Found May 09, 2012 on Mets Fever:
When SNY's cameras pan to Daniel Murphy in the dugout of a closely contested game, you'll see it all out on his sleeve. Each strike thrown to a batter is met with a look of concern, while each base hit is greeted with applause and an enthusiastic reaction. Just as he lives and dies with each pitch, Murphy is often the first on the field after a walk-off and the first to believe that the team is going to reach its full potential. It's this type of energy that has made Murphy a fan favorite in Flushing despite his reputation as a sub-par defender, whether the reputation is fair or not.

Which raises the question: Why would the Mets consider the 27-year old as trade bait?

Murphy, at 27, will be arbitration eligible for the first time in 2013 and is under team control through 2016, his age 31 season. Playing at a position where offense is hard to come by, Murphy is a perennial .300 hitter and has the stamina to play 150+ games a year. Murphy's "Gamer" style of play will resonate with any fan-base and he is only continuing to realize his true potential. While he won't hit 15-home runs in a season, his line drive power and ability to work a count are invaluable to a team.

It's for all these reasons that Murphy is a valuable commodity, yet at least part of the fan base believes that Murphy should become trade bait for a starting pitcher later in the season with the continued development of Jordanny Valdespin. Valdespin, 24, is a superior defender and has more potential power in his bat, but with only 10 big league plate appearances it's hard to argue that he's the answer to replace Murphy. He may hit 17-home runs in the big leagues as he did in the minors in 2011, but that's not a guarantee his first year in the big leagues. His average and OBP are also considerably less than what Murphy can contribute.

Trading Daniel Murphy for a starting pitcher to contend this year would be a foolish move on Sandy Alderson's part and would go against the precedent he set when he inked Jonathon Niese to a five year extension early this spring: Work hard and you'll be guaranteed a spot on the team for the foreseeable future and will be compensated accordingly. In addition to going against Alderson's precedent, trading Murphy for a starting pitcher creates a depth problem. Assume that Ruben Tejada or Valdespin have injuries, would Ronny Cedeno or Justin Turner really pique someone's interest as a starting player for a prolonged period of time?

Murphy isn't the perfect player. His defense, while improving, will still cause many to pull their hair out in frustration. The thing about Murphy, though, is that he's the heart and soul of this club. David Wright plays the role of the seasoned veteran and longest tenured Met while possessing a calm, cons ice attitude. Murphy, meanwhile, displays the type of emotion that helps to rally both a team and a fan base that's an essentially element to any successful team.

Daniel Murphy could very well be trade bait. For all of the reasons listed above, it's hard to see why a team wouldn't want a player of his caliber starting somewhere (Even DH). However, Murphy shouldn't be trade bait.

What do you think? Is Daniel Murphy going to be traded this season, or are people overreacting?
THE BACKYARD
BEST OF MAXIM
RELATED ARTICLES

Jenrry Mejia Solid In His First Game Back

Jenrry Mejia pitched solidly today for St. Lucie as they beat Brevard County by the score of 4-2. The Mets’ one-time top prospect tossed five innings and allowed just two runs on four hits and two walks with one strikeout. Mejia’s fastball ranged between 91-95 mph, but more importantly he felt good afterward in what was his first major hurdle toward his return to the majors...

Rookie Jordany Valdespin Belts A Pinch Hit Home Run In Mets 5-2 Comeback Win

Rookie Jordany Valdespin delivers a pinch hit three-run homer to put the Mets up 5-3. Recap Jon Niese had himself another good start despite only going five innings and being plagued with four walks. He gave up two runs in the first two innings, but was able to throw zeroes until he was taken out for a pinch hitter. Niese needs to stay in the game. He goes five innings, allowing...

Binghamton Buzz: Marte Keeps Raking, Wheeler Says He’ll Make Next Start

Ramblings from Henry and Fayette Streets The Week That Was: April 30th – May 7th The B-Mets went 2-5 over the past week, losing both their series in Akron against the Aeros and at home against the Harrisburg Senators.  Three of the five games they lost were only by one run.  The Mets fell below .500 and slid in the standings from third to fourth place.  The big news on the...

Is Wilmer Flores Finally Starting To Put It Together?

I know it’s early, but the promising start to the 2012 campaign for Mets former top prospect Wilmer Flores is extremely encouraging.  He was ranked at the top of the organization in recent years due to his hitting ability and future potential, but did not live up to the hype on the field. So far this season he is showing that maybe all that talk of him being a big time hitter...

