 SO/BB 2009 28 1.85 66 38 68.0 1.147 0.7 3.2 10.1 3.17 2010 29 3.90 65 37 67.0 1.269 0.9 3.8 10.2 2.71 2011 30 2.94 63 31 64.1 0.933 0.4 1.4 12.2 8.70 7 Seasons 2.33 396 219 429.1 1.018 0.6 2.4 10.7 4.43Provided by View Original Table
Generated 11/10/2011.
<span style="font-family: "Times","serif";">The number of saves is irrelevant. There are too many factors in play which determine the number of save chances aplayer receives. It is safe to say closers are expected to suppress or limitdamage when they enter the game. As such, the best closersstrike out a lot of hitters, exhibit very good control and do not allow homeruns. For the most part each of these players has shown this ability druing their careers.

<span style="font-family: "Times","serif";">The tables tell us a few things.Papelbon has the most experience closing games. Throughout his career Papelbonhas a far superior WHIP, allowed the least home runs allowed per nine and has the highest SO/9and SO/BB ratios. Papelbon maintains these numbers even with amajor hiccup season in 2010.

<span style="font-family: "Times","serif";">Further, the tables tell us thatsomething could be wrong with Bell based on his performance in 2011. His SO/9 ratio fell way off and he gave upmore home runs. Bell is also 33 years old. Madson, in his only season as afull-time closer had very respectable numbers, but at 30 years old won'tget better. He has thrown just over 200 more innings than Papelbon and 148 more than Bell.

<span style="font-family: "Times","serif";">The Phillies have created issues ifthey decide to change direction. They have already established they wouldgive a four-year contract to a player who has one year of closing experienceand more miles on his arm. Papelbon is going to want at least $12 million, ifnot $13.5 million or $14 million per season based on his 2011 salary. A smart GM would bringup the 2010 season as cautionary and possibly keep the salary on the lowerend of the scale. Bell would probably have to be satisfied with a similar deal offered toMadson considering his age and evident drop-off last season. Prior to the offer made to Madson, I don't think Bell would have gotten more than $10 million per season.

<span style="font-family: "Times","serif"; line-height: 115%; mso-ansi-language: EN-US; mso-bidi-language: AR-SA; mso-fareast-font-family: Calibri; mso-fareast-language: EN-US; mso-fareast-theme-font: minor-latin;">Amaro, in an effort to solidify a priority jumped the gun onMadson's deal in terms of salary and length. He could have offered Madsona three-year $27 million dollar deal. This would have almost doubledMadson's annual salary and shown faith in the player. Such a deal equates to $14 million less than the total Madson was offered, not including the option year. What if ownership believes Amaro's estimate on Madson is sound, butwould rather have Papelbon? They are looking at a $48-$56 million contract overthe same duration. Either way, the Phillies overpay and over commit. Sometimes it is best to let the market come to you versus create the market too quickly. Ruben Amaro Jr. may have learned that lesson the hard way.

Happy Madson’s Great Turnaround

“The game speeds up on Madson sometimes. He doesn’t get to the same comfort level. There’s a little anxiety in there. The ninth inning is a little different than the eighth. There’s been a lot of solid eighth-inning guys who just haven’t been able to pitch the ninth, then one day they learn how to do it. Ryan Madson is Ryan Madson. What did he do, take a crash course in...

Phillies Re-Sign Madson, But Overpay in the Process

On the heels of signing Jim Thome last Friday, the Philadelphia Phillies have made their second big move of the 2011 offseason, re-signing closer Ryan Madson. But the cost for Madson is already causing jeers for GM Ruben Amaro across the internet - four years for $44 million, with a $13 million option for the fifth year. The reaction on Twitter has been harsh, and it's been brutal...

Madson, Phillies talking multiyear deal

Ryan Madson is in serious discussions with the Phillies on a multiyear deal.

Papelbon Shipping Out to Philly

It has been reported, however not officially confirmed that Papelbon has reached a deal with the Philadelphia Phillies.  The Phillies were on the verge of signing Ryan Madson for 4 yrs/44 million when word came that the deal fell threw.  Suddenly the Phillies were talking with Papelbon again and then word came through twitter this afternoon that Pap and the Phils came to a deal...

Phils near deal with Madson, meet with Cuddyer's Jim Duquette first reported Tuesday night that the Phillies are working on a four-year, $44 million contract with closer Ryan Madson.

Who Will Be the Red Sox’ Closer in 2012?

It's open season for free agents, but thus far, no closer has signed a deal to set the market. Ryan Madson in the Phillies appeared close to a massive four-year, $44 million deal this week, though reports later indicated that those talks had stalled. If that deal were to be made, it may have been a bad sign for the Red Sox if they wanted to retain Jonathan Papelbon, who has more...

Would You Rather...? (Free Agent Closers)

The reported contract between Ryan Madson and the Phillies is currently held up for a myriad of reasons. Since there is pause in the signing, I'd like to look at the crop of free agent closers and the speculative pricetag for each.*Age listed for upcoming 2012 season.#:# = BB:K, #/# = ERA/WHIP, % = Save PercentagePast 3 Seasons:Jonathan Papelbon (31) 4 yr/$50 - 194 G, 199.1 IP...

Report: Phillies May Remain Interested in Jonathan Papelbon as Ryan Madson Deal Hangs in Limbo

Ryan Madson might not be returning to the Phillies after all. The reported $44 million, four-year deal the closer signed with the team still has not been approved by team executive David Montgomery, according to Sports Illustrated. Phillies general manager Ruben Amaro and agent Scott Boras reportedly reached a deal on Monday, but have been waiting to hear back from Montgomery for...

Moment of truth for Papelbon, Red Sox

No matter what happens between Ryan Madson and the Phillies, the fallout will be felt all the way to Fenway, where the Red Sox will suddenly have to ask a hard question: is Jonathan Papelbon worth keeping at, say, $14 million a year? The likelihood is that ownership says yes, especially since Papelbon is coming off his best season, is very much in his prime (age 31) and his reputation...

Did the Phillies Make the Right Choice with Papelbon?

After all the chaos that unfolded this week for the Philadelphia Phillies, first agreeing but not agreeing with Ryan Madson, and then signing Jonathan Papelbon, there was a general consensus opinion online among Phillies fans and non-Phillies fans alike: that the team would have overpaid for either player. There are just as many critics of the Papelbon deal as there were for the...

Papelbon Signs With Philly

Earlier in the week it was reported on MLB Trade Rumors that the Phillies talks with their now former closer, Ryan Madson, fell through and that they were interested in the former Red Sock. For the Sox, who obviously didn't feel like Papelbon was worth the money will now either hand the job over to Daniel Bard or look to sign one of the available closers. That list includes...

CSNPhilly: Papelbon agrees to deal with Phillies

I was just putting together a Pulitzer-winning post on Ryan Madson's ongoing odyssey with the Phillies when the news came down that Jonathan Papelbon has agreed to a deal with Philadelphia. Jim Salisbury of CSNPhilly reported the deal first, though he hasn't mentioned contract numbers. Earlier today, ESPN's Jayson Stark wrote about how the Phillies appeared to push more...

Closing In

The Philadelphia Phillies have found their closer, and appear to be a physical away from making the deal official, according to's Jim Salisbury. On Friday afternoon, news broke that the Phillies have reached an agreement with free agent closing pitcher Jonathan Papelbon that will pay the right-hander nearly $50 million over four years. The deal all by slams the...
MLB News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.