Mets put C Thole on 7-day DL with concussion

The New York Mets have put catcher Josh Thole on the seven-day disabled list because of a concussion. The Mets made the move before Tuesday night's game at Philadelphia and promoted catcher Rob Johnson from Triple-A Buffalo. Thole was elbowed in the head by Ty Wigginton of the Phillies during a play at the plate in the Mets' 5-2 win Monday night. Thole had returned to...

Mets come from behind again, defeat Phillies 7-4

Miguel Batista did little to solve the problem that is Mike Pelfrey’s absence from the rotation, but the Mets overcame a slow start tonight to defeat the Phillies once again 7-4. Trailing 4-1 entering the seventh, New York got to work when last night’s hero Jordany Valdespin got on base with a lead-off walk against Phillies starter Joe Blanton. However, Blanton would get catcher...

Mets' record is healthy despite injury bug

The Mets are playing these days without their starting shortstop, Ruben Tejada, who is sidelined because of a strained right groin. They also are playing without their starting catcher, Josh Thole, who has a concussion. They are playing without their starting left fielder, Jason Bay, who is recovering from a fractured left rib. And they are playing without one of their starting...

Ask Petey: What Will The Mets Look Like In 2017?

What am I doing here, on a grimy pier in lower Manhattan at 5 am? That’s a very good question. Just because I get a cryptic message from someone claiming to be JetsMets13, who says he has proof that a renegade Mets blog is conspiring to sell Mets secrets on the black market. The guy says this “rogue Mets blogger is huge”, and that everybody knows him, and that it could be me...

Good News, Bad News

Good News, Bad News. Mets bounce back after The Houston hell trip and take 2 out of 3 from the D'backs on the brief homestand. With another great start Dickey goes 4-1 on the season. That's good news...the bad, Ruben Tejada took a soil sample with his face when strained his quad. Check out the link below for a full game recap. Happy Sunday Blobbers! http://www.metsblog.com/2012/05/06/

Pre Game: New York Mets (16-13) at Philadelphia Phillies (14-16)

Following Monday night’s thrilling win, set off by the three-run bomb by #TeamValdespin, the Mets send Miguel Batista to the mound this evening looking to take the series and extend their winning streak to four games. Pray for Rain. When a team goes into a game on a losing streak, it’s said they’re looking for their start to be a stopper. I anticipate Batista to have the opposite...

TERRY COLLINS ON TONIGHT’S VICTORY

Mets 7 – Phillies 4TERRY COLLINS ON TONIGHT’S VICTORY“Let me tell you something…tonight’s game was a good win. A good victory for the team, for the guys and for me. The young guys learned that they can comeback at anytime and win a ball game. And that’s huge, huge. You play 9 innings for a reason and my guys did just that and I’m proud of them. For me tonight’s game...

The New York Minayas?

I don’t know if you noticed (how could you not?) but it seems like every time a young player does something positive, we see discussions here, and even on WFAN yesterday regarding which GM brought that player to the Mets. First, as I’ve said here I think Minaya did a better job than most give him credit for. Second, let us please stop pretending that Alderson has been here for...

Mets come from behind again, top Phillies for fourth straight win

PHILADELPHIA -- The New York Mets, who have made a habit of late-inning heroics so far this season, struck again Tuesday night, scoring all of their runs in the last three frames to beat the last-place Philadelphia Phillies 7-4. The Mets (17-13), who erased a 4-0 deficit, won their fourth straight game and came from behind to earn a victory for the 10th time this season. On Monday...

Gameday: Mets (16-13) vs. Phillies (14-16)

New York Mets (16-13) at Philadelphia Phillies (14-16) Miguel Batista (0-1, 6.92) vs. Joe Blanton (3-3, 2.83)Time: 7:05 Citizens Bank Park TV: CSN Weather: Showers, 63 Media: Twitter and FacebookMike Rizzo was fined. So that’s fun.As for tonight’s game, Carlos Ruiz moves up to the 5-spot in the order. He has been  their most consistent – and most awesome – offensive...
Mets News
Delivered to your inbox
You'll also receive Yardbarker's daily Top 10, featuring the best sports stories from around the web. Customize your newsletter to get articles on your favorite sports and teams. And the best part? It's free!

Today's Best Stuff
For Bloggers

Join the Yardbarker Network for more promotion, traffic, and money.

Company Info
Help
What is Yardbarker?

Yardbarker is the largest network of sports blogs and pro athlete blogs on the web. This site is the hub of the Yardbarker Network, where our editors and algorithms curate the best sports content from our network and beyond.